Tools
Change country:

Trump wants to use the military for mass deportations. Can he actually do that?

Posters that say mass deportation now
Delegates hold “Mass Deportations Now” campaign signs during the Republican National Convention at the Fiserv Forum in Milwaukee, Wisconsin, on Wednesday, July 17, 2024.

President-elect Donald Trump said he will use the military to carry out mass deportations — the centerpiece of his immigration agenda in his second term. He has not gone into detail about his plans, but legal experts have suggested he may be able to rely on a combination of federal laws to implement the deportations with the military’s help. The notion of the president deploying the military domestically may seem like a nightmare scenario, but it’s not implausible given his broad executive powers.

On Monday, Trump responded to a post on his social media network Truth Social, claiming that he would “declare a national emergency and will use military assets” to carry out mass deportations, saying it was “TRUE!!!

It’s not immediately clear what he means by that: whether he intends for the military to enforce the nation’s immigration laws, for military funds to be redirected toward supporting mass deportations, or something else. A representative for his transition team did not respond to a request for comment.

But Trump has a few avenues through which he could activate the military and its resources. Those include the Insurrection Act, which gives the president the power to deploy the military domestically; emergency powers, like redirecting funds to military construction projects; and other presidential powers like requesting national guard assistance in carrying out military missions.

Immigration advocates are readying to challenge mass deportations. Anthony D. Romero, executive director of the American Civil Liberties Union, said Monday after Trump’s announcement that his organization is preparing for litigation.

However, the law does give presidents significant leeway to use the military at their discretion, and courts have historically been wary of overstepping, though they may intervene if the civil liberties of immigrants are being violated.

The United States has “a very permissive legal regime regarding how the president can use the military,” said Chris Mirasola, a professor at the University of Houston Law Center. Again, those powers aren’t absolute, however. “There are downstream implementation matters that I think are more susceptible to litigation,” Mirasola said.

The Insurrection Act, briefly explained

According to the New York Times, Trump is planning to invoke the Insurrection Act to bring in the military to carry out mass deportations. The law is a key exception to the Posse Comitatus Act, which prohibits the use of the military to enforce federal law without the permission of Congress or the Constitution. 

Only in rare instances have presidents invoked the Insurrection Act. President George H.W. Bush was the last one to do so amid the 1992 Los Angeles riots that broke out in response to the acquittal of police officers in the beating of Rodney King. President Dwight D. Eisenhower also notably used the Insurrection Act to facilitate the desegregation of schools in Little Rock, Arkansas.

The provision of the Insurrection Act most likely to apply in Trump’s case is one that allows the president to unilaterally activate the military domestically to enforce federal law whenever they determine that “unlawful obstructions, combinations, or assemblages, or rebellion… make it impracticable [to do so] by the ordinary course of judicial proceedings.”

Mirasola said Trump would have a “relatively easy time” making the case that cartels trafficking immigrants across the border constitute an “unlawful obstruction” to the enforcement of US immigration law. Trump has in some ways appeared to begin building his case for invoking the Insurrection Act through his rhetoric on the campaign trail this year by describing an “invasion of criminals” coming across the border.

But Mirasola said it would be harder for Trump to argue that it is impracticable to enforce immigration laws through the “ordinary course of judicial proceedings.” That’s because presidents have done so for decades, and border crossings are no longer unusually high: They have sharply declined this year and are down even from certain points in the first Trump administration.

However, the law gives the president “sole discretion, in most instances” to determine whether the criteria necessary to activate the military have been met, according to 2022 congressional testimony given by Elizabeth Goitein, co-director of the liberty and national security program at the Brennan Center for Justice, and Joseph Nunn, the Center’s counsel in the national security program.

Goitein and Nunn also argued that the “vague and broad criteria for invoking the Act, combined with the lack of any provision for judicial or congressional review, render it ripe for abuse.” At that point, their concern was that Trump could have used the Insurrection Act to interfere with the certification of the 2020 election results. The use case is now different, but the potential for overreach is the same.

That is to say, while advocates may challenge Trump on whether the two key criteria for invoking the law have been met, the law gives presidents a wide berth — and the courts little power.

“For all practical purposes, courts have been cut out of the process,” Goitein and Nunn write.

The president’s emergency and other powers

There are other potential authorities that Trump could invoke to surge military resources to his mass deportation plan.

As Mirasola writes in Lawfare, Trump has a nonemergency power under federal law to request the assistance of state national guards in a federal military mission. Under the National Defense Authorization Act, that mission can be to assist US Customs and Border Protection in “ongoing efforts to secure the southern land border.” The law does not provide parameters limiting the kind of assistance that the military can provide, be that boots on the ground at the border or intelligence analysis support.

Emergency powers could be helpful in creating the infrastructure needed for mass deportations. Stephen Miller, one of Trump’s key immigration advisers, told the New York Times in November 2023 that a second Trump administration would construct “vast holding facilities that would function as staging centers” for immigrants facing deportation. Mirasola writes that, to do so, Trump could invoke federal law allowing the secretary of defense to “undertake military construction projects … not otherwise authorized by law that are necessary to support” the armed forces in a national emergency. 

If Trump declares a national emergency with respect to immigration, that law would essentially allow him to bypass the need for congressional approval to get the funds he needs to construct these holding facilities. He previously used the same law to try to get funding for his border wall during his first term. Whether he could do so was never settled. 

Pro-immigration advocates challenged the use of that law to fund the border wall in Trump’s first term. Their years-long litigation over the border wall became moot when President Joe Biden took office, but they were not expected to win if the issue had come before the Supreme Court. Advocates could again mount a legal challenge, but they may only succeed in delaying the construction of the facilities.

However, pro-immigration advocates might have a stronger case if they file lawsuits over the conditions in these yet-to-be built holding facilities and over potential violations of civil liberties for immigrants subject to mass deportations. Those might involve, for example, violations of their constitutional right to due process. That sort of challenge, over inhumane detention conditions previously seen in CBP facilities (including a lack of access to basic hygiene products and a lack of food, water, and basic medical care) was successfully made during the first Trump administration. 

Immigrants might also file suits arguing their constitutional protections against unlawful searches were violated: Doris Meissner, senior fellow and director of the US Immigration Policy Program at the Migration Policy Institute, said mass deportations of the scale Trump is imagining would likely involve “violations of people’s civil rights, profiling, all of those kinds of harms that poor policing brings about.” 

That will present a key test for the courts, Michael Waldman, president and CEO of the Brennan Center for Justice at NYU School of Law, said in a statement: “Will [the courts] use their power to enforce long-standing protections for individuals? Will they uphold the rule of law? Or will they bow to political pressure and allow the executive to expand its already ample power?”


