Tools
Change country:

What the Methodist split tells us about America

An LGBTQ+ flag flies over Union United Methodist Church in the South End of Boston on January 5, 2020. | Jessica Rinaldi/Boston Globe via Getty Images

A separation of church and church.

Last week, hundreds of United Methodist Church (UMC) delegates from around the world sat down to vote on whether or not to reverse a longstanding ban on the ordination of LGBTQ clergy. The decision would also determine whether or not to strike a rule that prohibited clergy from presiding over “homosexual unions.”

The room was uncharacteristically hushed as delegates logged their votes. They’d gathered to participate in a quadrennial General Conference, where an elected group of clergy and laypeople review and edit the rules and social stances of the church on a variety of subjects. When the results were announced, the room erupted in loud sobs and cheering. With this vote — and several others — over 50 years of church law, doctrine, and social stances aimed at restricting the full inclusion of LGBTQ methodists were reversed.

In a dramatic deviation from the staid (remarkably congressional) proceedings, the Methodists began to sing.

Church historian Ashley Boggan told Today, Explained’s Noel King that the UMC’s schism should matter to Methodists and non-Methodists alike. “If you look at Methodist history within the United States, it’s a great lens for looking at American history,” she said.

How did we get here?

For the last five years, the United Methodist Church has been fighting over its stance on LGBTQ members.

In a one-off special session in 2019, the UMC had voted to tighten its prohibitions on LGBTQ members — a decision that nearly half of all UMC congregations across the country went on to publicly reject in the following years. So, in 2022, a splinter denomination was born: the Global Methodist Church. Traditionalist congregations had seen the writing on the wall: Change was coming, and they didn’t want to be part of it.

Conservative churches began leaving the denomination in droves, and by the time the General Conference convened this year, a quarter of US congregations had jumped ship. It was this newly slimmed-down UMC that voted to reverse the church’s anti-LGBTQ positions earlier this month.

What Methodists say about America

The Methodist church developed in tandem with the United States. Both are 18th-century experiments in democracy, and each has weathered the great challenges of the last two centuries — war, reunion, and an ever-expanding understanding of personhood — in distinct but parallel lanes.

Throughout the 19th century, as the United States grappled with the notion of Black personhood and the reality of chattel slavery, so too did the Methodists. In 1844, 40 percent of Methodist congregations split off to form a pro-slavery splinter congregation.

That was the last time this many Methodists split off from the main denomination. Fifteen years later, the Confederacy seceded as well, and a bloody civil war shortly followed. This parallel has not gone unnoticed.

According to Boggan, in the decades that followed, this pattern repeated itself. As the post-war US reconstructed itself, the Methodist church followed suit. In a 1939 merger, the Southern and Northern Methodists were once again united. As states enacted Jim Crow laws across the country, the Methodists created a segregated system of their own.

The Methodist church became a sort of bellwether for larger national sentiment, and this extended beyond racial politics, The church granted full ordination rights to women in 1956, and seven years later, Betty Friedan’s The Feminine Mystique mainstreamed “the problem with no name.”

While this all might lead us to fear that the current breakup in the Methodist church is yet again a harbinger of violence, it is helpful to remember this caveat: the Civil War-era United States was extremely Methodist. According to church historian Nathan Hatch, in the runup to the Civil War, the Methodist church was “the most extensive national institution other than the Federal government.” The sheer size of the denomination meant that the political reality of the church would eventually become the political reality of the country.

Today, church membership is in decline, and the institutional influence of mainline protestant churches is much diminished (although to exactly what effect is debatable). The church is not, as it was in the 19th century, a small-scale model of the country. Today, according to Boggan, the church acts more like a lens: a way to see broader national tensions work themselves out on a smaller scale.

What next?

At the General Conference, several traditionalists told me that their local congregations were still actively considering leaving the denomination. Dixie Brewster, a conservative delegate from Kansas, told me she feels like the UMC is no longer a big-tent denomination, and “it seems like there’s no place at the table for the conservative view of traditional marriage and family.”

I’m not sure these anxieties are warranted. On paper, the church is an objectively bigger tent today than it was last year. Queer people can pursue ordination, and clergy now have the right to perform same-sex weddings.

