Tools
Change country:

43 lab monkeys escaped in South Carolina. They have a legal claim to freedom.

Rear view of two monkeys sitting side-by-side in a fenced enclosure.
Monkeys at the Alpha Genesis research facility in Yemassee, South Carolina.

Last week, 43 monkeys, all of them young female rhesus macaques, escaped from the Alpha Genesis research laboratory in Yemassee, South Carolina, when an employee failed to properly secure the door to their enclosure. 

It wasn’t the first time something like this happened at Alpha Genesis, a company that breeds and uses thousands of monkeys for biomedical testing and supplies nonhuman primate products and bio-research services to researchers worldwide. In 2018, the US Department of Agriculture (USDA) fined the facility $12,600 in part for other incidents in which monkeys had escaped. “We’re not strangers to seeing monkeys randomly,” a nearby resident and member of the Yemassee town council told the New York Times.  

Alpha Genesis is now working to recapture the macaques, who are each about the size of a cat; over the weekend, 25 of them were recovered. Meanwhile, the animal protection group Stop Animal Exploitation Now, which for years has filed federal complaints against the facility, has called on the USDA to prosecute Alpha Genesis as a repeat violator of its duty to keep the animals secure.

“The recovery process is slow, but the team is committed to taking as much time as necessary to safely recover all remaining animals,” a Facebook post from the Yemassee Police Department said, attributing the comment to Alpha Genesis CEO Greg Westergaard.

In one way, this is a story about what looks like a corporate failure. But there is another way to understand this situation, both legally and morally. What if these intrepid macaques, who the lab has said pose no threat to the public and carry no infectious diseases, have a legal claim to freedom? 

The legal status of wild animals is more contested and malleable than ever, evident in the recent court case arguing that Happy, an elephant living at the Bronx Zoo, was a legal person entitled to freedom, the phasing out of animal use at entertainment venues like circuses, and the end of US lab experimentation on chimpanzees. While Alpha Genesis may have a strong financial incentive to recapture the escaped monkeys, longstanding legal doctrines suggest that the 18 monkeys still at large may not belong to the company as long as they remain free and outside of its custody. State officials, or perhaps even members of the public, might even be legally protected in rescuing these monkeys from a fate of cage confinement and invasive experimentation and bringing them to a sanctuary. Such an outcome would matter not just for these monkeys but also for the rights of captive animals more broadly.   

When a captive animal becomes free

For many people, the idea of a lost animal becoming the property of another person might seem absurd. Certainly, no one would imagine forfeiting the companionship of a beloved dog or cat because the animal got out of the yard and was found by someone else. Neither law nor morality treats the escape of a domesticated animal as tantamount to a forfeiture of all claims to the animal. 

But when it comes to wild animals, the law is different. 

When a captive wild animal escapes, their captor generally remains liable for any damage the escaped animal creates to persons or property, but they may lose ownership of the animal, especially if the creature integrates into an existing wild population (sometimes called “reverting to the common stock”). That might sound unlikely for rhesus macaques in the US — the species is native to South and Southeast Asia and has been exported around the world for lab testing. But it turns out that it’s perfectly possible to live as a free-roaming rhesus macaque in South Carolina, where a more than four-decade-old population of the monkeys resides on the state’s Morgan Island, also known as “Monkey Island.” 

Originally relocated from Puerto Rico between 1979 and 1980, the Morgan Island macaques now serve as a kind of reservoir of lab monkeys for the US government. Last year, Alpha Genesis won a federal contract to oversee the monkey colony there — in fact, the 43 escaped macaques had originally lived as “free-range” monkeys on the island before they were taken to be used for testing and research purposes, the US Centers for Disease Control and Prevention told CBS News in a statement. While these monkeys may not be able to rejoin the Morgan Island colony on their own, the fact that they came from a wild population strengthens the view of them as animals who not only can live in the wild but who deserve to be free.

An adult monkey sitting on a tree branch cradles a baby monkey. A macaque in a laboratory cage, surrounded by other cages with no visible occupants, looks through the bars.

