Tools
Change country:

The Trump Cabinet picks who seriously threaten democracy — and the ones who don’t

Matt Gaetz speaks emphatically, raising an arm.
Rep. Matt Gaetz (R-FL) speaks on stage on the third day of the Republican National Convention on July 17, 2024 in Milwaukee, Wisconsin.

Let’s be clear: Not everything Donald Trump has proposed to do in his upcoming administration is a threat American democracy.

Some of his Cabinet appointments, like Sen. Marco Rubio for secretary of state or former Rep. Lee Zeldin for EPA administrator, are basically what you’d expect from Republicans. You might disagree with their policies, but you can’t seriously argue that they represent threats to the rule of law or democratic norms. Others, like former Rep. Tulsi Gabbard for director of national intelligence and Robert F. Kennedy Jr. for secretary of Health and Human Services, are troublingly unqualified and even outright dangerous — but not an immediate five-alarm fire for American democracy specifically.

Yet at the same time, there is already clear and undeniable cause for alarm.

Around the world, there are certain steps a leader takes if they want to destroy a country’s democracy, like putting loyalists in charge of law enforcement and politicizing the armed forces. Many of Trump’s early decisions fit this pattern to a T.

The biggest red flag is the choice of arch-loyalist Matt Gaetz as attorney general. The Justice Department is arguably the single most powerful domestic policy agency, running everything from the FBI to federal criminal prosecutors to civil rights litigation. Gaetz has few, if any, qualifications to manage all of this — except for his vendetta against the department, as it once investigated him on suspicion of sex crimes. (Gaetz denies the allegations and the DOJ dropped its investigation into them in 2023.) His pitch for the job, one Trump insider told the Bulwark, was to “go over there and start cuttin’ fuckin’ heads.”

Trump’s plans for the military are similarly ominous. Two teams of reports, in the Wall Street Journal and Reuters respectively, have uncovered plans for a political purge of the brass — potentially including the Joint Chiefs of Staff. Trump’s proposed secretary of defense, Pete Hegseth, is a Fox News commentator and MAGA diehard who called for precisely such a purge in a recent book.

And then there’s Trump’s scheme to get his Cabinet picks in office. If the Republican Senate actually does block any of these picks, Trump has demanded the power to install them through recess appointments while the chamber is out of session. If enough senators balk, Trump reportedly has put together a complicated backup plan that boils down to the House giving him the power to go around the Senate entirely — effectively eviscerating its constitutional advice-and-consent role on appointments.

Of course, we don’t know how much of these really bad ideas will come to pass. Trump is famous for saying things and failing to follow through. But given the enormity of the tail risk — the corrosion of American democracy — it’s critical to take what’s happening right now seriously. 

And that means being clear-eyed about the Trump agenda: both what’s not so scary about it, and what is.

The “authoritarian checklist” that can guide us through Trump 2.0

The United States is not the only democracy to elect an authoritarian of late. Voters in a series of other countries — including Hungary, Turkey, Israel, India, Poland, Venezuela, Brazil, and the Philippines — have elevated similarly dangerous leaders in recent elections. None of these countries are exactly like the United States, but all have some things in common that can give us guidance as to what to expect. 

One of the most important similarities is that none of these country’s leaders openly campaigned on abolishing democracy. The concept remained far too popular among both citizens and elites to act like Hitler and abolish elections outright.

Instead, they made incremental changes that would slowly-but-surely increase their own power while neutering opponents both in and out of the government. No one step marks the end of democracy, but each cumulatively makes it a little bit weaker. If this process reaches its endpoint, elections become functionally meaningless — theoretically free contests that in actuality are nearly impossible for the incumbent party to lose.

Executing this strategy requires a few key moves.

First, would-be authoritarians need the loyalists in key government positions. No one can hollow out an entire government on their own; it’s simply too towering a task to micro-manage. So they delegate, empowering individuals with unwavering loyalty and dedication to remaking key government institutions along authoritarian lines. In India, for example, the second-most powerful position in government — home minister — is occupied by a man named Amit Shah, a close friend and comrade of Prime Minister Narendra Modi’s since 1982.

Second, they need those appointees to eviscerate legal and political guardrails on their power. Independent prosecutors, government accountability offices, courts, legislative prerogatives — all of this needs to be either co-opted or eliminated. The failed 2023 judicial overhaul in Israel, which would have effectively stripped its courts of any ability to check Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu’s power, is an unusually stark example of such a move.

After these first two steps have succeeded in consolidating power over the state, the authoritarian then wields it to weaken dissenters outside of government — with the ultimate aim of tilting the playing field on which elections take place.

This doesn’t just mean obvious things, like formally restricting free speech rights, but more subtle tools — like wielding tax agencies and spurious legal investigations against critics and potential private sector rivals. Hungary’s Viktor Orbán is the pioneer here, using something as seemingly benign as government ad spending to bring the Hungarian media under his control.

Through all of this, they need to be able to count on the loyalty of the security services as a last resort. In between elections, would-be authoritarians fear nothing more than popular uprisings and military coups. Stacking the intelligence community and armed forces with loyalists is the best way to ensure that coups fail (as happened in Turkey in 2016) or to violently repress street protests if necessary (as happened after Venezuela’s stolen election earlier this year).

These four points — appoint loyalists, eviscerate guardrails, attack dissent, suborn armed forces — are the key benchmarks one should use for evaluating Trump’s policies. 

Does what he’s proposing truly further one of those objectives? If so, by how much? How likely is it to happen? And how does the threat level rank relative to other things that he’s doing?

Grading Trump’s early decisions by the checklist

Trying to assess Trump’s policies on these metrics is not some kind of academic game. 

Those of us who care about democracy, in the press and elsewhere, need to maintain our credibility with potentially persuadable third parties — like swing voters or moderate Republican senators. Being seen as liberal hacks who call any Republican appointee a threat to democracy is a problem; so too is developing a track record of crying wolf by labeling everything Trump does anti-democratic.

In this spirit, it’s clear what emerges as the most dangerous move of Trump’s early transition: the Gaetz pick.

It is hard to imagine someone more cravenly loyal to Trump than Gaetz. It is hard to imagine anyone who has a more serious vendetta against non-partisan administration of laws, since Gaetz was once the target of a federal investigation. And it is hard to imagine a more important position than attorney general — one that gives immense power both to eviscerate guardrails and to punish private sector dissenters with spurious criminal investigations (among other tools).

The Defense Department plans aren’t too far behind. Purging the Joint Chiefs based on political loyalty — excuse me, alleged “wokeness” — removes one of the chief barriers to Trump’s alleged desire to invoke the Insurrection Act and deploy soldiers against protestors at home. Hegseth isn’t quite as egregious a Cabinet choice as Gaetz, but it’s hard to imagine someone who has proposed such purges and regularly praises Trump on TV standing in the way of his boss’s plans.

We can go on down the list. 

The plan for circumventing the Senate’s advice-and-consent power would be extremely threatening to guardrails if it happened, but it’s unclear how likely it is to happen. Gabbard as director of national intelligence raises some troubling questions about politicizing intelligence, but she’s not as much of a Trump toady as a Gaetz or even a Hegseth. Kennedy is almost certainly a disaster for public health, but not an obvious threat to democracy narrowly speaking. The office of presidential personnel is small potatoes compared to a cabinet post, but Trump’s decision to put his book publisher in charge of it will facilitate his plans for seeding the entire government with loyalists.

By contrast, there’s no reason to think appointments like Rubio or Zeldin even register on this scale. These are the kind of appointments you’d expect from any Republican, and while their policies may be terrible, they’re not an attack on our system of government. In terms of protecting our democracy, the question for them isn’t whether they themselves are a sign of authoritarian rot, but whether they would have the courage to resist it while in power (color me skeptical).

