Tools
Change country:

Don’t Turn Inward

One month to the day before the 2024 presidential election, The New York Times reported on a new analysis of how Americans spend their time. More and more of the average American’s day is being spent at home: one hour and 39 minutes more in 2022 than in 2003. For each extra hour at home, a bit of it was spent with family—7.4 minutes. More of it, 21 minutes, was spent alone.

Obviously, because of the coronavirus pandemic, time at home spiked in 2020. Some of this homebody impulse may well be the stubborn persistence of habits formed during the isolating early days of lockdown. But this trend is more than just a pandemic hangover. For years before COVID-19 hit, time spent alone had been increasing as time spent socializing had been decreasing. Though solitude and loneliness are not the same, this downturn in social connection happened alongside a rise in loneliness so pronounced that the surgeon general called it an epidemic.

And now this: the reelection to the nation’s highest office of Donald Trump, a man who has attacked the very idea of a communal, democratic form of government, and who has indicated that he aspires to move the United States toward autocracy—auto, of course, meaning “self,” and autocracy being the concentration of power for and within the self. Self over others is one of Trump’s defining principles. In his first term as president, he used an office intended for public service to enrich himself. He has vowed to use it this time to take revenge on his enemies and—“within two seconds” of taking office—to fire the special counsel overseeing criminal cases against him.

Yet self over others, or at the very least self before others, has long been a prominent aspect of American culture—not always to Trumpian levels, certainly, but individualism for better and worse shapes both the structure of society and our personal lives. And it will surely shape Americans’ responses to the election: for the winners, perhaps, self-congratulation; for the losers, the risk of allowing despair to pull them into a deeper, more dangerous seclusion. On Election Day, the Times published an article on voters’ plans to manage stress. Two separate people in that story said they were deliberately avoiding social settings. To extend that strategy into the next four years would be a mistake.

[Read: Don’t give up on America]

In 1831, the French aristocrat Alexis de Tocqueville traveled to the United States. He observed and analyzed its people and culture, and published his thoughts in a massive two-volume report called Democracy in America. Alongside his praise for the country’s professed value of equality—which he wrote “possesses all the characteristics of a divine decree”—he warned of the individualism he saw as baked into American society and the isolation it could cause. “Each man is forever thrown back on himself alone,” he wrote, “and there is danger that he may be shut up in the solitude of his own heart.”

More than a century and a half later, Habits of the Heart: Individualism and Commitment in American Life, a sociological book by five scholars, followed explicitly in Tocqueville’s footsteps, examining how individualism affects institutions and personal relationships in the United States. Published in 1985, it reads today as wildly prescient. The authors feared that the danger Tocqueville described had already come to pass. “It seems to us,” they wrote, “that it is individualism, and not equality, as Tocqueville thought, that has marched inexorably through our history. We are concerned that this individualism may have grown cancerous … that it may be threatening the survival of freedom itself.”

Tempering American individualism, in Tocqueville’s view, was Americans’ propensity to form associations and participate in civic life. “These he saw as moderating the isolating tendencies of private ambition on one hand and limiting the despotic proclivities of government on the other,” the authors of Habits of the Heart wrote. But American associational life began hollowing out starting in the 1960s and ’70s, as people became less and less likely to attend any kind of club, league, church, or other community organization (a shift that Robert Putnam documented in his 2000 book, Bowling Alone). Since the late ’70s, faith in large-scale institutions such as organized religion, organized labor, the media, and the U.S. government has also been dwindling; in 2023, Gallup declared it “historically low.”

A few months ago I spoke with Ann Swidler, one of the authors of Habits of the Heart. “We obviously did not succeed in having things go the direction we might have hoped,” she told me. “I would say that every horrible thing we worried about has gotten worse.” Americans are spending measurably more time shut up in the solitude of their homes, and perhaps in the solitude of their own hearts as well.

It might be difficult to imagine the renaissance of many civic associations—the kind that could be good for both democracy and our relationships—given that a majority of Americans just voted for a man who has little interest in or respect for institutions beyond what they can do for him. If autocracy is indeed where the country is headed, Tocqueville’s prediction regarding our relationships is not a positive one. As he wrote in The Old Regime and the Revolution, his book on the French revolution:

Despotism does not combat this tendency [toward individualism]; on the contrary, it renders it irresistible, for it deprives citizens of all common passions, mutual necessities, need of a common understanding, opportunity for combined action: it ripens them, so to speak, in private life. They had a tendency to hold themselves aloof from each other: it isolates them. They looked coldly on each other: it freezes their souls.

