Tools
Change country:

The Columbine-Killers Fan Club

Mass shootings didn’t start at Columbine High, but the mass-shooter era did. Eric Harris and Dylan Klebold’s audacious plan and misread motives multiplied the stakes and inspired wave after wave of emulation. How could we know we were witnessing an origin story?

The legend of Columbine is fiction. There are two versions of the attack: what actually happened on April 20, 1999, and the story we all accepted back then. The mythical version explained it all so cleanly. A pair of outcast loners dubbed the “Trench Coat Mafia” targeted the jocks to avenge years of bullying. Dwayne Fuselier, the supervisory special agent who led the FBI’s Columbine investigation, is fond of quoting H. L. Mencken in response to the mythmaking: “There is always a well-known solution to every human problem—neat, plausible, and wrong.”

The legend hinges on bullying, but the killers never mentioned it in the huge trove of journals, online posts, and videos they left to explain themselves. The myth was so insidious because it cast the ruthless killers as heroes of misfits everywhere. Fuselier warned how appealing that myth would sound to anyone who felt ostracized. Within a few years, the fledgling fandom would find one another on social media, where they have operated ever since.

Around the world, Eric and Dylan are idolized as champions of “the nobodies.” Eric hated the nobodies. He mocked them mercilessly on his website and in his journal. He wasn’t a loner or an outcast, and neither was Dylan. Eric and Dylan made clear in their writings that they were planning the attack for their own selfish motives—certainly not to help the kids they ridiculed at the bottom of the social food chain.

They were not in the Trench Coat Mafia. They were not Nazis or white supremacists, and they did not plan the attack for Hitler’s birthday. They did not target jocks, Christians, or Black people. They targeted no one specifically. They shot randomly and designed their bombs to kill indiscriminately. That’s where “they” ends: Their polar-opposite personalities drove opposite motives. Psychopaths are devoid of empathy; Eric was a sadistic psychopath who killed for his own aggrandizement and enjoyment. Dylan was suicidally depressed and self-loathing. Eric lured him into punishing the world for the pain it inflicted on him, instead of punishing himself. Columbine was a suicide plan, but on “Judgment Day,” as they called it, Dylan would show the world the “somebody” we’d never seen.

The Columbine killers have fans. Eric and Dylan’s adoring online following spreads across nearly every continent, and it’s growing across multiple platforms. In Russia, the government, which has been plagued by an explosion of both Columbine fandom and mass shootings, estimates that more than 70,000 members exist. They call themselves the TCC, for “True Crime Community,” and I’ve spent much of the past 15 years inside their online world. My book Columbine made me enemy No. 1 for portraying Eric and Dylan as ruthless murderers.

In 2016, a young fan tweeted: “hey @DaveCullen block me or else i shoot my school.” She’d been ranting for hours, posting pictures of school shooters, and tweets such as: “It’s also something a lot of people need, To die....I wish i was dead...I LIKE VIOLENCE...I want to be killed in front of an audience. … I think someone failed to abort me (:”

These teens are ensnared in an American tragedy that just keeps growing worse.

diagram of shootings inspired by Columbine

I’ve tried to leave this story so many times, but this diagram haunts me, ruthlessly expanding like an unstoppable spider web, devouring all the lives and futures in its path. It demands that we address the cause—25 years too late. That web is made up of 54 mass shootings that have killed nearly 300 people and wounded more than 500. And every gunman left evidence that they were inspired or influenced by the murderers at Columbine. The Columbine effect.

Eric and Dylan’s bombs failed. Yet the legend made them heroic to their progeny and gave birth to their fandom. By the tenth anniversary, a small band of “Columbiners” had formed online. They gravitated to the TCC, to Ted Bundy, to the younger Tsarnaev brother, ‎to Dylann Roof, and to others—but Eric and Dylan are the megastars. The groupies multiply, as fresh crops of teens join their ranks each season.

Most gunmen die in the act, so the 54 attacks itemized in the diagram are just the ones that we know of, and that were carried out. A 2015 Mother Jones investigation of Columbine copycats found more than two thwarted attacks for each one that succeeded. It identified 14 plotters targeting Columbine’s anniversary and 13 striving to top its body count. Surviving mass shooters have admitted that they were competing with one another.

All roads lead back to Columbine. The Virginia Tech shooter, Seung-Hui Cho, wrote in a school assignment that he wanted to “repeat Columbine” and that he idolized its “martyrs.” The Northern Illinois University killer marked a third generation, explicitly inspired by both Virginia Tech and Columbine. Sandy Hook was the fourth generation; Adam Lanza had studied all three. Six more school shooters later referenced Sandy Hook and Columbine. Five generations of fallout, all reenacting the original legend.

Most early Columbiners were just curious teenagers interested in the criminal mind or in analyzing Columbine. Many still are, and their analyses are often useful. Many are angry about being tarred with the group’s reputation, but they have been outnumbered by new arrivals unabashedly calling themselves fans. Many use the killers’ faces as avatars, extoll their virtues, and compose love poems, fan fiction, and gory memes about them. Sue Klebold said she was shocked by the volume of letters she received calling Dylan “heroic” and by the number of girls saying, “I wish I could have his baby.”

How little these groupies know about the murderers they obsess over is ironic. They keep repeating the misreporting that was debunked decades ago, convinced it’s true because it has metastasized into TCC dogma. The TCC twists the story to recast the murderers as victims; and the dead, wounded, and traumatized as villains. The groupies didn’t start these myths; we in the media bear that shame. But the groupies are now the carriers, spreading the legend of Dylan and Eric to remote reaches of the globe.

Seventy thousand is a tiny fraction of the adolescent population, but a magnet for a dangerous cohort of marginalized, disaffected, and hopeless teens—a major pool of aspiring shooters. Most TCC members outright say that they condone the Columbine murders, often in their profiles. They have turned Eric and Dylan into folk heroes, and they celebrate them as avenging angels. Adam Lanza obsessed over the Columbine killers and spent years immersed in these groups online. Then he murdered 20 little kids and six adults at Sandy Hook Elementary School.

Here’s the twist: Most of the TCC members I’ve engaged with describe themselves as awkward outcasts desperate to fit in. The TCC embraces them. The TCC feels cool—Eric and Dylan are super cool—and so they finally feel cool. I find it heartbreaking to hear them describe the pain they endure at school and the affinity they feel for “Dylan” and “Eric,” the fictional characters they’ve constructed. These kids are shocked when I tell them that other members of the TCC have told me the same—that they are putting on the same show, sure that all the others really mean it. Did Adam Lanza believe the posers? We’ll never know, but we can be certain that as you read this, a distraught, lonely kid somewhere is contemplating an attack—and the one community they trust is screaming, Do it!

Lots of kids fantasize about killing. Two days after Columbine, Salon ran “Misfits Who Don’t Kill,” in which three people came clean about their youthful fantasies of enacting mass murder. The phenomenon was widely reported that week. But none of those people did anything, because they knew how horribly wrong acting out the fantasy would be. Inside the TCC bubble, the constant message is that if your classmates are tormenting you, killing them is not just moral —it’s heroic and noble.

The TCC has a tell: Actual shootings unnerve them. Their posts grow quiet, respectful, and even mournful after some troubled young person heeds their call. I can gauge the change instantly, because the incessant harassment I get from them stops cold—for a week or two. Parkland was different: Six months went by before the taunts began trickling back in, and I haven’t gotten a death threat in the six years since. Why? I have no way to be certain about this, but my educated guess is that David Hogg, X González, and the rest of the March for Our Lives kids were suddenly cooler than the young shooters. And so much more powerful.

Eric and Dylan weren’t powerful—their plan failed. They’d planned Columbine as a bombing, the primary terrorist tactic. They thought they were launching a three-act drama: The cafeteria bombs would kill nearly 600 people instantly; what they called the “fun” part would be shooting up hundreds of survivors; and the massive car bombs set in the parking lot outside were to be the coup de grâce. Those timers were set to explode 45 minutes after the initial blast, wiping out countless more survivors and first responders, live on national TV. The Columbine killers’ performance was staged as the most apocalyptic made-for-TV horror film in American history. Eric complained in his journal that his “audience” would fail to understand. He got that right. He got everything else wrong.

Every element fizzled. All of the big bombs failed. Eric and Dylan went down to the cafeteria in a last desperate move to ignite the bombs with gunfire and a Molotov cocktail. Failed. Experts on psychopaths say they get bored after their initial kills, and Eric had likely lost interest. His gun’s recoil had broken his nose, so he spent that time in acute pain. The cops refused to kill them in the blaze of glory that they’d described as their final curtain. The smell of all the blood and already decomposing bodies was overpowering. Out of options, each shot himself in the head.

A more obscene and pathetic way to die is hard to imagine. Yet their fans have never confronted that ugly reality, because the opposite story took hold, making Eric and Dylan masterminds of the “worst school shooting in American history.”

The Columbine effect has gone global. It has inspired mass shootings in Finland, Sweden, Brazil, Mexico, Canada, France, Germany, the Netherlands, Ukraine, and Russia—as well as knife and axe attacks in places as remote as Siberia. In 2022, Russia designated the online “Columbine movement” a terrorist group. To comply with the ruling, my publisher required me to disavow the group in the Russian translation of Columbine. Mass murder inspired by those inept perpetrators is America’s most revolting cultural export.

I know when the TCC colonizes a new region, because I start getting a barrage of taunts in a different language. It’s a social contagion. Researchers have described school shootings as the American equivalent of suicide bombings—an ideology joined with a tactic. The phenomenon is escalating and self-perpetuating.

The Columbine groupies have no idea that they’re exporting a fraud. The media set this whole thing in motion 25 years ago. To untell a legend is a formidable task. It will be possible only when the media finally begin to convey how pathetic and gruesome the killers’ final moments were. The fans need to hear the ugly truth. Eric and Dylan viciously murdered innocent kids for their own selfish and petty agendas, and they died miserable failures.

This essay is adapted by the author from the new preface to a 25th-anniversary edition of Columbine.


Read full article on: theatlantic.com
  1. Knicks compare Jalen Brunson’s late-game heroics to Damian Lillard In the biggest spots and most pressurized moments, Josh Hart has full faith in Jalen Brunson. 
    nypost.com
  2. Girl, 17, trafficked into US by Mexican national rescued after texting 911, relaying landmarks to authorities Deputies began scouring the area as the call taker continued to text back and forth of the victim, the law enforcement agency said.
    nypost.com
  3. Dodgers look flat on Shohei Ohtani bobblehead night Dodgers lose their second in a row, managing only four singles against a struggling Cincinnati Reds team.
    latimes.com
  4. 5-year-old dead after being strangled by backyard swing in freak accident “She pulled her little plastic slide over to where her swing was. And somehow got caught up in the swing, and the swing strangled her.”
    nypost.com
  5. Chris Kreider ended Rangers’ power-play drought at perfect time Highlights from the Rangers' 5-3 Game 6 win over the Hurricanes on Friday night to advance to the Easter Conference Final.
    nypost.com
  6. nypost.com
  7. Trump will campaign in Minnesota after attending his son Barron's graduation Former President Donald Trump’s break from his hush money trial in New York includes a trip to Minnesota for a Republican fundraiser in a traditionally Democratic state that he boasts he can carry in November
    abcnews.go.com
  8. ‘A Gentleman in Moscow’ Finale Will Make You Cry, if Only for a Moment Ben Blackall/Paramount+ with SHOWTIMEWe’ve reached the end of A Gentleman in Moscow, but we can’t wrap things up without one final escapade for Alexander (Ewan McGregor), Anna (Mary Elizabeth Winstead), and Sofia (Beau Gadsdon). Before the finale wraps, they’ll need to become spies for the American government—this way, Sofia will have a ticket out of the corrupt Russian leadership.The plan sounds simple enough. While Sofia is off performing at the conservatory in Paris, she’ll sneak off in the middle of the show to deliver the important tapes Alex recorded from dinner a few nights ago. She’ll head to the American Embassy in Paris, hand over the evidence, and Richard (Lucian Msamati) will get her on the next plane to the United States. Then, once everything has arrived safely, Richard will call every phone at the Metropol Hotel, alerting Alex to his child’s safety.Sofia is fitted for her recital dress—really one of the most gorgeous dresses I’ve seen all year, a fit that would look marvelous on Anne Hathaway—by Marina (Leah Harvey), and Alex is speechless. “You look so grown up,” he says through tears. Wait…am I also crying? This is kind of adorable. I’ve spent weeks complaining about how much I want this show to end, but now, I’m a little sad it’s coming to a close. Just two episodes ago, Sofia was giggling while hiding a thimble in Alex’s room—now, she’s a woman.Read more at The Daily Beast.
    thedailybeast.com
  9. Mets ace Kodai Senga ‘making some strides’ during injury recovery Mets officials have begun to receive a positive vibe about Kodai Senga’s rehab.
    nypost.com
  10. PGA Championship odds: A new leader at the top after Round 1 Round 1 of the PGA Championship is in the books, and there's a new favorite at the top of the odds board.
    nypost.com
  11. Chris Kreider adds another signature playoff moment to storied Rangers career The narrative was threatening to overwhelm the Rangers. But the narrative was never really about this team and its Game 4 and Game 5 defeats. 
    nypost.com
  12. Bus rider fatally shot amid spate of violence on L.A. Metro A Metro passenger was fatally shot on a bus Thursday afternoon in Commerce hours after Mayor Karen Bass ordered a 'surge' in law enforcement on the system's trains and buses.
    latimes.com
  13. GREG GUTFELD: Don't expect a 'fair fight' in Trump-Biden debates, it's 'not part of the Democrat playbook' Fox News host Greg Gutfeld argues there are "other tricks in the works" to explain President Biden's plans to debate former President Trump on "Gutfeld!"
    foxnews.com
  14. A New Lawsuit Accuses Spotify of Cheating Songwriters Out of Royalties Spotify allegedly used a legalistic word change to justify slicing royalties to musicians and publishers, reducing the revenue on which royalties are based by almost 50%.
    time.com
  15. House hearing on Garland devolves into chaos involving AOC, MTG & Crockett: ‘Are your feelings hurt? Aww’ “I think you know what you’re here for,” Greene shot back. “I think your fake eyelashes are messing up what you’re reading.” 
    nypost.com
  16. Sports Illustrated Swimsuit 2024 Issue Release: see the stars The event also celebrated the magazine's 60th anniversary.
    nypost.com
  17. Mets’ Edwin Diaz won’t use being out for year as reason for closing woes It took 17 games this season for Mets closer Edwin Diaz to allow his ninth run and blow his third save, a far cry from his magical 2022 season.
    nypost.com
  18. House Oversight Committee Hearing Goes Totally Off the Rails Thanks to MTG TwitterA House Oversight Committee hearing—which was supposed to be cover contempt proceedings for Attorney General Merrick Garland on Thursday night—quickly devolved into chaos after repeated interruptions from a certain far-right representative from Georgia.The meeting, originally intended to advance a measure to hold Garland in contempt for refusing to hand over audio of President Biden’s interview with special counsel Robert Hur, quickly fell off the rails, with Marjorie Taylor Greene (R-GA) responsible for much of the drama and delay. Republicans have been obsessed with Hur’s investigation ever since the special counsel claimed that revealed Biden suffered memory loss during the interview. Biden on Thursday blocked access to the audio by invoking executive privilege, which was met with typical criticism from the committee’s chair, Rep. James Comer (R-KY).Read more at The Daily Beast.
    thedailybeast.com
  19. Rangers’ Chris Kreider gave teammates third-period guarantee before hat trick Chris Kreider told teammates within earshot that he was going to score before they took the ice Thursday for the third period of Game 6.
    nypost.com
  20. