Tools
Change country:

The messy SCOTUS drama about Black voters in Louisiana, explained

Protesters in front of the Supreme Court building hold signs in the shapes of the voting districts in Louisiana.
Anti-gerrymandering protesters outside of the Supreme Court’s building. | Evelyn Hockstein/Washington Post via Getty Images

Multiple federal courts are fighting over Louisiana's illegal racial gerrymander.

Three different federal courts are fighting among themselves over who gets to draw Louisiana’s congressional maps.

In June 2022, Chief Judge Shelly Dick, an Obama appointee to the United States District Court for the Middle District of Louisiana, ruled that the state’s maps were an illegal racial gerrymander. Under the invalidated maps, Black voters made up a majority in only one of six congressional districts, despite the fact that Black people comprise about one-third of the state’s population.

Dick concluded that “the appropriate remedy in this context is a remedial congressional redistricting plan that includes an additional majority-Black congressional district” — meaning that the state needed new maps with at least two Black-majority districts.

There’s been a lot of litigation since Dick initially made this decision, but the most significant recent development in this case, known as Robinson v. Ardoin, came last November. That’s when a bipartisan panel of the Fifth Circuit, the federal appeals court that oversees Louisiana, rejected many of the state’s legal arguments against Dick’s decision, but also gave the state until mid-January to draw new, legal maps before Dick could step in and draw them herself.

The state legislature took the Fifth Circuit up on this offer and passed a new law drawing maps that included two Black-majority districts. So it seemed like that would be the end of the litigation over Louisiana’s maps.

But then an entirely different set of plaintiffs filed a new lawsuit in a different court, the Western District of Louisiana, claiming that the new maps were unconstitutional. This second case is known as Callais v. Landry.

For complicated procedural reasons, Callais was heard by a panel of three judges, and two of those judges — the ones appointed by Donald Trump — agreed that the new maps are illegal.

That means that Louisiana is now subject to two competing court orders. Judge Dick’s order prohibits it from using its old maps, and the Western District’s order prohibits it from using the new maps. Meanwhile, the state needs to hold a congressional election this year, and it must have maps of some kind to do that.

This mess is now before the Supreme Court in a pair of cases known as Robinson v. Callais and Landry v. Callais. In these cases, both the plaintiffs in Robinson and the state ask the justices to put the lower court’s decision in Callais on hold, although for different reasons. If the justices don’t step in, it’s far from clear how, exactly, Louisiana is supposed to conduct its congressional election.

What does the law actually say about Louisiana’s congressional maps?

There’s no question that Louisiana’s original maps, the ones struck down by Judge Dick, are illegal.

Dick initially ruled that those maps were illegal in mid-2022, but the Supreme Court stepped in almost immediately to put that decision on hold. At the time, the justices were also considering a very similar case, Allen v. Milligan, which involved a racially gerrymandered map in Alabama. The Court ultimately concluded that Alabama’s maps were an illegal racial gerrymander and ordered the state to redraw those maps to include an additional Black-majority district.

Shortly after it handed down its Milligan decision, it lifted its hold on the Robinson litigation, allowing that challenge to Louisiana’s original maps to move forward. There’s been a lot of needless drama since that happened, but the Fifth Circuit ultimately rejected Louisiana’s arguments seeking to salvage its original maps, pointing out that “most of the arguments the State made here were addressed and rejected by the Supreme Court in Milligan.”

The Fifth Circuit gave the state legislature until mid-January to draw new maps that include a second Black-majority district, and the legislature complied.

The two judges who struck down these new maps in the Callais case, meanwhile, fixated on a line in Milligan that states that a key provision of the Voting Rights Act “never requires adoption of districts that violate traditional redistricting principles” — such as ensuring that districts are compact and that they group together communities with similar interests.

The new maps are pretty ugly, and they include at least one district that snakes through the center of the state, flouting traditional norms of compactness.