Notably, a clear majority of delegates also voted to pass a statement that formally enshrined the rights of traditional clergy to refuse to officiate a same-sex marriage. In a 479–203 vote, the UMC decided that “all clergy have the right to exercise and preserve their conscience when requested to perform any marriage, union, or blessing of any couple.”

It appears that this now “more progressive” UMC is walking a sort of quasi-libertarian road toward progress. By “removing restrictions on paper,” Boggan said, the conversations about how best to love one’s neighbor must change venues. No longer enshrined in the black-and-white text of doctrine, debate is forced back inside the four walls of the church.

While the Methodist church was once a reliable indicator of national sentiment, it lifted its prohibition on gay marriage nearly a decade after Obergefell v. Hodges did the same for the rest of the country. This is not to say that LGBTQ rights in the United States are set in stone. In Florida, legislators have decided that while you can say gay, you have to say it carefully. Most Republican-run states have restricted or outright banned gender-affirming care for minors, and in states where restrictions on LGBTQ people have gotten tighter, reported hate crimes against LGBTQ elementary and high school students have quadrupled.

It is unclear whether or not the United Methodist Church will continue to embody these tensions. The mass exodus of conservative congregations was orchestrated by what Boggan called the “evangelical wing” of the UMC. The wing of the church most actively engaging in conservative culture wars has taken itself out of the conversation.

Whether the Methodists pull back together or splinter further is still an open question.

This story originally appeared in Today, Explained, Vox’s flagship daily newsletter. Sign up here for future editions.