Our modern understanding of animals’ legal status derives from 19th-century American common law cases, which adopted the classical Roman legal approach to wild animals, or ferae naturae. Under that system, wild animals were a special type of property known as “fugitive” property because they could move freely and weren’t owned by anyone before being captured by a human. This created unique legal challenges — for example, conflicts between two hunters claiming the same animal — that can help us understand the case of the escaped monkeys. 

The 1805 New York Supreme Court case Pierson v. Post, sometimes considered the most famous property case in American law (and about which one of us has written a book), is the starting point for understanding who legally owns a wild animal. In a dispute between two hunters, one who had been in hot pursuit of a fox and one who swooped in to kill the animal, the case held that the property interest of the latter was stronger. The court made clear that a definitive capture, and not pursuit alone, was necessary to establish and retain ownership of a wild animal. 

In 1898, another New York case, Mullett v. Bradley, went further by recognizing that capture alone is not sufficient to claim ownership of a wild animal if the animal is able to escape and regain their liberty. The court found that a sea lion who had been brought by rail from the Pacific Ocean to the East Coast and later escaped from an enclosure in Long Island Sound was legally free until he was captured by a different person two weeks later. Cases like these gave rise to a doctrine that legal scholars now call “the law of capture,” which holds that if a captive wild animal escapes and control over them is lost, they no longer necessarily belong to the party who had previously captured them.  

This line of legal reasoning generally works to the detriment of animals, ensuring that each generation of law students learns that animals are ours to possess and use for our own ends. But in the case of the escaped South Carolina monkeys, the law of capture raises doubt about whether the lab retains ownership of the animals unless and until it recaptures them. 

A more recent Canadian case suggests that the law of capture may indeed offer a path to rescue for escaped animals like the South Carolina lab monkeys. In 2012, Darwin, a Japanese snow macaque, became a worldwide media sensation when he was found roaming through an Ontario IKEA store wearing a shearling coat and a diaper. While Darwin had been kept as a pet, a Canadian court ruled that he was a wild animal, and his owner lost her rights to him after he escaped from her car. Toronto Animal Services captured Darwin inside the store and transferred him to a primate sanctuary, where he could live among other macaques. 

Still, one could argue that the escaped lab monkeys in South Carolina are effectively domestic animals who belong to their owner. Alpha Genesis has put resources into housing and raising them, including managing the monkey population on Morgan Island. But unlike pets who have been domesticated over many generations to live safely among humans, these rhesus macaques retain their wild instincts — they’ve been described as skittish, and food is being used to lure them into traps. 

If the monkeys were to return on their own, like a house cat coming home after a day of adventure, the legal case for viewing them as domestic animals would be stronger because wild animals, once they stray, must have no animus revertendi, or intention to return. So long as these monkeys express their desire to remain free by evading capture, they should be considered wild animals. A 1917 Ontario court case, Campbell v. Hedley, involving a fox who had escaped a fur farm, established a similar principle, finding that the animal remained wild and thereby became free after fleeing the farm because they belonged to a species that “require[d] the exercise of art, force, or skill to keep them in subjection.” 

There are, to be sure, cases in which common law courts have found losing control of an animal does not result in a loss of ownership. A 1927 Colorado case, Stephens v. Albers, held that a semi-domesticated silver fox who escaped from a fur farm still remained the property of that owner. And questions about the ownership of wild animals are infinitely debatable, as any good student of Pierson v. Post will tell you. 

While these past cases offer important insight into the treatment of wild animals under common law, none of them took place in South Carolina, so courts in that state could consider them for guidance but wouldn’t be required to follow them when deciding who owns the escaped Alpha Genesis monkeys (and nothing in this piece should be construed as legal advice). 

The moral meaning of animal escapes

Yet the law of capture aside, the plight of these monkeys is also interesting to us as legal scholars because it highlights one of many disconnects between the law and our moral intuitions about animals who have escaped and who are seeking or being afforded sanctuary. As journalist Tove Danovich has written, there is often great public sympathy and compassion for animals who escape painful confinement or slaughter at zoos, factory farms, or research labs — even among people who might otherwise tolerate the very systems that normalize those animals’ suffering. The public’s outrage when a single cow who escapes slaughter is gunned down by authorities is palpable and crosses ideological lines.

There is something enchanting and powerful, even romantic, about the idea of an animal escape, especially if it results in the animal’s rescue from confinement. Yet the law generally fails to recognize the moral tug that these escapes place on our collective conscience.