If individualism is, as the authors of Habits of the Heart wrote, “the first language in which Americans tend to think about their lives,” it makes sense that people would reach for their mother tongue in times of upheaval. In the days after the 2016 election, for example, searches for the term self-care spiked. Caring for yourself takes different forms, of course, though in mainstream culture, self-care is commonly used to mean treating yourself, by yourself. Self-soothing, alone. (One can see in this echoes of Ralph Waldo Emerson’s essay “Self-Reliance”: “Nothing can bring you peace but yourself.”)

But caring for yourself doesn’t always have to breed isolation. Among activists and in the helping professions, self-care is often talked about as a way to restore people so that they don’t burn out and can continue their altruistic work. Some in these circles critique a focus on self-care as distracting from the need for institutional support. But the overall conception at least shows an understanding of the two types of care as having a symbiotic relationship: Care for the self so that you can show up for others.

[Read: Focus on the things that matter]

What’s more, caring for others is a form of self-care. Research shows that doing things for other people leads to greater well-being than trying to make yourself happy or indulging yourself. This is not to say there is no place for self-soothing or solitude, or for buying yourself a little treat. But it is to challenge the cultural message that turtling up alone is the most appropriate response to difficult feelings.

Under an administration for which (to paraphrase my colleague Adam Serwer) cruelty, not care, is the point, it falls to people to care for one another on scales small and large. This task is made harder not just by the cultural pressure for Americans to rely only on themselves but also by the slow, steady atrophying of the muscles of togetherness. “American individualism resists more adult virtues, such as care and generativity, let alone wisdom,” the authors of Habits of the Heart wrote. The inverse, I hope, is true too: that care and generativity—working to make contributions to a collective future—are the path to resisting hyper-individualism and isolation.

Even if turning inward is a big-picture trend, it is, of course, not the only development happening. As isolating as the pandemic lockdown was, those years saw the rise of mutual-aid groups determined to care for the vulnerable whether the government did or not. During the first Trump administration, mass protests broke out; people fought for women’s rights and an end to racist police brutality. People are always showing up for one another in quiet, everyday ways too. Building networks of support and commitment could provide some small buffer against the effects of a self-serving president-elect’s policies while keeping people from drifting further apart.

Americans’ skills of connection and care are not lost. But they are rusty. And all of us will need those skills if we are to find a way to turn toward one another instead of inward. I’m not even talking about overcoming political polarization or reaching out to build bridges with strangers who voted differently than you did. Those are tasks that people won’t be equipped to tackle if they’re struggling to show up for the loved ones already in their life. For now, it is enough of a challenge to attempt to reverse the isolationist inertia of decades. It is enough of a challenge to resist what has become a cultural tendency to withdraw, while also processing the stress of an election that has left many people exhausted and deeply afraid for the future. How do we proceed over the next four years? Not alone. How do we proceed over the next week, hour, minute? Not alone.

​​When you buy a book using a link on this page, we receive a commission. Thank you for supporting The Atlantic.