Read full article on: vox.com
Stevie Nicks doesn't have many regrets, but waiting until 70 to vote is one of them
Stevie Nicks, who has endorsed Vice President Kamala Harris in the 2024 presidential election, admits she never voted until she was 70. 'I regret that.'
6 m
latimes.com
Young Thug pleads guilty to gang, drug and gun charges in long and winding RICO trial
Young Thug's stop-and-go racketeering trial may soon be over after nearly a year and several twists. The Atlanta rapper just pleaded guilty to several charges.
9 m
latimes.com
Watch Live: New York City’s Halloween Parade 2024
Get a front-row seat to see New York City’s craziest creatures of the night with a live stream of the 51st Village Halloween Parade from lower Manhattan at 7pm ET. This year’s theme is “Meow!” with a focus on celebrating our feline friends.
nypost.com
The NFL’s Most Annoying Celebrity Is About to Make Himself Irrelevant
We may all soon finally be free of this man.
slate.com
‘Teams are circling’ on Giannis Antetokounmpo amid Bucks’ slow start
A dreadful start to the season in Milwaukee already has the sharks circling in the water over the team’s superstar. 
nypost.com
'Here' takes the elements of a 'Gump' reunion and flattens them into faux-cosmic tedium
Tom Hanks and Robin Wright rejoin filmmaker Robert Zemeckis for a stunty, pointless drama about the passing of time captured from one fixed vantage point.
latimes.com
New Conservative Poll Shows Key Shift for Donald Trump
Trump has improved on his lead in Georgia, according to a new Rasmussen Reports survey.
newsweek.com
More than 60 million people have voted early in 2024 race so far
More than 60 million people have already voted in the 2024 presidential race. CBS News deputy director of elections and data analytics Kabir Khanna is tracking the mountain of ballots cast in the battleground states so far and what it could mean for the eventual outcome.
cbsnews.com
Harris seizes on Trump's pledge to protect women 'whether they like it or not'
Vice President Kamala Harris slammed Donald Trump on Thursday, saying the former president's pledge to protect women was "offensive to everybody."
abcnews.go.com
Roy quizzes DOJ on 'coordination' with left-wing groups over suits challenging states' voter roll purges
Rep. Chip Roy, R-Texas, is asking questions of the Department of Justice about what he says could be coordination with left-wing groups on lawsuits challenging voter roll purges.
foxnews.com
Trump facing backlash for remark about protecting women
Former President Donald Trump is facing criticism for a comment about women he made at a rally Wednesday night. "I'm going to do it whether the women like it or not. I'm going to protect them," Trump said. CBS News' Lilia Luciano and Nikole Killion have the latest on the backlash.
cbsnews.com
Anna Kendrick slams director for embarrassing her in front of 100 extras on set: ‘f–k you’
Kendrick called the incident a "very specific power move" on the director's part.
nypost.com
Woman Decides To Donate Toy Cat Ignored, Then Pet Throws a Curveball
The cat finally showed interest in the toy after months of not using it.
newsweek.com
Longtime sportscaster Bob Costas says presidential election is a question of morality, not politics
Sportscaster Bob Costas has often spoken about issues beyond the sports world, including politics. He argued the upcoming election is a question of morality, not politics.
foxnews.com
Harris calls on Arizona voters to pass abortion initiative — while misstating Trump’s positions
Vice President Kamala Harris urged Arizonans to turn out to vote for a measure reaffirming abortion access — and to support her while they’re at it — during a Thursday rally at which she again misstated former President Donald Trump’s policies on reproductive rights. “Arizona, to protect your right to make your own health care...
nypost.com
Yankees’ World Series failure started — and ended — with fundamental issues
When you are in charge of something and see redundant mistakes, you are either fixing them or condoning them — there is no middle ground at this level. 
nypost.com
Donald Trump Files Lawsuit Against CBS News: What We Know
Trump's lawsuit filed Thursday alleges that CBS News' 60 Minutes interview with Kamala Harris misled the public.
newsweek.com
Dodgers fan, 25, blows up hands with firework while celebrating World Series win over Yankees
Schadenfreude, Yankees fans?
nypost.com
Chart-topping rapper Young Thug accepts surprising plea deal in Georgia’s longest-ever criminal trial
Grammy Award-winning rapper Young Thug has agreed to take a plea deal amid the nearly year-long trial accusing him of being the ringleader of a Georgia gang, according to a report.
nypost.com
House Speaker Mike Johnson suggests DOJ went after Eric Adams for speaking out on migrant crisis: ‘He’s pushed back’
House Speaker Mike Johnson, campaigning in upstate New York, hinted that Mayor Eric Adams comments about the White House's migrant policies led to his federal indictment.
nypost.com
Kamala Harris May Be Within Striking Distance in Solidly Red State: Poll
In Alaska, the Democrat has gained ground on her opponent, former President Donald Trump, in recent weeks.
newsweek.com
Action star Steven Seagal looking worse for wear in latest Russian propaganda appearance
"Seagal, as a rule, controlled the narrative hard when filming as he insisted on certain camera angles and nothing that accentuates his weight gain," a source said.
nypost.com
Vance tells Rogan he initially thought Trump had been killed in July assassination attempt: 'I was so pissed'
Vice presidential candidate JD Vance said he initially thought Trump had been killed at the infamous rally in July, saying his first response was to guard his family.
foxnews.com
Texas Senate candidate begs super PAC to stop ‘helping’ him with ‘Cucked King’ ads against Sen. Cruz