In a recent high-profile case in upstate New York, two cows wandered onto an animal sanctuary after escaping from a neighboring ranch. Unlike the South Carolina monkeys, these were straightforwardly domesticated animals, and the response from local law enforcement was harsh. 

The sanctuary owner, Tracy Murphy, was arrested, shackled, and faced criminal liability for taking the cows in and refusing to immediately turn them over for slaughter (one of us, Justin, was defense counsel for Murphy, whose case was dismissed last month after a two-year legal battle). Her aid to two escaped cows was widely vilified by her neighbors and by local law enforcement because our legal system continues to treat many animals as property without any recognized rights or interests of their own. 

The law is unlikely to swiftly abandon the archaic notion of human ownership over nonhuman animals. But we believe the law does implicitly recognize a right to rescue escaped animals, at least those who are lucky enough to make it on their own steam. We hope that the case of the escaped South Carolina monkeys will inspire conversations about the right of at least some animals to liberate themselves from exploitation and harm at human hands. Escapes are rare, but when they happen against all odds, we might ask ourselves, on both legal and moral grounds, whether the animals have a claim to freedom.  


Read full article on: vox.com
Mystery around missing 'Gossip Girl' actor deepens, with family, LAPD at odds
Depending on whom you ask, Chanel Maya Banks is either a missing person who may be in danger or hurt, or she has been located and is safe.
latimes.com
How Travis Kelce subtly referenced Taylor Swift on ‘New Heights’ amid couple’s rare ‘alone time’
The Kansas City Chiefs tight end nodded to his Grammy-winning girlfriend while discussing vocal cord protection and sunny concerts.
nypost.com
21 holiday romance books to cozy up with this Christmas season
Cozy up by the fire with one of these festive romances.
nypost.com
Jill Biden’s apparent cold shoulder to Kamala Harris ignites social media
Social media erupted following First Lady Jill Biden’s icy reception for Vice President Kamala Harris as Harris took an adjacent seat at Arlington Cemetery on Tuesday.
nypost.com
Belissa Escobedo is finding her happy place
L.A.'s homegrown actress, Belissa Escobedo, stars opposite Reba McEntire in the new NBC series "Happy's Place"
latimes.com
UFO hearing: Ex-Pentagon official says government 'cabal' is hiding 'the fact that we are not alone'
Witnesses testified to the House Oversight Committee regarding the Pentagon's alleged hiding of UFOs.
foxnews.com
So Long, FreeVee: Amazon’s Ad-Supported Streamer Shutters After 5 Years
Even Jury Duty couldn't save Freevee. 
nypost.com
Très chic! The Bath & Body Works ‘Emily in Paris’ collab is now available
Even though she may be Emily in Rome now...
nypost.com
‘Emily in Paris’ cast reportedly ‘so upset’ over Lucas Bravo’s disparaging comments about the show: ‘A lot of tension’
The 36-year-old raised eyebrows last month after he hinted at a possible departure from the series due to disagreements about his character arc.
nypost.com
JK Rowling is ‘fairly involved’ in ‘Harry Potter’ TV series after anti-trans controversies
JK Rowling is an executive producer on HBO's upcoming "Harry Potter" show.
nypost.com
Outside: vinyl siding. Inside: a bear
In Pittsburgh, entire houses have been converted into individual art installations filled with unusual objects. A new house is now open.
npr.org
What to know about Sen. John Thune, the new Republican leader in the Senate
Sen. John Thune of South Dakota is set to lead the Senate as majority leader in the new Congress, after Republicans flipped the chamber in the 2024 elections.
cbsnews.com
Padma Lakshmi on stripping down for Pirelli Calendar 2025: ‘You can do it in a beautiful, elegant way’
The former "Top Chef" host showed a lot of skin in the imagery, saying, "I don’t think that nudity is anything to be afraid of."
nypost.com
‘Gossip Girl’ actress Chanel Maya Banks found safe and uninjured after going missing in LA
Law enforcement told TMZ that the "Gossip Girl" actress was found safe and sound and they do not suspect foul play was involved in her disappearance.
nypost.com
Republican calls Biden-Harris border policies 'a joke'
ABC News’ Linsey Davis spoke with Rep. Monica De La Cruz of Texas about securing a second term.
abcnews.go.com
Behind Trump's plans for Elon Musk, Vivek Ramaswamy
Donald Trump's plans for Elon Musk and Vivek Ramaswamy's roles in his government are emerging after he announced they would head a temporary agency known as the Department of Government Efficiency. CBS News' Libby Cathey breaks down what's known.
cbsnews.com
U.S. and Polish officials open missile defense site that Russia has long protested
The U.S. missile defense base, which is being integrated into NATO's defenses, was originally planned under U.S. President George W. Bush.
latimes.com
Jewelry-store heist by illegal migrants damns Biden border crisis AND failed NY criminal justice ‘reforms’
It's a perfect storm of terrible progressive policy.
nypost.com
Spurs reveal Gregg Popovich suffered 'mild stroke,' expected to make full recovery
San Antonio Spurs head coach Gregg Popovich has been sidelined for several games and on Wednesday the team announced that the longtime NBA coach had suffered a "mild stroke" on Nov. 2.
foxnews.com
Democrats make last stand for unions ahead of Trump administration
The National Labor Relations Board on Wednesday ruled to ban employers nationwide from forcing workers to attend anti-union meetings.
washingtonpost.com
Actor Ben Foster files for divorce from 'That ’70s Show' star Laura Prepon
Ben Foster has filed for divorce from actor Laura Prepon in Tennessee, stating that they are 'unable to live together successfully as husband and wife.'
latimes.com
Missing ‘Gossip Girl’ actress Chanel Maya Banks found unharmed in Texas
Chanel Maya Banks, a Los Angeles actress whose family said she went missing for two weeks, has been found safe in Texas, police said.
nypost.com
Spurs coach Gregg Popovich suffered mild stroke before game, expected to make ‘full recovery’
It was previously reported that Popovich, 75, suffered a health issue at the team's arena before its win over the Timberwolves, but the issue was not previously disclosed.
nypost.com
My husband gives me $100 per week to be his housewife — feminists hate my ‘traditional’ lifestyle
Trad wife Alyssa "Ally" Dee, 28 says her husband pays her around $100 per week to cook and clean for him -- a choice that's earned her flack from feminists.
nypost.com
5 Thanksgiving apple desserts for bakers of all levels
Depending on your time and ambition, use the base caramelized apples to make a cake, galette, two types of pie and a cheesecake.
washingtonpost.com
This ‘preppy’ ’90s fashion trend is back, thanks to celebs from J.Lo to Billie Eilish
Gen Z and millennials chest can’t get enough of this throwback swag now. 
nypost.com
Trump names Stephen Miller, Dan Scavino to senior White House staff
Dan Scavino and Stephen Miller are among four new cabinet picks announced by the Trump-Vance transition team.
foxnews.com
Jay Leno's look inside one of the top car collection museums in the U.S.
The Petersen Automotive Museum hosts a collection of more than 400 classics, including Hollywood legend Steve McQueen's 1956 Jaguar, now worth more than $30 million.
cbsnews.com
In Oval Office, Biden Welcomes Trump, Who Plans to Unwind Biden’s Presidency
Biden promised Trump a "smooth transition"
time.com
How Trump and Biden's meeting started at the White House
President Biden welcomed President-elect Donald Trump back to the White House during a meeting to ensure a smooth transition before the January inauguration. CBS News chief White House correspondent Nancy Cordes has more.
cbsnews.com
Jay Leno's rides through 30 years of auto history
Cruising through Los Angeles in an open-top sports car epitomizes the California dream. That's why LA naturally became home to one of the world's finest car collections, the Petersen Automotive Museum, now marking its 30th anniversary. For car enthusiast Jay Leno, it's a beloved destination.
cbsnews.com
Mod Sun moves on with ‘Love Is Blind’ star Brittany Wisniewski after Avril Lavigne split
It looks like Mod Sun has found his new “flame” following his breakup with Avril Lavigne. The musician was recently spotted packing on the PDA with “Love Is Blind” star Brittany Wisniewski. Watch the full video to learn more about this new romance.  Subscribe to our YouTube for the latest on all your favorite stars.
nypost.com
'The Big D' delivers divorced dating comedy game show just in time for cuffing season
The Big D Comedy Dating show at West Side Theater
latimes.com
First-time homebuyers are now older than ever as the housing crisis deepens
First-time homebuyers in America are hitting an unprecedented milestone, and it’s not one they’ll be celebrating.
nypost.com
Joe Rogan says Kamala Harris campaign had a condition to avoid 'marijuana legalization' talk for interview
Podcast host Joe Rogan revealed on Tuesday that VP Kamala Harris' campaign had put a condition on a potential interview with the podcast host about avoiding marijuana talk.
foxnews.com
John Driskell Hopkins on new song and $3 million donation for ALS research
After his ALS diagnosis, Zac Brown Band's John Driskell Hopkins plans to donate $3 million to fund research through his "Hop On A Cure" foundation and released a new single titled "Each Other."
cbsnews.com
Tropical Storm Sara likely to form as Florida braces for potential impacts with weeks left of hurricane season
Florida residents are now keeping an eye on the system, which forecasters say will likely strengthen into Tropical Storm Sara by the weekend.
nypost.com
‘St. Denis Medical’s Co-Creators Tease A Slow-Burn Romance For Matt And Serena: “Definitely A Thing That We’re Tracking Throughout Season 1”
Eric Ledgin and Justin Spitzer break down their new NBC comedy with Decider.
nypost.com
How Rangers’ Mika Zibanejad can get out of his slump
Jim Cerny, executive editor for ‘Forever Blueshirts’, joins Brandon London to break down the Rangers’ Tuesday night loss to the NHL-best Winnipeg Jets and explain the reasons for Mika Zibanejad’s continued struggles.
nypost.com
Stream It Or Skip It: ‘Bad Sisters’ Season 2 On Apple TV+, Where Another Body Brings Up New Questions About The Garvey Sisters
Fiona Shaw joins Sharon Horgan, Eve Hewson, Anna-Marie Duff, Eva Birthistle and Sarah Greene in Season 2.
nypost.com
Video shows drunk passenger assaulting flight attendant — and lunging at cop trying to arrest her
The chaotic incident played out on a flight from Moscow to Surgut on Friday.
nypost.com
Biden to meet with China’s Xi at Peru summit — ahead of Trump tariffs and COVID reparations push
Biden, 81, and Xi, 71, will meet on Saturday in Lima during the Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation conference.
nypost.com
Beyoncé, Shawn Mendes, Barry Keoghan show skin & more spicy news | Hump Day
https://youtu.be/yxbyNFDOHSY Happy “Hump Day”! From thirst traps to saucy sound bytes, Page Six is rounding up the spiciest celebrity content to get you over the hump. In the premiere episode, hosts Astra and Brian Faas tackle Ricky Martin’s latest shirtless selfie, Beyoncé’s “Baywatch”-inspired music video, Shawn Mendes’ Interview magazine cover and more. Plus, did Barry...
nypost.com
He Was Featured in People’s “Sexiest Man Alive” Spread. Now the Villagers Are Coming With Pitchforks.
You are not allowed to be this upset about this!
slate.com
Lava drifting over snow in Iceland is surprisingly not AI
Fire, meet ice. Stunning aerial video shows molten lava traveling across a snowy landscape in Iceland following Sundhnukagigar Volcano’s Feb. 2024 eruption. Videographer Jeroen Van Nieuwenhove says many social media users were stunned by the visuals, believing them to be AI-generated because of the lack of visible steam. The phenomenon is called the Leidenfrost Effect,...
nypost.com
Democratic governors form resistance group against Trump
Colorado Gov. Jared Polis and Illinois Gov. J.B. Pritzker are co-chairing an initiative called Governors Safeguarding Democracy.
foxnews.com
Do you gift people books? These are among the strangest ones you can give
In time for the holiday season, the survey of 2,000 American readers looked at book gifting trends, including some of the strangest books people have ever received.
nypost.com
John Thune elected Senate Republican leader as Mitch McConnell steps down
South Dakota Sen. John Thune has been elected to replace Kentucky Sen. Mitch McConnell as the upper chamber's Republican leader. CBS News' Nikole Killion reports.
cbsnews.com