Tools
Change country:

Monkey Man’s imperfect political critique still packs a punch

Patel, with a mustache and beard, peers between thin columns of purple glass, his face illuminated by red light. Dev Patel as Kid in his directorial debut Monkey Man. | Universal Pictures

Dev Patel’s action-packed directorial debut also takes aim at contemporary Indian politics.

Image reads “spoilers below,” with a triangular sign bearing an exclamation point.

Monkey Man, a gripping, blood-soaked action film from first-time director Dev Patel, has garnered acclaim for its fight scenes — including, famously, when the main character cuts a man’s throat open by holding the knife in his mouth.

Undergirding all this action, however, is also an attempt at commentary about growing authoritarianism in India, and how political leaders leverage both religion and police to maintain their power.

“Having spent most of my career traveling in and out of India shooting films, it is hard to ignore some of the stories that fill the columns of the newspapers there,” Patel said in a BBC interview. “I wanted to touch on some of that and maybe reach an audience that would never normally access such topics.”

Monkey Man’s debut comes as India navigates its 2024 elections, which the right-wing Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP), led by Prime Minister Narendra Modi, a chief proponent of Hindu nationalism, hopes to use to maintain its political dominance nationally. Since he came to power in 2014, Modi has acted to suppress political opposition, to undermine the free press, and to discriminate against Muslim people, all efforts that mark what experts describe as a backsliding of the country’s secular democracy.

Monkey Man stops short of critiquing the BJP’s policies explicitly — and in fact reportedly underwent minor changes to avoid doing so. But key plot points levy clear broadsides against India’s current political leaders, Hindu nationalism, and corruption in law enforcement.

Centered on a protagonist known as “Kid” (Patel) seeking vengeance for his mother’s murder at the hands of a brutal police chief (Sikandar Kher), Monkey Man is largely a breakneck action film jam-packed with stunts, gore, and creative uses of fireworks.That Patel was willing to use this forum to make a political statement, however, is significant as the Indian government has cracked down on journalists, freedom of expression, and cinema. Notably, too, Monkey Man goes further than many mainstream Bollywood films, which are unlikely to have such pointed politics — and which at times have even boosted Modi.

Monkey Man’s villains are analogues for contemporary politics

In his efforts to avenge his mother (Adithi Kalkunte), Kid’s chief targets are Rana Singh, the police chief of a fictional city clearly meant to be a stand-in for Mumbai, as well as Baba Shakti (Makarand Deshpande), the religious leader Singh works for.

Shakti (whose name translates to “power” in Hindi) is depicted as a guru who capitalizes on religious fervor to justify crimes like the land dispossession of minority groups.While not a political leader himself, Shakti is portrayed as the puppetmaster behind a political leader’s operation. Singh, meanwhile, is shown using violence and authority to hurt those with less power and to implement Shakti’s plans.

Given the framing of these characters, Shakti has been perceived by many viewers and critics as an analogue for Modi and key members of the BJP, like Yogi Adityanath, a far-right populist spiritual leader and politician who built his following in part through a fiery, reactionary interpretation of Hinduism. Like Modi, Adityanath has been accused of using his political power to harm minority communities.

Monkey Man takes direct aim at both Shakti and Singh’s characters, with a particularly devastating scene featuring the police destroying Kid and his mother’s village, as the officers seek to clear the land for development under Shakti’s orders. That destruction is followed by Singh’s attempted sexual assault and then violent murder of Kid’s mother, a harrowing attack that fuels the protagonist’s lifelong pursuit of revenge.

While Kid grew up listening to stories about Hindu gods and isn’t Muslim, these developments echo real-life land dispossession that has specifically targeted Muslims in India and been overseen by the state and by police. “Thousands of Muslim families have been forcibly evicted [in the Indian state of Assam] since 2021 from land they had been residing on for decades,” Nazimuddin Siddique writes for Al Jazeera. “Since 2016, police have shot at and killed protesters in at least two instances.”