The other Ted vying for Texas Senate is demanding a mysterious pop-up Super PAC stop blasting out mailers and campaign ads supporting him, including ones calling incumbent Sen. Ted Cruz a "cuck" and "spineless simp."
nypost.com
Do you have to fill out your entire ballot?
Some voters may wish to only vote in some races. Here's what happens if you leave fields blank.
cbsnews.com
Kim Kardashian covered in scales as an ‘albino alligator’ for Halloween
The Skims mogul underwent the major transformation with the help of artist Alexis Stone.
nypost.com
JD Vance sits down with Joe Rogan, reveals ‘biggest difference’ between Donald Trump and Kamala Harris that voters should know
“That is anathema to everything that I believe in -- and that is what’s happened in the modern Democratic Party," the Ohio senator said during a three-hour interview on "The Joe Rogan Experience."
nypost.com
I’m a high school athlete — don’t let Prop 1 destroy girls’ sports
Biological boys are stealing medals away from deserving girls and posing a physical danger to females — but Democratic lawmakers want to let them dominate girls' sports statewide.
nypost.com
Juan Soto eyeing a historic $700 million MLB free agency contract
Word is that within two hours of the Yankees losing the World Series, eight rival teams checked in with interest, and by Thursday morning, the number was up to 11.
nypost.com
BetMGM Bonus Code NEWSWEEK200: Earn Instant $200 Bonus for NFL Week 9 Games
Eligible new users who register with the BetMGM bonus code NEWSWEEK200 will kick off NFL Week 9 with $200 in bonus bets.
newsweek.com
Suns vs. Clippers prediction: NBA picks, odds, bets Thursday
The Clippers return home for a Thursday night encounter with the Suns after an impressive two-game road trip, which included wins against Golden State and Denver.
nypost.com
Real estate mogul loses eviction battle at Chrysler Building — and is ordered to pay $21M in back rent
The stinging setback comes after Rosen sued the venerable college, which owns the land under the iconic Art-Deco skyscraper, following its move to evict his company RFR on Sept. 27.
nypost.com
Actor Nathan Chasing Horse Hit With New Sexual Abuse Charges
On Thursday, a Nevada grand jury re-indicted Nathan Chasing Horse, accusing the former 'Dances with Wolves' actor of decades-long sexual abuse.
newsweek.com
LeBron James endorses Kamala Harris: 'The choice is clear to me'
Los Angeles Lakers superstar LeBron James voiced his support for Vice President Kamala Harris Thursday, saying "the choice is clear" to him.
foxnews.com
In a nation divided, local news is what unites communities
A newspaper in Palm Springs eliminated opinion pieces on national politics for a month to see if divisions in the community lessened. They did, a lesson for us.
washingtonpost.com
NASCAR Team Confirms Martinsville Driver After Jones Suspension Fallout
Hattori Racing Enterprises has confirmed that Landen Lewis will be competing in the Zip Buy Now, Pay Later 200 race at Martinsville Speedway.
newsweek.com
NY Republicans claim ‘election interference’ as more than 200 stamped mailers for GOP House candidate Alison Esposito found strewn near creek
The New York State Republican Party has filed a complaint with the US Postal Service after more than 200 pieces of party-paid mailers in support of congressional candidate Alison Esposito were found strewn near a creek in the Hudson Valley.
nypost.com
Ford to pause production of F-150 Lightning electric pickup trucks
Ford is temporarily halting production of its F-150 Lightning electric pickup truck as motorists cool on EVs.
cbsnews.com
Boys' water polo: City Section playoff pairings
CIF City Section boys' water polo playoff pairings.
latimes.com
Iowa election officials sued by 4 naturalized citizens who say their right to vote was harmed
Concern about elections being undermined by noncitizen voting has been a focus of political messaging this year from Republicans.
latimes.com
Driver of Trump garbage truck shares how viral moment came about: ‘Didn't really believe it at first’
Andrew Brisson, the vice president of LoadMaster, says a 'spur of the moment' phone call led to former President Trump using one of his company's garbage trucks.
foxnews.com
ICE Confirms Chicago Shooting Suspect Entered US Illegally
Sidi Mohamed Abdallahi is facing multiple felony counts after a Jewish man was shot in the Rogers Park neighborhood on Saturday.
newsweek.com
'Finding Mr. Christmas' challenges men to 'lead with kindness' for a role as a Hallmark hunk
The contestants of 'Finding Mr. Christmas' talk about how showing their emotions was a big part of the Hallmark reality competition series seeking a new leading man.
latimes.com
Riley Gaines mocks Mark Cuban for suggesting pro-Trump women aren't 'strong' or 'intelligent'
Former NCAA swimmer and OutKick contributor Riley Gaines called out billionaire Mark Cuban for comments about former President Trump never being seen around "strong" or "intelligent" women.
foxnews.com
Some Virginia voters think Vindman’s brother is the one on the ballot
The Vindman twins both played a role in Trump’s first impeachment As Eugene campaigns for Congress, some voters are confusing him with his brother, Alexander.
washingtonpost.com
Trump Allies Issue Warning That He Could Lose Critical Battleground State
Allies of former President Donald Trump have highlighted that the Republican nominee could lose Pennsylvania due to higher women early voter turnout.
newsweek.com
NYC Muslim, Arab American community leaders back Trump at Bronx event: ‘Fed up with the woke idealogy’
An in-law of Donald Trump said the former Republican president is going to do well with Arab and Muslim American voters because they are sick of the Democratic Party's "woke ideology."
nypost.com
Viral video shows Trump staffer berating Dem mayor for trying to take down barricade before Allentown rally
A viral video shows a Trump staffer berating Allentown Mayor Matthew Tuerk for trying to take down barricades ahead of former President Trump’s rally Tuesday.
foxnews.com