Read full article on: theatlantic.com
Cynthia Erivo: ‘Hard conversations’ with ‘Wicked’ co-star Ariana Grande were needed to create ‘sister’-like bond
"We had a beautiful relationship offscreen," Erivo told Elle, explaining that their connection came from "vulnerability."
9 m
nypost.com
Get hitched without hassle with pop-up weddings and budget busters
Couples are saying yes to budget-friendly, easy-to-plan, pop-up weddings that first became popular during the pandemic.
nypost.com
Rays to play at Yankees’ Steinbrenner Field in 2025 after hurricane ravaged stadium
The Yankees are helping the rival Rays stay in Tampa for 2025 after their stadium was damaged by Hurricane Milton.
nypost.com
Meek Mill distances himself from Sean ‘Diddy’ Combs after mogul’s sex trafficking arrest: ‘No Diddy gang’
"This real life. No Diddy gang. Meek Milly in real life. Don't ever disrespect me, ya heard?" the rapper said before getting into a Rolls Royce.
nypost.com
The Weasley twins on their new baking show and how the ‘Harry Potter’ TV series will be ‘a bit odd’
“I dunno, it would be a bit odd, I think, because we’d be like,‘So, who’s that guy? That’s not Harry!'"
nypost.com
Mets ready to go ‘full blast’ to sign Juan Soto: Carlos Beltran
Steve Cohen and the Mets appear ready to go all in for Juan Soto.
nypost.com
Geraldo Rivera claims he ‘threw up’ after hearing Matt Gaetz was Trump’s AG pick
"When I heard that Matt Gaetz was picked to be attorney general, I threw up in my mouth,” Rivera, 81, told NewsNation’s "On Balance with Leland Vittert" Wednesday.
nypost.com
What are the best ways to get rid of credit card debt in retirement?
New research shows that retirees' credit card debt is growing. Here's how you can tackle yours now.
cbsnews.com
Harris backed out of Joe Rogan podcast over ‘backlash’ from lefty staffers
A campaign official reportedly said Vice President Kamala Harris backed out of appearing on Joe Rogan’s podcast out of fear of backlash within the Democratic Party. .
nypost.com
Nicole Kidman’s fictional home in ‘Babygirl’ can be yours in real life — and for a discount
Down from its $38 million ask last year, the 6,347-square-foot 200 Amsterdam penthouse — also featured in "Succession" — comes with four bedrooms and terraces.
nypost.com
Holiday travelers warned about fake TSA ‘scam’ that could bleed you dry
Don't get prechecked by crooks.
nypost.com
Inflation remains stubborn as wholesale prices accelerate after Fed rate cuts
The October report on producer prices comes a day after the Labor Department reported that consumer prices rose 2.6% last month from a year earlier.
nypost.com
Heir to British pie fortune charged with killing best friend also tried to break into Buckingham Palace
Thomas is accused slashing Bush in the neck and severing his jugular vein during “seven minutes of horror” at their shared home on Christmas Eve 2023.
nypost.com
Gary Vaynerchuk has some tough love for those who don’t embrace AI: Ride this wave or put your head in the sand and let it kill you
"The answer is to weaponize the opportunity instead of crying about it," the entrepreneur and media personality told The Post.
nypost.com
FEMA official fired for telling staff to avoid helping Trump supporters says agency scapegoating her
A former FEMA employee fired for instructing subordinates to avoid visiting Florida homes displaying Trump signs says the agency is scapegoating her for its own policy.
foxnews.com
‘Say Nothing’ Cast Opens Up About How Close the FX IRA Drama Hews to Their Real Life: “It Felt Like the Least Acting I’ve Ever Had to Do”
The real-life best friends revealed how the show honors the world of their native West Belfast. 
nypost.com
BetMGM Bonus Code NYP1600DM: Pocket a deposit match up to $1.6K for ‘Thursday Night Football’
Sign up with a BetMGM bonus code to unlock an exciting welcome offer, available for any game, including the Washington Commanders vs. Philadelphia Eagles matchup on "Thursday Night Football".
nypost.com
NATO jets scrambled after Russian aircraft spotted
The Russian planes were "not adhering to international norms" when Italian and Norwegian NATO jets were mobilized.
cbsnews.com
Girls' high school volleyball: Regional playoff results and updated schedule
Girls' high school volleyball regional playoff scores from Wednesday, plus Thursday's schedule.
latimes.com
Feeling ranchy? Wrangle a wild west wedding
Hoping to put their own brand on a stable relationship, more and more brides are ranching out in cow country.
nypost.com
Megan Rapinoe 'overwhelmed’ by another Trump presidency, fearful for the transgender community
Megan Rapinoe shared her disappointment with Donald Trump's victory over Kamala Harris in the 2024 presidential election, adding that she is now fearful for the transgender community.
foxnews.com
It's Starbucks Red Cup Day. Here's what to know about the event.
Here's how to get a free holiday-themed reusable red cup and what else there is to know about the event.
cbsnews.com
Texas Salon Owner Jailed for COVID Lockdown Violation Wins Seat in Legislature
A former Dallas salon owner who was jailed for re-opening her salon during COVID-19 will now be the next state representative for Texas House District 62. Shelley Luther won the election with nearly 80 percent of the vote. The post Texas Salon Owner Jailed for COVID Lockdown Violation Wins Seat in Legislature appeared first on Breitbart.
breitbart.com
Elon Musk Wants the Government to Stop Wasting Money on Wacky Science. That’s a Terrible Idea.
Science is inefficient. That’s a good thing.
slate.com