Modi has also been repeatedly scrutinized for his role in anti-Muslim riots in 2002, which police and government officials did little to stop and which killed 1,200 people in the state of Gujarat. As chief minister of the state at the time, Modi has been accused not only of condoning but inciting this violence. He has been cleared of wrongdoing by Indian courts, but questions about his involvement remain, and were most recently surfaced by a 2023 BBC documentary about the massacre that was censored by the Indian government. In 2005, the State Department barred Modi from a US visit due to concerns about his involvement.

Shakti’s power only grows after the destruction of Kid’s village, and as Monkey Man documents the success of the political party he supports in the film, it also intersperses clips from actual news reports on protests against the rise of anti-Muslim sentiment in India. Shakti at one point also utilizes the Hindi phrase “Bharat Mata ki jai,” which translates to “Long live Mother India,” and is often employed by BJP leaders, including Modi.

For all its efforts to broach this subject, the film’s critiques could be even sharper. When it comes to its depiction of Shakti, the film doesn’t offer many specifics about his ideology, beyond that he abuses the support he receives. And much of the attention in the movie is dedicated to the individual animus Kid has toward Singh, the police officer, rather than the system that he’s a part of.

Some film critics, including Siddhant Adlakha, who wrote a piece for Time, andPrabhjot Bains, who authored a review for But Why Tho, also took issue with how the film employed certain Hindu references.

For Bains, the use of the phrase, “Jai Bajrang Bali,” which praises Hanuman, the Hindu monkey god behind the film’s namesake, contained uncomfortable echoes of how Hindu nationalists have utilized it. This phrase is used by a viewer at a boxing match to support Patel’s character, who is dressed like a monkey.

That same phrase, however, has also been used as a slogan by Hindu nationalists while committing harm against Muslims, Bains writes. For Adlakha, efforts to recast Hindu imagery were also complicated by how they were used to endorse violence.

“The reclamation of such images appears to be Patel’s goal — one he shares with numerous Hindu leaders who have continued to battle Hindu nationalism,” Adlakha adds. “But the use of Hindu imagery as a call to violence, reminiscent of the Hindutva project, is central to Kid’s mission, resulting in narrative dissonance.”

It’s worth noting that the film’s inclusion and celebration of trans people in India, some of whom are part of a community known as hijra, is also significant, directly pushing back on how they have been marginalized by media and in society. In Monkey Man, a group of hijra offer Kid sanctuary, train him in a martial arts montage, and rescue him during an especially pivotal fight scene. Monkey Man’s depictions of the sexual assault and harassment of women also nod at enduring violence that women have experienced in India, drawing more awareness to this ongoing problem.

you don’t understand. the people in this gif are hijras/transfemme/3rd gender people & they’re about to kick ass. MONKEY MAN is an incredible action film featuring INDIAN TRANS PEOPLE as a major part of the plot! I can’t stop screaming it from the rooftops! Dev Patel ilysm ️‍⚧️ pic.twitter.com/WX4fQE2Omo

— Jeremy Allen Black ✊ (they/them) (@LKirwanAshman) April 7, 2024

Despite its shortcomings, it’s nonetheless notable that Patel made political criticism of Indian leaders such a pivotal aspect of the film, especially given the current climate and how heavily studios count on the Indian market. According to Irfan Nooruddin, a professor of Indian politics at Georgetown University, it’s “virtually unheard of” for mainstream films to make such a direct critique of Modi and the BJP.

That’s because film censorship in India has gotten worse in recent years as the BJP has increased scrutiny of art and expression that’s critical of the government. Ahead of April’s election, for instance, Bollywood has released a slew of films that amplify Modi’s agenda. Besides the BBC documentary, other projects — including a film adaptation of Maximum City, a book that nods at Muslim oppression in India, and Gormint, a political satire — have also been tabled by Netflix and Amazon due to what The Washington Post describes as “self-censorship.”