 Plaintiff’s complaint in Callais v. Landry
The most recent congressional maps drawn by the Louisiana state legislature.

The reason for these oddly shaped districts is that Louisiana’s Republican legislature hoped to accomplish two goals when it drew these new maps. It knew that it must include two Black-majority districts to comply with Judge Dick’s order in the Robinson case, but it also wanted to ensure that three Republican incumbents — Speaker Mike Johnson, House Majority Leader Steve Scalise, and Rep. Julia Letlow — would still prevail under the new maps.

Additionally, the Robinson plaintiffs claim that the state legislature wanted to ensure that the new Black-majority district would come at the expense of Rep. Garret Graves (R-LA), who they describe as a “political rival” of Louisiana Gov. Jeff Landry (R).

In any event, the two judges behind the Callais decision ultimately concluded that these new maps were too ugly to survive, ruling them invalid in large part because they do not “comply with traditional districting principles.”

It’s far from clear that this decision was correct. Though Milligan did say that the Voting Rights Act does not require districts that violate these traditional principles, that line appeared in a broader paragraph emphasizing that “reapportionment remains primarily the duty and responsibility of the States, not the federal courts.”

Read in context, in other words, the key line in Milligan that the Callais judges fixated upon suggests that a state legislature ordered to draw new maps under the Voting Rights Act should retain the freedom to comply with traditional principles such as drawing compact districts, not they they absolutely must do so.

But there’s also no need for the Supreme Court to untangle this complicated debate about what Milligan means, at least not right now, because there’s another perfectly good reason why the Callais judges’ decision blocking the new maps must be put on hold.

The “Purcell principle,” briefly explained

In Purcell v. Gonzales (2006), the Supreme Court warned that “federal courts ordinarily should not alter state election rules in the period close to an election.” The Court has often wielded this principle quite aggressively — too aggressively, I’ve argued — in cases where a lower court issued a decision in an election year that could benefit the Democratic Party.

In the Milligan case, for example, Justice Brett Kavanaugh relied on Purcell to argue that Alabama could not be ordered to redraw its maps more than nine months before a general election. That meant that Alabama got to run the 2022 election using illegal maps that the Supreme Court eventually struck down, and it also meant that Republicans won an extra seat in the current, closely divided US House of Representatives.

But, if Purcell was violated when a federal court ordered Alabama to redraw its maps in the January before a congressional election, then it was certainly violated in Callais, where a lower court ordered Louisiana to redraw its maps in late April of an election year.

In its brief asking the Supreme Court to block the lower court’s decision in Callais, Louisiana’s lawyers argue that “this case screams for a Purcell stay,” pointing to a long line of deadlines the state’s election officials must comply with — the first deadline is this Wednesday — for the state’s congressional election to comply with state law.

Even if a federal court were to delay those deadlines, moreover, the late-breaking Callais decision means that candidates for congressional seats in Louisiana now have no idea who their constituents are and where they should campaign for the 2024 election. They won’t know that until the courts stop messing around and tell them which maps the state must use in its next election.

The two judges behind the Callais decision, meanwhile, are threatening to draw their own map if the state legislature does not produce a new map by June 4. But there’s no guarantee that the Callais judges’ map will comply with Judge Dick’s order in the Robinson litigation — which could potentially lead to an awkward situation where Judge Dick has to strike down maps drawn by her fellow judges.

None of this confusion makes any sense, and there is an easy way to solve it, at least for now. The Supreme Court should block the lower court’s decision in Callais for violating the Purcell principle. And it should order the state to use the new, legislatively drawn maps in the 2024 election.

All of the more difficult questions about whether those maps are too ugly to be used in future elections can be resolved by the Supreme Court at a later date.


Read full article on: vox.com
Anna Kendrick slams director for embarrassing her in front of 100 extras on set: ‘f–k you’
Kendrick called the incident a "very specific power move" on the director's part.
nypost.com
Harris calls on Arizona voters to pass abortion initiative — while misstating Trump’s positions
Vice President Kamala Harris urged Arizonans to turn out to vote for a measure reaffirming abortion access — and to support her while they’re at it — during a Thursday rally at which she again misstated former President Donald Trump’s policies on reproductive rights. “Arizona, to protect your right to make your own health care...
nypost.com
Yankees’ World Series failure started — and ended — with fundamental issues
When you are in charge of something and see redundant mistakes, you are either fixing them or condoning them — there is no middle ground at this level. 
nypost.com
Dodgers fan, 25, blows up hands with firework while celebrating World Series win over Yankees
Schadenfreude, Yankees fans?
nypost.com
Chart-topping rapper Young Thug accepts surprising plea deal in Georgia’s longest-ever criminal trial
Grammy Award-winning rapper Young Thug has agreed to take a plea deal amid the nearly year-long trial accusing him of being the ringleader of a Georgia gang, according to a report.
nypost.com
House Speaker Mike Johnson suggests DOJ went after Eric Adams for speaking out on migrant crisis: ‘He’s pushed back’
House Speaker Mike Johnson, campaigning in upstate New York, hinted that Mayor Eric Adams comments about the White House's migrant policies led to his federal indictment.
nypost.com
Action star Steven Seagal looking worse for wear in latest Russian propaganda appearance
"Seagal, as a rule, controlled the narrative hard when filming as he insisted on certain camera angles and nothing that accentuates his weight gain," a source said.
nypost.com
Vance tells Rogan he initially thought Trump had been killed in July assassination attempt: 'I was so pissed'
Vice presidential candidate JD Vance said he initially thought Trump had been killed at the infamous rally in July, saying his first response was to guard his family.
foxnews.com
Texas Senate candidate begs super PAC to stop ‘helping’ him with ‘Cucked King’ ads against Sen. Cruz
The other Ted vying for Texas Senate is demanding a mysterious pop-up Super PAC stop blasting out mailers and campaign ads supporting him, including ones calling incumbent Sen. Ted Cruz a "cuck" and "spineless simp."
nypost.com
Do you have to fill out your entire ballot?
Some voters may wish to only vote in some races. Here's what happens if you leave fields blank.
cbsnews.com
Kim Kardashian covered in scales as an ‘albino alligator’ for Halloween
The Skims mogul underwent the major transformation with the help of artist Alexis Stone.
nypost.com
JD Vance sits down with Joe Rogan, reveals ‘biggest difference’ between Donald Trump and Kamala Harris that voters should know
“That is anathema to everything that I believe in -- and that is what’s happened in the modern Democratic Party," the Ohio senator said during a three-hour interview on "The Joe Rogan Experience."
nypost.com
I’m a high school athlete — don’t let Prop 1 destroy girls’ sports
Biological boys are stealing medals away from deserving girls and posing a physical danger to females — but Democratic lawmakers want to let them dominate girls' sports statewide.
nypost.com
Juan Soto eyeing a historic $700 million MLB free agency contract
Word is that within two hours of the Yankees losing the World Series, eight rival teams checked in with interest, and by Thursday morning, the number was up to 11.
nypost.com
Suns vs. Clippers prediction: NBA picks, odds, bets Thursday
The Clippers return home for a Thursday night encounter with the Suns after an impressive two-game road trip, which included wins against Golden State and Denver.
nypost.com
Real estate mogul loses eviction battle at Chrysler Building — and is ordered to pay $21M in back rent
The stinging setback comes after Rosen sued the venerable college, which owns the land under the iconic Art-Deco skyscraper, following its move to evict his company RFR on Sept. 27.