See which 17 brands made ‘Toxic Hall of Shame’ for using ‘dangerous’ chemicals — Chipotle, Trader Joe’s get Fs on report card
The nonprofit Toxic-Free Future graded brands including Apple, Sephora, Target, and Walmart.
nypost.com
The Myth of Woke Gen Z
The same young people once derided as liberal snowflakes are moving to the right.
theatlantic.com
Kelly Ripa And Mark Consuelos’ Son Dressed Like Don Johnson On ‘Miami Vice’ “For A Solid Year”: “Thought It Was The Coolest Ever”
"Our son, I used to show him Miami Vice, and he so took to it," Ripa told Johnson on Live with Kelly and Mark.
nypost.com
A comedy show that addresses politics head on, while also providing escape
“Dance Like There’s Black People Watching: A Black Excellence Revue” is the latest Second City collaboration with Woolly Mammoth.
washingtonpost.com
Nikki Haley claims she turned down ‘truce’ offer from Trump ally: ‘There’s nothing I want’
Former US ambassador to the UN Nikki Haley claimed that she slapped down an overture from one of President-election Donald Trump's allies who suggested he could help her land a role in the new administration.
nypost.com
‘Deadpool & Wolverine’ helps push Disney past Wall Street estimates: ‘Well positioned for growth’
"We've emerged from a period of considerable challenges and disruption," Iger told investors. "We're well positioned for growth."
nypost.com
Denzel Washington: My Gay Kiss was Axed from 'Gladiator II'
Actor Denzel Washington says he "kissed a guy full on the lips" in the 2024 movie "Gladiator II," but that the queer scene ended up being axed from the film. The post Denzel Washington: My Gay Kiss was Axed from ‘Gladiator II’ appeared first on Breitbart.
breitbart.com
Biden admin bans employers from discussing unionization with 'captive audience' employees
The Biden administration's National Labor Relations Board issued an opinion on Wednesday that bars businesses from expressing their views on unionization to a "captive audience" of employees.
foxnews.com
High school flag football: City Section playoff results and updated pairings
High school flag football: City Section playoff results from Wednesday and updated pairings.
latimes.com
Consultant charged with murder of Cash App founder Bob Lee claims tech titan attacked him
Prosecutors say Momeni drove Lee to a secluded area and stabbed him three times, then fled.
nypost.com
Clay Aiken randomly questions Shawn Mendes’ sexuality during interview: ‘I shouldn’t out him’
"By the way, did Shawn Mendes come out today?" Clay Aiken asked in a new interview.
nypost.com
Biden to meet with China's Xi Jinping at APEC summit
President Biden is heading to South America Thursday with his first stop coming at the Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation summit where he'll meet with Chinese leader Xi Jinping. CBS News chief White House correspondent Nancy Cordes has more.
cbsnews.com
Pistons’ Isaiah Stewart uses ‘dangerous play’ to stop Giannis Antetokounmpo
No one could stop Giannis Antetokounmpo on Wednesday night — even as the Pistons tried reliving their "Bad Boys" past.
nypost.com
Sofia Richie’s 5-month-old daughter has a real phone — and she’s already texting ‘guncle’ Jake Shane
"Eloise has a little bit of an attitude!" the influencer quipped on his "Therapuss" podcast Wednesday.
nypost.com
Looking for Italian romance? Weddings in Tuscany are a dream come true
Couples are flocking to Tuscany for a dream wedding -- followed, naturally, by a bucolic honeymoon in the magical landscapes.
nypost.com
‘Gladiator II’ star Denzel Washington has awkward encounter with King Charles
Denzel Washington experienced an awkward encounter with King Charles III during the London premiere of "Gladiator II."
foxnews.com
Lindsey Vonn announces a comeback at 40, saying she's ready to race
The record-setting skier once notched speeds that would be illegal on most U.S. highways — until knee injuries slowed her down and she retired in 2019. Now Vonn says she's ready to return to racing.
npr.org
Is the ‘Red One’ Movie Streaming on Netflix or Amazon Prime Video?
The Rock is coming to save Christmas.
nypost.com
Halle Berry looks ageless as she rewears iconic Elie Saab Oscars dress 22 years after historic win
The A-lister closed out the 1001 Seasons of Elie Saab runway show, which celebrated the Lebanese designer's career, in the legendary gown.
nypost.com
Trump picking Gaetz for AG may be loyalty test for senators
President-elect Donald Trump's choice for attorney general, Matt Gaetz, is facing a tough Senate confirmation process for the job. CBS News political director Fin Gómez reports on some of the speculation about why Trump made such a controversial pick.
cbsnews.com
I dated a Mr. Big in NYC — if you want one, prepare for 4 a.m. exits and vasectomy bragging
It’s 4 a.m. and I’m being gently prodded awake by a very sexy man. Nope, not because he’s horny — although, trust me, we did manage to squeeze in a little action — but because my saucy love interest’s alarm just went off, and I’m being politely but firmly booted out. This was my first...
nypost.com
Do GOP Senators Have Any Backbone Left?
Trump’s ridiculous Cabinet nominations will provide senators with a new test.
theatlantic.com
Who are Trump's likely top contenders to lead comms team, interact with the media?
President-elect Trump is expected to announce his second administration's press secretary and communications team, as he speedily rolls out key Cabinet and staff positions.
foxnews.com
Exploring Trump-Musk bromance and how the two powerful personalities can last
What we know about Elon Musk’s ‘Department Of Government Efficiency’ and bromance with Donald Trump.
abcnews.go.com