Concerns about this were even clear in Monkey Man itself, which was bought then dropped by Netflix, with some reports suggesting that may have been due to worries about its political content. Even after it was rescued by Universal, there appear to have been changes: In one example, an early trailer showed the banners for the political party in the film as saffron — the color of the BJP. In the final film, some of these banners have been changed to red. And presently, it’s still uncertain if Monkey Man will screen in India at all.

the new trailer shows that they've changed the colors of the evil political party from saffron (hindu nationalist BJP) to red (communist party) https://t.co/HYFrhNqcV8 pic.twitter.com/te2NKTYy2p

— atulya (@computer_atulya) March 23, 2024

“I don’t see it coming out in India, but if it does it’s not going to come out in one piece,” Adlakha tells Vox, citing likely censorship of violence, sexuality, and politics in the film. “It’s going to be a heavily compromised version.”

There are major threats to India’s democracy

Monkey Man is premiering during a period when experts are worried about the state of India’s democracy and the potential for more erosion.

In a federal election set to begin on April 19, the BJP is expected to maintain its majority in Parliament, wins that could further cement the anti-Muslim positions it employs and its efforts to subvert major institutions like the press and the judiciary.

As Vox’s Zack Beauchamp has written, the BJP rose to power while pursuing “policies undermining Muslim rights and inflaming Hindu anxieties about their Muslim neighbors.” A key law that has raised concern is the Citizenship Amendment Act, which excludes Muslims from neighboring countries from obtaining a fast track to Indian citizenship. That same law allows members of other religious groups including Hindus, Sikhs, Buddhists, Jains, and Christians to expedite their attempts at naturalization.

Both Modi’s and the party’s rhetoric have sought to exploit existing divides between Hindu and Muslim people, including questioning the right of certain Muslims to be in India and alleging that they’re seeking to overtake the Hindu majority by growing their population. One example of this has been fears that the BJP have stoked about the concept of “love jihad,” which alleges that Muslim men are interested in marrying Hindu women in order to establish a larger presence in India.

There’s “a growing sense of fear that a continued run of the BJP is going to bring more laws that are going to really put Muslims in second-class citizenship status,” says Nooruddin.

During Modi’s tenure, there have also been a number of anti-democratic developments, including the increased jailing of opposition, attacks on journalists, media censorship, and the weakening of the judiciary.

In recent weeks, the chief minister of Delhi, a major opposition leader, was jailed shortly before the election on corruption charges he claims are politically motivated. Assaults on the press have also become more common, with police raiding the homes of reporters at a left-leaning publication in 2023, and some mainstream outlets now dubbed “lapdog media” by prominent journalists who call them that for their willingness to dilute critiques on the government. Top political leaders have also tried to diminish the role of the judiciary and to exert greater influence in the selection of judges.

Monkey Man, though imperfect, dares to allude to some of these concerns in a time when even doing that is a risky move.