nypost.com
LeBron James endorses Kamala Harris: 'The choice is clear to me'
Los Angeles Lakers superstar LeBron James voiced his support for Vice President Kamala Harris Thursday, saying "the choice is clear" to him.
foxnews.com
In a nation divided, local news is what unites communities
A newspaper in Palm Springs eliminated opinion pieces on national politics for a month to see if divisions in the community lessened. They did, a lesson for us.
washingtonpost.com
NY Republicans claim ‘election interference’ as more than 200 stamped mailers for GOP House candidate Alison Esposito found strewn near creek
The New York State Republican Party has filed a complaint with the US Postal Service after more than 200 pieces of party-paid mailers in support of congressional candidate Alison Esposito were found strewn near a creek in the Hudson Valley.
nypost.com
Ford to pause production of F-150 Lightning electric pickup trucks
Ford is temporarily halting production of its F-150 Lightning electric pickup truck as motorists cool on EVs.
cbsnews.com
Boys' water polo: City Section playoff pairings
CIF City Section boys' water polo playoff pairings.
latimes.com
Iowa election officials sued by 4 naturalized citizens who say their right to vote was harmed
Concern about elections being undermined by noncitizen voting has been a focus of political messaging this year from Republicans.
latimes.com
Driver of Trump garbage truck shares how viral moment came about: ‘Didn't really believe it at first’
Andrew Brisson, the vice president of LoadMaster, says a 'spur of the moment' phone call led to former President Trump using one of his company's garbage trucks.
foxnews.com
'Finding Mr. Christmas' challenges men to 'lead with kindness' for a role as a Hallmark hunk
The contestants of 'Finding Mr. Christmas' talk about how showing their emotions was a big part of the Hallmark reality competition series seeking a new leading man.
latimes.com
Riley Gaines mocks Mark Cuban for suggesting pro-Trump women aren't 'strong' or 'intelligent'
Former NCAA swimmer and OutKick contributor Riley Gaines called out billionaire Mark Cuban for comments about former President Trump never being seen around "strong" or "intelligent" women.
foxnews.com
Some Virginia voters think Vindman’s brother is the one on the ballot
The Vindman twins both played a role in Trump’s first impeachment As Eugene campaigns for Congress, some voters are confusing him with his brother, Alexander.
washingtonpost.com
NYC Muslim, Arab American community leaders back Trump at Bronx event: ‘Fed up with the woke idealogy’
An in-law of Donald Trump said the former Republican president is going to do well with Arab and Muslim American voters because they are sick of the Democratic Party's "woke ideology."
nypost.com
Viral video shows Trump staffer berating Dem mayor for trying to take down barricade before Allentown rally
A viral video shows a Trump staffer berating Allentown Mayor Matthew Tuerk for trying to take down barricades ahead of former President Trump’s rally Tuesday.
foxnews.com
Murdoch Children’s Research Institute unveils new initiative at American Australian Association benefit dinner
Sarah Murdoch announce a new collaboration between the Murdoch Children's Research Institute in Melbourne and the Gladstone Institutes in San Francisco that will work on helping children affected by heart disease.
foxnews.com
Passenger who pepper sprayed Uber driver for no reason indicted for hate crime: DA
Jennifer Guilbeault, 23, was indicted in New York State Supreme Court on two counts of assault as a hate crime for the unprovoked July 31 attack near Lexington Avenue and East 66th Street.
nypost.com
‘Walking Dead’ director unpacks the ‘senselessness’ of Glenn’s brutal death 8 years later: ‘That was rough’
"The Walking Dead" viewers weren't the only ones sad to see Steven Yeun's character killed off the series.
nypost.com
Harris billionaire surrogate's suggestion Trump women are dumb comes on heels of Biden’s 'garbage' comment
Harris campaign surrogate Mark Cuban's suggestion that women in Donald Trump's orbit are "weak" and "dumb" rocks the Kamala Harris campaign even as the furor rages over President Biden's dismissal of Trump supporters as “garbage."
foxnews.com
Apprentice alum joins Women for Trump, speaks out against 'sad' Harris-supporting contestants
After several alumni from the Apprentice publicly endorsed Kamala Harris, one former contestant who officially joined the Trump campaign spoke out against their decision.
foxnews.com
Terps are ‘a good mystery’ this year after bringing in 10 new players
Coach Brenda Frese revamped her roster after last season ended earlier than expected for the Maryland women’s basketball team.
washingtonpost.com
Stream It Or Skip It: ‘Go Ahead, Brother’ On Netflix, Where A Former Elite Police Officer Pays His Father’s Debts Any Way He Can
The new crime drama from Poland seems like it's complicated, but it really isn't.
nypost.com
Cowboys' Micah Parsons, DaRon Bland, Trevon Diggs in Danger of Missing Week 9
The Dallas Cowboys could be facing another reality where they are down even more defensive stars, as Micah Parsons, DaRon Bland, and Trevon Diggs did not practice.
newsweek.com
Roy Oswalt shades Gerrit Cole for not covering first base during disastrous fifth inning
The former big league starting pitcher took to social media after Gerrit Cole’s Game 5 mishap.
nypost.com
Civic duty leads to an inconvenient moral quagmire in Clint Eastwood's 'Juror #2'
Nicholas Hoult, J.K. Simmons and Toni Collette star in an unshowy Clint Eastwood production about the limits of American justice, rare in today's multiplex.
latimes.com
Elon Musk Lottery Could Give Trump 50,000 Pennsylvania Votes, Axelrod Says
"Given the closeness of the race, that could be really, really important," David Axelrod said on CNN.
newsweek.com
Skateboard-wielding suspect accused of destroying D.C.'s tiki torch statue
The destruction of the tiki torch statue occurred about 6:15 p.m. in D.C.’s Freedom Plaza, where the artwork once stood about eight feet tall.
1 h
washingtonpost.com
Republicans ask Pennsylvania court to put on hold decision on mail ballot envelope rules
The national and state Republican parties are appealing a Pennsylvania court ruling that would relax the rules for mail ballots.
1 h
latimes.com
NYPD academy graduate was inspired to become a cop by officer who saved his sister from bleeding to death after crash
Freshly minted Officer Xavier Duran, 35, was 9 years old in March 1998 when a big rig plowed into his family as they were crossing a street in the Corona neighborhood — crushing his then-6-year-old sister Jeanette’s leg, he told The Post.
1 h
nypost.com
Walz's closing campaign message to air on "The Late Show with Stephen Colbert"
Walz recorded the interview with Colbert Thursday in Bucks County, Pennsylvania​, underscoring the Harris campaign's focus on the battleground state in the 2024 election.
1 h
cbsnews.com
Actor Wendell Pierce says 'unruly' fans at Yankee Stadium prompted him to leave World Series Game 5 early
“Suits" actor Wendell Pierce said Wednesday that Game 5 of the World Series was spoiled for him due to a group of "unruly" fans at Yankee Stadium.
1 h
foxnews.com
Motion picture academy lays off staff at archive and library amid broader restructuring
The Academy of Motion Picture Arts and Sciences is restructuring its archive and library, cutting 16 staff members as part of a strategic effort to consolidate preservation efforts.
1 h
latimes.com
Lindsay Hubbard took marriage ‘off the table’ when she found out she was pregnant: ‘Nowhere near the top of my mind’
The "Summer House" star is expecting her first child, a baby girl, with her boyfriend, Dr. Turner Kufe.
1 h
nypost.com
Diddy investigators have interviewed male escorts about his infamous ‘Freak Off’ parties — and they’re ‘happy to talk’: source
"They were all encouraged to take Viagra and Cialis before the parties," said a federal law enforcement source.
1 h
nypost.com
Arizona high court rules Secretary of State must turn over list of noncitizens on voter roll
The Arizona Superior Court ordered Maricopa County to release a list of noncitizens registered to vote, siding with America First Legal's lawsuit.
1 h
foxnews.com