Read full article on: vox.com
Texas man convicted after saying he mutilated victims, ate human heart as part of 'ritualistic sacrifices'
A Texas man was convicted of killing three people, dismembering them and burning their bodies after admitting to investigators that the killings were part of "sacrifices."
foxnews.com
Soros-backed prosecutor under fire over death penalty decision for Laken Riley's killer
Politicians and pundits from Georgia and across the country have expressed frustration that Laken Riley's killer, Jose Ibarra, was not sentenced to death.
foxnews.com
Valerie Bertinelli marks two years of ‘freedom’ since Tom Vitale divorce: ‘I didn’t deserve to tolerate the intolerable’
The Food Network alum, 64, took to social media Friday to share a hopeful message with fans, saying life "does get better" eventually.
nypost.com
First bird flu case in a child in the US confirmed by CDC in California
The US The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention confirmed the country's first H5N1 bird flu infection in a child.
1 h
nypost.com
Upstate New York blasted by winter storm, rain as major airports face travel delays
As Thanksgiving travelers hit the road, a potent early-season snowstorm over the Northeast caused travel delays and disruptions. 
1 h
nypost.com
Texas lawmaker proposes bill to abolish death penalty in Lone Star State: 'I think sentiment is changing'
A Texas state lawmaker has introduced legislation to abolish the death penalty in the state amid a high-profile case in the state that has received national attention.
2 h
foxnews.com
High school football: City and Southern Section semifinal playoff scores
CIF City Section and Southern Section semifinal playoff scores.
2 h
latimes.com
Officer kills ‘loveable’ pet dog mistaken for a coyote, owner left fuming over unnecessary death
The animal control officer went into the woods to look for the coyote and found what they thought was the animal in a threatening position and shot it.
3 h
nypost.com
NATO and Ukraine to hold emergency talks after Russia's attack with new missile
NATO and Ukraine will hold emergency talks Tuesday after Russia attacked the city of Dnipro with an experimental, hypersonic ballistic missile that escalated the nearly 33-month-old war.
3 h
npr.org
Mater Dei cruises past Centennial to set up rematch with St. John Bosco
The Monarchs make life miserable for Husan Longstreet and the Huskies in another rout on the way to the Southern Section Division 1 title game.
3 h
latimes.com
Narbonne ends Birmingham's City Section winning streak to reach Open Division final
Narbonne dominates Birmingham in a 27-7 City Section Open Division semifinal victory to set up a showdown with rival San Pedro for the title.
3 h
latimes.com
Thief who stole gold-plated 9/11 memorial rose from NYC church turned in by father: sources
The heartless crook accused of stealing a gold-plated rose from a 9/11 memorial at a Midtown Catholic church was arrested Friday for the unholy crime, according to the NYPD.
3 h
nypost.com
Clippers beat Kings for fourth win in a row and first NBA Cup victory
In need of a win to stay relevant for the in-season tournament, the Clippers only commit 12 turnovers and clamp down on defense to earn the win.
4 h
latimes.com
St. John’s fans have Zuby Ejiofor’s back after big free-throw misses: ‘Warm inside’
A day after Zuby Ejiofor’s two missed free throws in the final seconds contributed to St. John’s loss to Baylor, the Red Storm fans had his back. 
4 h
nypost.com
Joe Rogan explains why liberal media ‘hemorrhaging’ audiences: ‘You’re not accurate, you’re delusional’
Podcaster Joe Rogan dunked on left-wing media for losing viewers as many Americans have grown distrustful and wary of their bias.
4 h
nypost.com
St. John’s proves it has talent — and resiliency — to hang with anyone
On Thursday night, St. John’s showed its potential. A night later, it displayed its toughness. 
4 h
nypost.com
GOP lawmaker plans to introduce bill that would abolish the ATF: ‘Disaster agency’ 
The ATF, which falls under the umbrella of the Justice Department, regulates firearms and explosives and has the authority to enforce federal criminal laws and create new rules related to guns. 
4 h
nypost.com
Storm lashes Northern California after leaving thousands without power in Seattle
The storm arrived in the Pacific Northwest earlier this week, killing two people and knocking out power to hundreds of thousands, mostly in the Seattle area, before moving through Northern California.
4 h
npr.org
Donald Trump Announces Flurry of New Appointments: Full List
Donald Trump capped off a busy week with a slew of new appointments on Friday, including several major positions in his cabinet.
4 h
newsweek.com
Aday Mara makes oversized contribution in UCLA's win over Cal State Fullerton
Aday Mara puts his size and energy to good use, finishing with 10 points and five rebounds off the bench to help lead UCLA to an 80-47 victory.
4 h
latimes.com
Fantasy football: Knowledge and research trumps ready-made projection systems
Every week we continue to see fantasy managers mistakenly evaluate their team and make lineup calls based solely off their host website’s projections.
4 h
nypost.com
Chicago lottery winner scores $650K using numbers honoring his late wife: ‘It felt like a message from her’
"When I won, it felt like it was a message from her."
4 h
nypost.com
DC brothers freed after wrongful murder convictions seek presidential pardon
Two Washington, D.C., brothers who spent decades in prison after being wrongfully convicted of a 1984 murder before they were eventually freed, are seeking a presidential pardon.
4 h
foxnews.com
What to know about Trump's labor secretary nominee Lori Chavez-DeRemer
President-elect Donald Trump's pick for labor secretary is being applauded by some key labor unions.
5 h
abcnews.go.com
NYT 'Connections' November 23: Hints and Answers for Game #531
Connections is published by The New York Times and is one of its most popular games.
5 h
newsweek.com
'Wordle' Today #1,253 Answer, Hints and Clues for Saturday, November 23
We don't stop playing Wordle just because it's the weekend, so here are some ways to beat today's games.
5 h
newsweek.com
Miss Manners: Close friend moved back and didn’t tell me for 6 weeks
Does this letter writer just accept their longtime friend doesn’t want to be close anymore?
5 h
washingtonpost.com
Asking Eric: Nephew disappears into his video games during visits
Great-nephew plays too many video games when he visits, and the letter writer thinks it’s a “bad omen.”
5 h
washingtonpost.com
Carolyn Hax: Obvious reason for breakup doesn’t seem so in anxious retrospect
His girlfriend ended things when he seemed smitten with another woman, but now she’s not so sure.
5 h
washingtonpost.com
Nic Claxton’s back injury will be ‘long-term’ Nets issue: ‘Managing for a while’
Nic Claxton made his return to the court Friday after missing the past three games. But he acknowledged his back injury is “long-term,” and admitted it’s going to need management over the course of the season. 
5 h
nypost.com
Should fans sing along in theaters during the "Wicked" movie?
Cynthia Erivo, Ariana Grande, AMC and fans react to the debate over in-theater singing during "Wicked."
5 h
cbsnews.com
How U2 turned a ‘Bomb’ into their last classic album 20 years ago: ‘We were very lucky’
Longtime U2 producer Steve Lillywhite helped the Irish icons reignite their unforgettable fire to make another Grammy-winning classic in 2004's "How to Dismantle an Atomic Bomb."
5 h
nypost.com
What Trump's Labor Secretary Nominee Lori Chavez-DeRemer Signals to Unions
Chavez-DeRemer is one of only a few Republican lawmakers to back legislation that would strengthen labor unions.
5 h
newsweek.com
Breaking down the potential suitors for Daniel Jones after his Giants release
Here’s a look at potential suitors for Daniel Jones’ next team.
5 h
nypost.com
After getting ripped by coach, Wizards respond by hanging with the champs
Coach Brian Keefe tore into his team earlier in the week. The criticism resonated, despite a 10th straight loss.
5 h
washingtonpost.com
No. 7 Madison stays perfect, earns a gritty second-round win over Westfield
With a 25-28 win over their district rivals, the Warhawks moved to 12-0 and advance to a fifth straight regional final.
6 h
washingtonpost.com
Islanders need to give fans more than just blind hope as same problems persist
The Islanders’ season is only 20 games old, but it already feels like things are hitting a critical point. 
6 h
nypost.com
Narcotraficante mexicano arrestado en EEUU fingió su propia muerte, dicen fiscales
A Gutierrez Ochoa se le acusa de asociación delictuosa para importar toneladas de metanfetamina y cocaína a Estados Unidos
6 h
latimes.com
Trump picks former congressman Dave Weldon of Florida to lead CDC
The medical doctor has been a vocal critic of the agency, especially its vaccine program.
6 h
washingtonpost.com
Chris Woodward rejoins Dodgers staff as new first base coach
Chris Woodward, who worked as the Dodgers' third base coach before managing the Texas Rangers, returns to the Dodgers as their new first base coach.
6 h
latimes.com
Realtor urges parents to ditch the kids during house tours after witnessing 6-year-old girl’s horrific injury
Things got real. A Utah realtor is warning parents to think twice before bringing their children to open houses — sharing a gut-rending story that ended up with a little girl being airlifted to a hospital. Karina VanOrman shared a story on TikTok about one couple that insisted on bringing their three kiddos on each...
6 h
nypost.com
49ers' Deebo Samuel responds to Terrell Owens criticism: 'Cut it fam'
6 h
foxnews.com
Arundel turns to its defense for revenge and ousts Northern
The Wildcats’ high-flying offense was largely grounded, but running back TJ Mordecai’s two touchdowns lifted Arundel at home.
6 h
washingtonpost.com
Paul VI wins WCAC Metro championship, earning first football title since 1999
Senior Joshua Johnson had three touchdowns as the Panthers topped St. Mary’s Ryken, 27-17.
6 h
washingtonpost.com
Bob Dylan's Reagan Movie Song 'Don't Fence Me In' is Finally on YouTube
Bob Dylan's song "Don't Fence Me In," a cover of Cole Porter's 1934 song, continues the song's enduring popularity with inclusion in the movie "Reagan."
6 h
newsweek.com
Wise handles Dundalk to reach Maryland semifinals for ninth straight year
With a 39-14 quarterfinal victory at home, the Pumas became the fourth Maryland program to reach nine straight semifinals.
6 h
washingtonpost.com
TJ Maxx CEO says company could benefit from Trump’s proposed tariffs
Retailers and industry trade groups are sounding the alarm about how President-elect Trump's proposed tariffs could lead to higher prices.
6 h
nypost.com
Mother of construction worker slain by unhinged NYC stabber breaks down at vigil: ‘No words how I feel’
Mercedes Landi said she spoke to her son the night before his senseless killing — and is taking his body back to the Ecuadoran city he left 20 years ago for his funeral.
6 h
nypost.com