Read full article on: vox.com
  1. Knicks compare Jalen Brunson’s late-game heroics to Damian Lillard In the biggest spots and most pressurized moments, Josh Hart has full faith in Jalen Brunson. 
    nypost.com
  2. Girl, 17, trafficked into US by Mexican national rescued after texting 911, relaying landmarks to authorities Deputies began scouring the area as the call taker continued to text back and forth of the victim, the law enforcement agency said.
    nypost.com
  3. Dodgers look flat on Shohei Ohtani bobblehead night Dodgers lose their second in a row, managing only four singles against a struggling Cincinnati Reds team.
    latimes.com
  4. 5-year-old dead after being strangled by backyard swing in freak accident “She pulled her little plastic slide over to where her swing was. And somehow got caught up in the swing, and the swing strangled her.”
    nypost.com
  5. Chris Kreider ended Rangers’ power-play drought at perfect time Highlights from the Rangers' 5-3 Game 6 win over the Hurricanes on Friday night to advance to the Easter Conference Final.
    nypost.com
  6. nypost.com
  7. Trump will campaign in Minnesota after attending his son Barron's graduation Former President Donald Trump’s break from his hush money trial in New York includes a trip to Minnesota for a Republican fundraiser in a traditionally Democratic state that he boasts he can carry in November
    abcnews.go.com
  8. ‘A Gentleman in Moscow’ Finale Will Make You Cry, if Only for a Moment Ben Blackall/Paramount+ with SHOWTIMEWe’ve reached the end of A Gentleman in Moscow, but we can’t wrap things up without one final escapade for Alexander (Ewan McGregor), Anna (Mary Elizabeth Winstead), and Sofia (Beau Gadsdon). Before the finale wraps, they’ll need to become spies for the American government—this way, Sofia will have a ticket out of the corrupt Russian leadership.The plan sounds simple enough. While Sofia is off performing at the conservatory in Paris, she’ll sneak off in the middle of the show to deliver the important tapes Alex recorded from dinner a few nights ago. She’ll head to the American Embassy in Paris, hand over the evidence, and Richard (Lucian Msamati) will get her on the next plane to the United States. Then, once everything has arrived safely, Richard will call every phone at the Metropol Hotel, alerting Alex to his child’s safety.Sofia is fitted for her recital dress—really one of the most gorgeous dresses I’ve seen all year, a fit that would look marvelous on Anne Hathaway—by Marina (Leah Harvey), and Alex is speechless. “You look so grown up,” he says through tears. Wait…am I also crying? This is kind of adorable. I’ve spent weeks complaining about how much I want this show to end, but now, I’m a little sad it’s coming to a close. Just two episodes ago, Sofia was giggling while hiding a thimble in Alex’s room—now, she’s a woman.Read more at The Daily Beast.
    thedailybeast.com
  9. Mets ace Kodai Senga ‘making some strides’ during injury recovery Mets officials have begun to receive a positive vibe about Kodai Senga’s rehab.
    nypost.com
  10. PGA Championship odds: A new leader at the top after Round 1 Round 1 of the PGA Championship is in the books, and there's a new favorite at the top of the odds board.
    nypost.com
  11. Chris Kreider adds another signature playoff moment to storied Rangers career The narrative was threatening to overwhelm the Rangers. But the narrative was never really about this team and its Game 4 and Game 5 defeats. 
    nypost.com
  12. Bus rider fatally shot amid spate of violence on L.A. Metro A Metro passenger was fatally shot on a bus Thursday afternoon in Commerce hours after Mayor Karen Bass ordered a 'surge' in law enforcement on the system's trains and buses.
    latimes.com
  13. GREG GUTFELD: Don't expect a 'fair fight' in Trump-Biden debates, it's 'not part of the Democrat playbook' Fox News host Greg Gutfeld argues there are "other tricks in the works" to explain President Biden's plans to debate former President Trump on "Gutfeld!"
    foxnews.com
  14. A New Lawsuit Accuses Spotify of Cheating Songwriters Out of Royalties Spotify allegedly used a legalistic word change to justify slicing royalties to musicians and publishers, reducing the revenue on which royalties are based by almost 50%.
    time.com
  15. House hearing on Garland devolves into chaos involving AOC, MTG & Crockett: ‘Are your feelings hurt? Aww’ “I think you know what you’re here for,” Greene shot back. “I think your fake eyelashes are messing up what you’re reading.” 
    nypost.com
  16. Sports Illustrated Swimsuit 2024 Issue Release: see the stars The event also celebrated the magazine's 60th anniversary.
    nypost.com
  17. Mets’ Edwin Diaz won’t use being out for year as reason for closing woes It took 17 games this season for Mets closer Edwin Diaz to allow his ninth run and blow his third save, a far cry from his magical 2022 season.
    nypost.com
  18. House Oversight Committee Hearing Goes Totally Off the Rails Thanks to MTG TwitterA House Oversight Committee hearing—which was supposed to be cover contempt proceedings for Attorney General Merrick Garland on Thursday night—quickly devolved into chaos after repeated interruptions from a certain far-right representative from Georgia.The meeting, originally intended to advance a measure to hold Garland in contempt for refusing to hand over audio of President Biden’s interview with special counsel Robert Hur, quickly fell off the rails, with Marjorie Taylor Greene (R-GA) responsible for much of the drama and delay. Republicans have been obsessed with Hur’s investigation ever since the special counsel claimed that revealed Biden suffered memory loss during the interview. Biden on Thursday blocked access to the audio by invoking executive privilege, which was met with typical criticism from the committee’s chair, Rep. James Comer (R-KY).Read more at The Daily Beast.
    thedailybeast.com
  19. Rangers’ Chris Kreider gave teammates third-period guarantee before hat trick Chris Kreider told teammates within earshot that he was going to score before they took the ice Thursday for the third period of Game 6.
    nypost.com
  20. Alleged arsonist, 26, set NY state trooper’s childhood home on fire over traffic tickets Williams had searched online for personal information about the trooper who gave him traffic tickets, including his address, before the house fire, according to the DA.
    nypost.com
  21. At Least 12 Arrested at U.C. Berkeley After Police Order Protesters to Disperse The authorities had given demonstrators until 7 p.m. to vacate a new encampment that had been erected at a fire-damaged complex on campus.
    nytimes.com
  22. Congress Suddenly Erupts Into Chaos Amid Hearing Lawmakers took shots at one another's appearance during a House Oversight Committee hearing Thursday.
    newsweek.com
  23. Houston metro rocked by severe storms that left 4 dead and over 1 million without power During the height of the severe weather, utility companies that service the Houston metro reported that nearly 1 million customers were without power.
    nypost.com
  24. 4 dead as storms slam Houston again; nearly 1 million customers without power The Houston Mayor's Office confirmed to CBS News that there were at least four weather-related deaths from the storms.
    cbsnews.com
  25. 5/16: CBS Evening News Morehouse College prepares for possible disruptions ahead of Biden's commencement address; Oncology nurse faces down her own cancer diagnosis with courage
    cbsnews.com
  26. Rangers refused to panic while staring down past demons: ‘It was calm’ This was a referendum on the culture built not just by Peter Laviolette but by the guys who were here before him.
    nypost.com
  27. Archaeologists Reveal Iron Age Building Destroyed by 'Violent' Fire Around 2,200 years ago, a fire ravaged an Iron Age settlement, preserving remains that shed light on the life of the community.
    newsweek.com
  28. Billie Eilish is a master of deception on mind-blowing new album ‘Hit Me Hard and Soft’: review The critical darling's sonic sleight of hand comes to play throughout her latest record, on which she contorts herself to toy with diverse genres and tempos.
    nypost.com
  29. Ask Amy: Retired couple misses social activities since the pandemic A retired couple has seen their social life dwindle as many of the activities they used to participate in have been shut down.
    washingtonpost.com
  30. Miss Manners: Longtime friends lose minds over canceled dinner plans A couple canceled dinner plans with old friends a month ago. Their friends are still fuming.
    washingtonpost.com
  31. Carolyn Hax: After holiday meals, guests rush the kitchen to claim the leftovers When fellow guests rush the leftovers after big family holiday gatherings, is it okay to speak up on behalf of the hosts?
    washingtonpost.com
  32. How Rich Candidates Burned Cash on Running for Office It is a time-honored tradition in U.S. politics: wealthy people burning through their fortunes to ultimately lose an election.
    nytimes.com
  33. Elle King sobbed after drunken Dolly Parton birthday tribute performance, admits ‘I was mortified’ Elle King spoke out for the first time about her drunken performance during Dolly Parton's 78th birthday celebration at Nashville's Grand Ole Opry in January.
    nypost.com
  34. At Least Four Dead as Storms Batter Houston Area Buildings were damaged in Houston and school officials canceled classes in the city on Friday, citing the destruction. It may take the city as much as 48 hours to restore power to some customers.
    nytimes.com
  35. Hurricanes coach accuses Rangers’ Mika Zibanejad of selling crucial penalty: ‘Lot of extra’ Minutes after his team’s season ended, Carolina coach Rod Brind’Amour expressed his displeasure with the call that led to the Rangers’ tying goal in their comeback victory Thursday night. 
    nypost.com
  36. Missouri Attorney General Accuses Local Government of Doxxing Chiefs Kicker David Eulitt/Getty ImagesMissouri’s top prosecutor is baying for justice after accusing Kansas City of having “doxxed” Harrison Butker, the Chiefs kicker who has come under fire in recent days for a controversial commencement speech in which he urged women to get back in the kitchen.State Attorney General Andrew Bailey said his office was “demanding accountability,” declaring that he would “enforce the Missouri Human Rights Act to ensure Missourians are not targeted for their free exercise of religion” and telling his X audience to “stay tuned.”Bailey’s heated response came after the official X account of Kansas City tweeted “a reminder” on Wednesday night that Butker did not live in Kansas City, but in a named city around 25 minutes’ drive away.Read more at The Daily Beast.
    thedailybeast.com
  37. Rangers fans raucously celebrate inside — and outside — the Garden after Game 6 thriller The Rangers huge Game 6 series-clinching win over the Hurricanes in Game 6 came on the road, but that didn't mean Madison Square Garden was silent.
    nypost.com
  38. Christopher Gregor, NJ dad accused of son’s treadmill death, tried to coach his mother’s testimony In the recorded jailhouse call, both Gregor's parents were heard repeatedly telling their son to stop talking.
    nypost.com
  39. ‘Summer House’ star West Wilson says Jesse Solomon and Danielle Olivera had sexual tension "I think Danielle would f--k Jessie in two seconds," Wilson said during Page Six's "Virtual Reali-Tea" live taping Thursday.
    nypost.com
  40. Kevin Spacey Breaks Cover to Do First U.S. TV Interview in Seven Years NewsNationKevin Spacey sat for his first U.S. television interview in seven years on Thursday, telling NewsNation’s Chris Cuomo that he is eager to “get back to work” in show business after a series of sexual misconduct accusations derailed his career.When asked by the Cuomo host about some of Spacey’s peers in the industry—like Liam Neeson and Sharon Stone—publicly stating their desire to see his return, Spacey said their support “means a tremendous amount.”“These are people that I have conversations with who have been really helpful on my path, and I’m very, very grateful to them,” he said. “But look, Chris. Here’s the thing: I just want to go back to work. I would much rather play you in a movie than to be sitting here answering questions on your show.”Read more at The Daily Beast.
    thedailybeast.com
  41. May 16, 2024 Israel-Hamas war Israel called South Africa the "legal arm" of Hamas on Thursday after it accused Israeli forces, in remarks at the International Court of Justice, of failing to protect civilians in the southern Gaza city of Rafah.
    edition.cnn.com
  42. Chiefs’ Harrison Butker jersey ranked among NFL’s bestsellers after kicker’s faith-based commencement address Kansas City Chiefs kicker Harrison Butker's commencement address at a private Catholic liberal arts school in Kansas over the weekend has drawn strong reaction.
    nypost.com
  43. Deadly Storm Ravages South Texas: Everything We Know Southern Texas was pummeled by a violent storm on Thursday, knocking out power for nearly 1 million residents.
    newsweek.com
  44. UPS driver fatally shot while sitting in parked van, Irvine police say The Irvine Police Department said that a man was shot near Chrysler and Bendix streets around 3 p.m. Thursday.
    latimes.com
  45. New Hampshire daycare workers sprinkled melatonin in children’s food unbeknownst to parents, police say The owner of an in-home daycare in New Hampshire and three of her employees are facing charges after they allegedly served melatonin to children without parents’ knowledge and consent
    foxnews.com
  46. Rangers become first Presidents’ Trophy winner in nearly a decade to make conference final The Rangers are the first team to advance to the Conference Finals after winning the President's Trophy in nine years.
    nypost.com
  47. Donovan Mitchell shoots down reported Cavaliers discontent: ‘Sick of y’all’ Donovan Mitchell is trying to put an end to the rumors about his happiness in Cleveland. 
    nypost.com
  48. Seth Meyers Revels in Lauren Boebert’s Courthouse Humiliation NBCFormer president Donald Trump is not allowed to publicly complain about his ongoing trial without risking a gag order violation, so Rep. Lauren Boebert (R-CO) and a clown car of Republican suck-ups flew to Manhattan Thursday to aid his defense.After sitting through hours of the proceedings, she attempted to give an impassioned speech outside the courthouse, only to be drowned out by a sea of heckling New Yorkers who got creative rather than sticking with the tried and true “boos” often used to disrupt public addresses.They chanted “Beetlejuice!” at Boebert, referring to the 2023 scandal where she was kicked out of a public theater for vaping and groping her date—all of which was caught on camera.Read more at The Daily Beast.
    thedailybeast.com