Εργαλεία
Να αλλάξει χώρα :

Biden screwed up on inflation — badly

President Joe Biden wearing a suit and tie, looking down and not smiling.
President Joe Biden in the East Room of the White House on November 13, 2024. | Chip Somodevilla/Getty Images

There’s a pretty widespread consensus about which issue was most responsible for Kamala Harris’s defeat: inflation.

There’s much less consensus on what, if anything, Democrats could have done differently about it.

Polls have been clear for years that voters were irate about the inflation that occurred under the Biden administration — the highest in decades. Yet it’s also clear that Biden’s policies were not the primary cause of that inflation. It was a global phenomenon in the post-pandemic return to normal, exacerbated by Russia’s invasion of Ukraine in early 2022.

Some of Biden’s defenders have argued he did the best he could with a bad hand. After all, his economic policy eventually resulted in a “soft landing” where inflation rates dropped without a recession. Additionally, incumbent parties have been struggling in elections nearly everywhere, and Harris’s loss was comparatively small compared to incumbents’ blowout defeats overseas.

There’s another theory of the case, which argues that Biden’s team shouldn’t be let off the hook so easily. The administration, critics say, screwed up on inflation in two distinct and avoidable ways. 

First, according to economists, the Biden administration’s policies worsened inflation. This was not inevitable — policymakers ignored critics’ warnings at the time that their policies would likely have this effect. 

Then, once the problem became evident, Democrats didn’t pivot to genuine inflation-fighting policies, such as deficit reduction. Instead, they mainly chose to rebrand their existing policy priorities as “inflation-reducing” or cost-reducing, sometimes falsely. The public didn’t buy it.

All this suggests a reckoning is needed in Democratic policy circles, to address what went so wrong and why.

The first mistake: The American Rescue Plan was much too big

Traditionally, the purpose of an economic stimulus bill is to fill what economists refer to as the “output gap”: the amount of economic activity recessionary pressures are currently suppressing. If there’s a bigger output gap, you need a bigger stimulus. But if a stimulus is too big, the risk is overstimulating the economy and spurring high rates of inflation.

By the time Biden took office, the US had already passed two very large pandemic aid bills, the $1.9 trillion CARES Act of March 2020 and a $900 billion follow-up bill in December 2020. The Congressional Budget Office (CBO) estimated in early 2021 that the remaining output gap over the next two years would be about $600 billion.

But Democrats ended up passing a far bigger stimulus than any credible estimate of the output gap required — they enacted the $1.9 trillion American Rescue Plan. They didn’t just overshoot the output gap, they blew past it by more than $1 trillion, assuming the CBO estimate was accurate.

How, exactly, Democrats decided to size their bill at $1.9 trillion was something of a mystery at the time. The fullest accounting of it I’ve read was in Franklin Foer’s book, The Last Politician, which lays out the following sequence of events:

  • In mid-December (with Senate control still unclear pending the following month’s Georgia runoffs), Biden’s team proposed he try to pass a $2.4 trillion bill, about half of which was pandemic aid. The other half would be for progressive priorities like green energy, child care, and infrastructure.
  • But Biden pushed back. He thought the proposed bill was too big and that he should prioritize pandemic relief only.
  • After Democrats won the Georgia runoffs in January 2021, Biden and incoming White House chief of staff Ron Klain proposed a $1.3 trillion pandemic relief package to incoming Senate Majority Leader Chuck Schumer. The proposal “took Schumer aback,” Foer writes, because “it wasn’t nearly high enough.”
  • The reason was that Schumer had been talking with Democratic senators for months about things they wanted to put in a pandemic aid package if they didn’t need Republican support to pass one. All those demands, he told Biden, would likely amount to about $2 trillion. 
  • So Biden acquiesced to the bigger number, and it passed Congress as the $1.9 trillion American Rescue Plan.

There could be more to the story, but by this account, the sizing of the American Rescue Plan was determined largely by political concerns — the need to please Democratic senators — and not by economic analysis. (The eventual package contained stimulus checks, expanded unemployment insurance benefits, an expanded child tax credit, and aid to state and local governments. Some of that helped people in need, but much of it was not so well-targeted.)

Critics, such as economist Larry Summers — who’d served as Barack Obama’s top economic adviser — warned at the time that this seemed too big. “There is a chance,” Summers wrote in February 2021, that it “will set off inflationary pressures of a kind we have not seen in a generation.” 

But Summers’s star had fallen in a Democratic Party that had moved left. Mainstream economists, too, had far less influence in the Biden administration, compared to Obama’s. Biden’s administration was more keen on the advice of progressive reformers, lawyers, and political aides.

Democrats pushed back furiously against Summers’s criticisms. They argued that the risks of going too small were far bigger than going too big (since Congress would be unlikely to approve new spending if needed later) and that Obama’s too-small stimulus in 2009 was one of his biggest mistakes. (Though Obama’s approval recovery in time for his 2012 reelection is looking pretty good right about now.) 

Democrats had also likely been conditioned to ignore concerns about inflation after a decade in which deficit hawks had constantly warned of imminent inflation that never seemed to arrive, and after Trump had spent freely with no practical or political consequence.

All of this, in retrospect, seems like wishful thinking — justifications for what Democrats wanted to do politically, rather than a serious analysis of how best to manage the economy.

How much did it hurt? Inflation increased by about 7 percentage points in 2021, and estimates suggest the American Rescue Plan was responsible for between 1 and 3 percentage points on its own.

In other words, there would have been inflation anyway, but quantities matter. Four, 5, or 6 percent inflation would have been significantly better than 7. Prices wouldn’t have risen as high, and interest rates wouldn’t have needed to have been hiked as high to quash inflation later on. (The public, as a rule, dislikes inflation, and they also dislike aspects of the ensuing high-interest-rate environment, like high mortgage rates.)

It is true that the US economy ended up quite strong by many metrics — strong GDP growth, low unemployment, a booming stock market — and in the international context. But that growth came with inflation and price growth that ate into much of workers’ gains, and the American Rescue Plan’s poverty-fighting policies proved temporary when they later expired. And given how much stimulus had already passed, the US may have been on track to recover perfectly well, albeit a bit more slowly, without Biden’s added spending, so it’s unclear whether his policies actually deserve credit for the economy’s strengths.

The second mistake: Democrats’ economic policymaking energy was misplaced 

Democrats’ errors, critics contend, continued once it became clear inflation was really happening at a level unseen for decades. This was, simply, not a problem the party’s political experts or political coalition was well-equipped to solve.

The party’s economic policy under Biden was focused very heavily on bespoke interventions into various parts of the economy or toward various constituencies. These policies included a sectoral restructuring for clean energy and semi-conductors, an expanded child tax credit, ribbon-cuttings on new bridges, an effort to rein in big tech and cut down on corporate mergers, and loan forgiveness for student debtors (some of which likely worsened inflation).

Democrats’ hope was that all of that would add up and they’d get credit from the electorate for doing good things — for “delivering.” But because inflation affected everyone, not just workers in certain industries or people getting certain government benefits, it mattered more to voters than Democrats’ various scattered policy accomplishments. To shore up their economic bona fides, Democrats may have been better off focusing on the broader economy rather than these various projects.

Furthermore, once inflation did become undeniably painful, Democrats pursued a somewhat cynical strategy of rebranding the policies they wanted to pass anyway as inflation-fighting initiatives. This most famously occurred with the so-called Inflation Reduction Act — mainly a bill to fight climate change, it did not actually reduce inflation (and wasn’t meant to; it got that name as a sop to wavering Sen. Joe Manchin). The administration also pitched its toughened antitrust enforcement as anti-inflationary, but these individual interventions were insufficient to make a real dent in an economy-wide problem.

It is true that, once inflation had gotten going, the main determinant in how it would play out was the Federal Reserve’s approach to interest rates. Given norms against presidential influence on interest rate decisions, Biden’s decision to reappoint Fed chair Jerome Powell in late 2021 was his key decision there. Powell got some criticism for initially being slow to act on inflation, but he has since been praised for hitting the sweet spot of raising interest rates enough to rein in inflation while avoiding a recession. Biden could have appointed someone else, but it’s far from clear that a different person would have done a better job (particularly if he appointed a progressive, given widespread progressive skepticism of the inflation problem’s seriousness).

In theory, Biden could also have tried to fight inflation by urging Congress to cut spending. Both Bill Clinton and Barack Obama pivoted to deficit reduction after midterm defeats in far less inflationary environments, but Biden never made this pivot. In his battle with House Republicans over spending levels in 2023, he fought to keep spending high, and the result was basically a continuance of the status quo. 

If Biden had advocated spending cuts, he would have faced serious pushback from progressives. But if it helped rein in inflation, perhaps it would have been politically worthwhile. Biden could also have tried to drive prices down by lowering some of the Trump administration’s high tariffs — but that would have won the ire of labor unions and national security hawks.

So to the extent voters concluded that Biden’s administration was not making fighting inflation its top priority, they were clearly correct: Democrats had many other things they cared about more.

The lessons

Biden was faced with a genuinely tough environment and truly challenging economic problems, and he had his fair share of bad luck. But he also had some good luck: despite record inflation, he got away without an actual recession, and Powell managed the soft landing. There’s no reason the US economy was necessarily doomed to similar struggles as, say, Europe’s, which was weaker to begin with and hit far harder by the impact of Russia’s war in Ukraine. 

Democrats also made their own bad luck. In retrospect, the assumption in 2021 that it was okay to greatly overstimulate the economy because the Fed could always correct it later with interest rates was disastrous. Politically, the enduring higher prices from inflation made Democrats extremely unpopular — and, once interest rates did go up quite a lot, a public used to a decade of easy money hated that too. Economically, throwing gas on the fire led to a bigger fire, which meant the ensuing interest rate hikes ended up having to be higher and more painful.

This is not just hindsight. Many of these criticisms were made at the time and dismissed. Through it all, the party’s brain trust demonstrated a preference for coalition-pleasing happy talk rather than a willingness to seriously grapple with what was going wrong or what the public was unhappy about. The policies Democrats were most excited about turned out to be utterly ineffective at making Biden popular, and his economic record became toxically unpopular.

Blueprint, a Democratic polling initiative, published research showing that one of the most effective arguments for pushing swing voters away from Harris was that “inflation was too high under the Biden-Harris administration.” So in the blame game over Harris’s defeat, Democrats need to think hard about what they could and should have done differently to have produced different results. As it is, Harris’s loss suggests their governance on the issue was an unequivocal failure.


Lue koko artikkeli aiheesta: vox.com
Treasury secretary contenders Howard Lutnick and Scott Bessent in ‘knife fight’ for the job | Reporter Replay
Two top contenders to serve as Donald Trump’s Treasury secretary are engaged in what is being reported as a “knife fight” — and the president-elect is apparently widening his list of choices after he is said to have soured on one of them, according to reports. NY Post reporter Ariel Zilber shares this story.
nypost.com
Paraguay-Bolivia, duelo vital en la altura por ir al Mundial
Entonada tras vencer a la campeona mundial Argentina, la selección de Paraguay que dirige Gustavo Alfaro se enfrentará el martes a una urgida Bolivia en la altura de El Alto, la ciudad situada a unos 4.150 metros sobre el nivel del mar por las eliminatorias de la Copa del Mundo.
latimes.com
'Sanctuary' city mayor vows she will defy Trump's mass deportation push: 'Causing widespread fear'
Boston Mayor Michelle Wu says her city won't be cooperating with the mass deportation operation ready to be launched by the Trump administration in January.
foxnews.com
‘Like-new’ Dyson Airwrap is less than half a new one for Black Friday
No need to pay for a blowout again.
nypost.com
Chile se juega una 'final' ante Venezuela
Tras un incómodo empate sin goles con Perú, Chile se jugará seguir en la batalla por uno de los boletos a la Copa Mundial 2026 cuando reciba a Venezuela el martes, para un partido que hinchas y jugadores han definido como una "final".
latimes.com
Cher got transgender son Chaz Bono’s ‘blessing’ to write about him in her memoir
Cher revealed that she had a thoughtful approach to writing about her son, Chaz Bono in “Cher: The Memoir: Part One.” The singer shared that Chaz gave his mom his “blessing” to use his deadname, Chastity, in the book. Watch the full video to learn more about her reason for doing this.  Subscribe to our...
nypost.com
Bill Belichick’s girlfriend still recovering from Tom Brady roast
Bill Belichick’s 24-year-old girlfriend took to instagram on Friday to commemorate the six-month anniversary of Netflix’s famous special, “The Roast of Tom Brady.”
nypost.com
This beloved NYC theater is finally poised to sell — after decades of vacancy
The show might finally go on for the Metro Theater on the Upper West Side, which has sat vacant since 2005 and is in the home stretch of being sold.
nypost.com
Vladimir Shklyarov, ballet star who dazzled with Russia's Mariinsky Theatre, dies at 39
Vladimir Shklyarov, who danced with Russia's prestigious Mariinsky Ballet Theatre, died Friday after reportedly falling from a fifth-floor balcony. He was 39.
latimes.com
Stray Kids announce ‘Dominate World Tour,’ Citi Field show. Get tickets
The K-Pop icons are scheduled to get the party started in Flushing on June 18.
nypost.com
Cher claims Sonny Bono isolated her from peers, swindled her during disastrous marriage: ‘He took all my money’
The diva was duped by Bono, who had set up a company called Cher Enterprises in which he owned 95 percent, with the other 5 percent going to his lawyer.
nypost.com
House Ethics Committee may meet on Gaetz report
There are reports of a potential gathering of the House Ethics Committee to discuss the investigation into former Florida Rep. Matt Gaetz. CBS News' Nikole Killion has more on the probe and its findings possibly being made public.
cbsnews.com
12 Thanksgiving stuffing and dressing recipes for every kind of feast
These Thanksgiving stuffing and dressing recipes include something for everyone, including vegetarian and gluten-free options.
washingtonpost.com
Netflix 'cannot get away with' production issues for NFL games, ex-star Shawne Merriman warns
Former NFL star linebacker Shawne Merriman weighed in on the massive production issues Netflix experienced during the Jake Paul-Mike Tyson fight.
foxnews.com
How to watch Texans vs. Cowboys live for free on Monday Night Football
Can Dallas rise to the occasion on their home turf?
nypost.com
Stream It Or Skip It: ‘Carville: Winning is Everything, Stupid’ on Max, An Immediately Outdated Documentary About A Prominent Democrat Strategist
Sure, James Carville is an icon in political circles, and deserves a biodoc. But in the current moment, this film feels like a failure.
nypost.com
Suspect in custody after New York City stabbing spree leaves 2 men dead, woman with critical wounds: police
Two men were killed and a woman left fighting for her life after a homeless New York City man allegedly committed a series of random stabbings, police said.
foxnews.com
L.A.'s wildest taco pop-up opens its debut restaurant in El Sereno
Black-metal-inspired taco pop-up Evil Cooks, known for its subversive dishes and genre-bending taco omakase, opens a bricks-and-mortar in El Sereno.
latimes.com
A massive 80M travelers will hit the road this Thanksgiving, setting record, AAA predicts
Millions of Americans are booking planes, trains and automobiles to gather around the table with their loved ones this holiday season.
nypost.com
Could Biden's decision on Ukraine weapons use be start of world war with Russia?
Russian officials are reacting to President Biden's move to allow Ukraine to fire U.S.-made and supplied missiles deeper into Russia, a request that Ukraine's Volodymyr Zelenskyy has been making for some time. CBS News' Charlie D'Agata reports.
cbsnews.com
Colombia busca ante Ecuador dar un paso casi definitivo hacia el Mundial
Con el objetivo de conseguir un triunfo que le permita acariciar la clasificación al Mundial 2026, Colombia recibirá el martes a Ecuador en Barranquilla, donde se mantiene invicto en la actual eliminatoria sudamericana.
latimes.com
Why This Alaskan Town Will Experience 64 Days of Darkness
Utqiaġvik undergoes the unique experience of polar night—which for them is a period of more than 60 days of darkness when the residents live without daylight.
time.com
Lucy Liu makes like Taylor Swift in red checked Versace skirt suit
Putting a spin on Swift's separates, the 55-year-old star chose a collarless coat and matching skirt in a wider plaid pattern while promoting "Red One."
nypost.com
Celebrate the holidays with your favorite ‘Housewives’ and ‘Love Is Blind’ stars at Page Six’s ‘Virtual Reali-Tea’ live show
Kelly Bensimon and Jennifer Aydin are among the reality TV icons toasting the season with co-hosts Evan Real and Danny Murphy at Chelsea Table & Stage on Dec. 2.
nypost.com
Jake Paul’s win over Mike Tyson sets staggering combat sports betting record
If you didn't fall asleep during the Jake Paul-Mike Tyson fight, it's probably because you were betting on it.
nypost.com
Judge slashes black UPS driver’s bias verdict by nearly $200M, ruling jurors acted unreasonably
The judge accepted UPS' request to throw out a $198 million in punitive damages award, finding jurors acted unreasonably in awarding the sum to Tahvio Gratton.
nypost.com
32 best Christmas gifts and toys for 4-year-old boys and girls in 2024
We're all about the 4-year-olds — here's the only expert-backed toy guide you'll ever need.
nypost.com
Jessica Simpson ‘heartbroken’ while trying to ‘figure out’ Eric Johnson separation
Hopefully this will be her “final heartbreak.” Jessica Simpson is reportedly “heartbroken” following her split from her husband Eric Johnson. Watch the full video to learn more about how she feels about the breakup.   Subscribe to our YouTube for the latest on all your favorite stars.
nypost.com
Environmental groups present differing opinions of Trump's energy and environment appointees
Environmental groups are reacting to President-elect Trump's nominees to head energy and environmental issues in his administration.
foxnews.com
‘Yellowstone’ Season 5 Episode 10 Recap: “The Apocalypse of Change”
“I will be the last thing on this planet your rotten f***ing eyes will ever see. And I will be smiling.”
nypost.com
Biden misses G20 group photo in latest embarrassment: ‘He’s behind the palm tree!’
White House spokespeople insisted that organizers didn't wait long enough for him to arrive alongside Canadian Prime Minster Justin Trudeau, who also missed the photo, as did Italian PM Giorgia Meloni.
nypost.com
Katt Williams calls out ‘SNL’ for constantly using a woman to parody him
Imitation is the sincerest form of flattery. Katt Williams shared his reaction to “Saturday Night Live” using a woman to parody him on the show. Watch the full video to learn more about his feelings on the matter.  Subscribe to our YouTube for the latest on all your favorite stars.
nypost.com
What will happen to the Gaetz House Ethics report?
A draft of the House Ethics report on former Florida Rep. Matt Gaetz could be leaked if it's not released to the public. Mia McCarthy, a politics reporter at POLITICO, joins CBS News with more on how the findings may emerge.
cbsnews.com
Help! I Encouraged My Husband to Quit His Job to Pursue His Passion. What a Mistake.
Everything is a mess.
slate.com
Natasha Rothwell on Her Memorable Firsts
Actor and showrunner Natasha Rothwell shares stories about memorable first experiences.
time.com
Podcaster Taylor Strecker says Brittany Mahomes is ‘not worthy’ of Taylor Swift friendship: ‘Get away from her’
The "Cruel Summer" singer has been friends with Brittany since she began dating Kansas City Chiefs player Travis Kelce in 2023.
nypost.com
Will Spirit Airlines bankruptcy disrupt holiday travel?
The Spirit Airlines bankruptcy news may not affect holiday travel but could limit some service options in the future due to cost-cutting measures. CBS News MoneyWatch correspondent Kelly O'Grady has more on the airline, and new details on the stock market rally after the 2024 elections.
cbsnews.com
Ben Affleck is confident AI cannot replace Hollywood movies for this reason
Ben Affleck explained how he believes artificial intelligence will impact Hollywood, saying that movies will be "one of the last things" replaced by AI.
foxnews.com
WWII vet who fought at Battle of the Bulge finally gets high school diploma — 82 years after dropping out
"I never expected to be honored like this," Anthony Simeone, of Cranston, Rhode Island, told the crowd at a ceremony last week. “I am so honored.”
nypost.com
House committee demands interviews with FEMA employees about order to avoid Trump supporters' houses
House lawmakers want to talk to the FEMA employees who oversaw policy in Florida during Hurricane Milton recovery, as FEMA Administrator Criswell faces a congressional grilling Tuesday.
foxnews.com
Paul Teal, 'One Tree Hill' actor, dead at 35
Paul Teal, known for his work on the WB teen drama "One Tree Hill," and working on "Deep Water" with Ben Affleck in 2022, died Friday. He was 35.
foxnews.com
Jake Paul’s girlfriend pays tribute to him after Mike Tyson win
Jake Paul's girlfriend, Jutta Leerdam, said his unanimous decision victory over legendary boxer Mike Tyson was "bigger than the Super Bowl" Friday night.
nypost.com
Amazon's Black Friday and Cyber Monday deal events kick off on Nov. 21 and 30
Amazon's Black Friday and Cyber Monday events give customers 12 days of big savings. Here are seven deals that are already live.
foxnews.com
Michael J. Fox admits it’s ‘hard for me’ to maintain humor during Parkinson’s battle
Michael J. Fox is still showcasing his humor and hobbies as he continues to deal with Parkinson’s disease.
nypost.com
Knicks vs. Wizards prediction, odds: NBA picks, best bets Monday
This is a bad matchup for the Wizards.
nypost.com
Betty White postage stamp to be released in 2025: 'An icon of American television'
A Betty White postage stamp based on a 2010 photo of the 'Golden Girls' actor will be released in 2025, the U.S. Postal Service said Friday.
latimes.com
Kevin Costner reacts to ‘Yellowstone’ outrage over John Dutton’s death
Kevin Costner isn't shaking in his boots about the backlash.
nypost.com
What is engagement season, and when is it? How to prepare for your proposal
Everything to know before saying "I do."
nypost.com