Ranking these matters for more than just credibility purposes. Democracy’s defenders have limited resources and energy, especially when both chambers of Congress and the Supreme Court are controlled by Republicans. They need to prioritize which Trump appointments and policies to fight, a task made far more difficult by the deluge of daily outrages that we all remember from Trump’s first term.

That requires being clear-eyed about what really is threatening and what isn’t. And at present, an objective evaluation of Trump’s early proposals should give Americans a hell of a lot to worry about.


Read full article on: vox.com
Cam Newton upset he’s been ‘erased’ by the Panthers
Cam Newton said the Panthers hurt his feelings by not inviting him to Germany, where Carolina beat the Giants on Sunday.
2 m
nypost.com
If you use these common text abbreviations, there’s a big downside you could regret: APA study
LOL — BRB! (Or will you?)
4 m
nypost.com
‘Martha’ director R.J. Cutler responds to Martha Stewart’s harsh criticism: ‘It wasn’t surprising’
“She gave me her feedback, and she was upset that I didn’t make the changes that she wanted to make. But this is the process," the filmmaker scoffed.
7 m
nypost.com
Scientific American editor-in-chief resigns after calling Trump voters ‘fascists’
Scientific American editor-in-chief Laura Helmuth announced her resignation after calling Trump supporters "fascists" and the "meanest, dumbest, most bigoted" group.
8 m
foxnews.com
Murdered nursing student Laken Riley’s horrifying 911 call played in court — leaving her mom in a flood of tears
ATHENS, Ga. — The chilling 911 call that captured Georgia nursing student Laken Riley’s horrifying final moments was played in court Friday – leaving her grieving mother in a flood of tears during the first day of opening statements. Riley, 22, triggered the emergency function on her cell phone and called 911 while jogging on...
8 m
nypost.com
Intense video shows Israeli airstrike obliterate Beirut high-rise near Lebanese capital
The latest strike decimated a high-rise building near one of Beirut's busiest traffic junctions — shaking the Lebanese capital as Israel kept up its heavy bombardment.
nypost.com
Fetterman defends Casey-McCormick recount as challenger’s team says 'zero' path for Democrat
Pennsylvania Democratic Sen. John K. Fetterman talked to Fox News Digital about the Casey-McCormick race now headed for automatic recount.
foxnews.com
Elon Musk blasts John Bolton as 'staggeringly dumb warmonger' after criticism of Trump AG pick Matt Gaetz
Elon Musk called John Bolton "a staggeringly dumb warmonger" and suggested that Bolton's opposition to someone is "a great sign!"
foxnews.com
Top Iranian official vows support for Lebanon on Israel-Hezbollah war as U.S. pushes for cease-fire
A top Iranian official has pledged his country’s unwavering support for Lebanon after talks with Lebanese leaders on the Israel-Hezbollah war.
latimes.com
Pregnant Jennifer Lawrence shows off baby bump in black couture at ‘Bread & Roses’ premiere
The actress announced she's expecting her second child with husband Cooke Maroney last month.
nypost.com
Trump transition news live updates: Pence rips HHS nominee RFK Jr.
Follow The Post’s live updates for the latest news, reactions and analysis as President-elect Donald Trump makes cabinet selections and meets with politicians ahead of his inauguration.
nypost.com
Chris Evans Wanted to Quit Acting 10 Years Ago. So Why Did He Make Dreck Like ‘Red One’ and ‘Ghosted’ Instead?
It's gotta be more than money ... or does it?
nypost.com
Martin Scorsese says his new FOX Nation series 'The Saints' was a story he always wanted to tell
FOX Nation presented an exclusive screening of legendary director Martin Scorsese's new series "The Saints" on Thursday night in New York City.
foxnews.com
Parents stunned by sick truth behind beloved nursery rhyme: ‘Childhood shattered’
The real meaning behind the rhyme was revealed by a TikTok scuttlebutt.
nypost.com
This DeWalt 20V Max Drill and Driver Kit is 46% off ahead of Black Friday on Amazon
Save big on this DeWalt deal ahead of Black Friday!
nypost.com
Dorit Kemsley calls out Kyle Richards’ ‘hurtful’ behavior as feud heats up in new ‘RHOBH’ season
"She hadn't been somebody that I could lean on for a sustained period of time," Kemsley tells Page Six's "Virtual Reali-Tea" of her fallout with Richards.
nypost.com
TV host Davina McCall diagnosed with ‘very rare’ brain tumor: ‘Say a prayer for me’
"I don't want you guys to worry about me," she said. "I'm doing that enough as it is."
nypost.com
What the Internet Age Is Taking Away From Writers
Authors tirelessly self-market online, but I find myself wishing that they still had the option to disappear.
theatlantic.com
Films, full orchestras and reforestation: The best of L.A. arts this weekend
Stephanie J. Block and Adrian Dunbar in a 'Kiss Me, Kate' revival and more arts headlines and happenings.
latimes.com
8 of the best restaurants in Arlington
Right this way for juicy Greek lamb, savory Uyghur noodles and attention-getting fried chicken sandwiches.
washingtonpost.com
Meet Pete Hegseth: The 'recovering neocon' and Pentagon critic who's been tapped for Defense secretary
President-elect Donald Trump sent shock waves through the national security establishment when he nominated Pete Hegseth for Defense secretary.
foxnews.com
New Movies on Streaming: ‘Megalopolis,’ ‘Goodrich,’ + More
...plus Your Monster, Saturday Night, and loads of other great new titles.
nypost.com
Ohio transgender bathroom ban heads to governor's desk
A transgender bathroom ban has been sent to Ohio Gov. Mike DeWine's desk after passing through the state legislature.
abcnews.go.com
Cowboys’ Micah Parsons shades Daniel Jones while torching Giants over Saquon Barkley
Like everyone else Thursday, Micah Parsons was in disbelief while watching Saquon Barkley rack up 198 total yards and a pair of touchdowns for the Eagles in a win over the Commanders.
nypost.com
Mike Rogers in consideration for FBI chief after meeting in Mar-a-Lago with Trump transition team, sources say
Former FBI special agent and former Rep. Mike Rogers of Michigan, the 2024 Senate nominee in the key battleground state, met with Trump transition officials about potentially serving as FBI director
foxnews.com
Rotimi drops new album, spills on 50 Cent staged drama and credits Jay Z’s influence
Rotimi stopped by the Page Six studio to talk to Astra about his new two-parter album “In My Heart, In My Veins,” which encompasses the sounds of both R&B and Afrobeats. The Nigerian-American actor and singer also explained the “fake feud” he once had with 50 Cent, who co-created the show “Power,” which Rotimi starred...
nypost.com
Kenya Moore admits to sex poster scandal that led to ‘RHOA’ suspension
Kenya Moore took responsibility for the explicit poster scandal that got her suspended from “The Real Housewives of Atlanta.” The reality star addressed the controversy during her guest appearance on “Tamron Hall.” Watch the full video to learn more about Kenya speaking out on the scandal.  Subscribe to our YouTube for the latest on all...
nypost.com
Jake Paul’s mom trash talks ‘little bitch’ Mike Tyson after slap drama
Even Jake Paul's mother is getting in on the trash talking.
nypost.com
A century after Owens Valley aqueduct protest, event marks tense time in L.A. water history
In 1924, Owens Valley residents seized the L.A. Aqueduct in a defiant protest. An event focuses on remembering the troubled chapter of L.A. water history.
latimes.com
What unified government means for Trump's Cabinet and agenda
Even with unified GOP control of government, Trump's agenda and some of his more controversial nominees may run into some opposition.
cbsnews.com
Photos of the Week: Blue Pond, Camel Fair, Embracing Peace
Speed climbing in Saudi Arabia, wildfires in California and New Jersey, a blanket of smog in New Delhi, a celebration of rural life in Turkey, Veterans Day in Seattle, and much more
theatlantic.com
Kelly Ripa Jokes She And Mark Consuelos “Already Screwed Up” Their Kids On ‘Live’: “Too Late For Us”
"Gentle parenting" puzzled the pair. 
nypost.com
Skai Jackson’s boyfriend arrested for parole violation following her pregnancy announcement
Skai Jackson’s boyfriend, Deondre Burgin, was arrested for a parole violation one day after her pregnancy announcement. According to a police report obtained by TMZ, Deondre was detained in Cincinnati, Ohio, after a brief run-in with law enforcement. Watch the full video to learn more about his arrest.  Subscribe to our YouTube for the latest...
nypost.com
Now's the perfect time for your flu and COVID shots. Here's why.
If you still haven't gotten your COVID or flu shot​, now is the time so you'll stay protected throughout the season, according to doctors.
cbsnews.com
Pilot reveals secret why plane windows are rounded — and it’s for a tragic reason
The shape of airplane windows might seem arbitrary, but there's actually a somber reason behind their design, according to air experts.
nypost.com
Former NFL linebacker arrested over Jan. 6 Capitol riot charges
Antwione Williams, a former player for the Detroit Lions, is one of the first Capitol riot suspects to be charged since Donald Trump’s 2024 election win.
washingtonpost.com
Ali Larter talks "Landman" and working with Billy Bob Thornton
Ali Larter stars as Angela in the Paramount+ series ""Landman,"" created by Taylor Sheridan. Set in the intense world of West Texas oil rigs, Larter navigates the life as the ex-wife of Billy Bob Thornton's character in West Texas.
cbsnews.com
‘Hope you like measles’: Jake Tapper warns viewers after Trump picks RFK Jr. as health secretary
Kennedy has been vocal about his belief in the lack of effectiveness vaccines, especially the COVID jab.
nypost.com
Man turns memories with his grandmother into timeless art
A South Bay artist found purpose and connection by painting with his grandmother, capturing her stories and turning them into a heartfelt book.
cbsnews.com
Breaking down America's two-party system
Political scientist Lee Drutman joins "CBS Mornings Plus" to discuss America's winner-take-all system, its flaws, and whether a third party could reshape the nation's politics.
cbsnews.com
Two Missouri officers charged with stealing nude photos during traffic stops
A Missouri highway patrol trooper and, separately, a Florissant police officer are accused of illegally searching women’s phones for nude images during traffic stops.
washingtonpost.com
New report highlights why so many teens feel burned out
A new report from Common Sense Media reveals more than a quarter of American teens feel burnout due to grind culture, with 81% experiencing pressure in at least one area of their lives. Dr. Sue Varma explains the impact.
cbsnews.com
Josh Brolin admits to using nicotine pouches 24 hours a day — even when sleeping
“I have a pouch in my lip, and I’m not f–king lying, 24 hours a day,” the actor, 56, said during a new podcast interview.
nypost.com
Meghan Markle dances with friends during glam night out in LA without Prince Harry
Meghan Markle is dancing the night away! The Duchess of Sussex attended the launch of her friend Kadi Lee and Myka Harris’ Highbrow Hippie haircare line, without Prince Harry. Watch the full video to learn more about Meghan’s girls night out.  Subscribe to our YouTube for the latest on all your favorite stars.
nypost.com
"Morning Memory:" Reliving the college lifestyle
In today's "Morning Memory," we travel back to 1994 for a CBS News report that explores how the fun and freedom of college life never have to end.
cbsnews.com
Shel Talmy, record producer who oversaw hits by the Kinks and the Who, dies at 87
The American-born record producer was an architect of the catchy if rough-hewn sound that drove many a British pop act to stardom in the mid-1960s.
latimes.com
Mike Tyson returns to boxing ring to take on Jake Paul
Former heavyweight champion Mike Tyson is returning to the boxing ring Friday against social media star Jake Paul. Tyson, who retired in 2005, last fought in 2020 during an exhibition with former four-division world champion Roy Jones Jr.
cbsnews.com
Drew Barrymore Explains Why She Felt “Safer” Working With Adam Sandler After She Had Kids
Barrymore and Sandler starred in Blended after she gave birth to her first daughter.
nypost.com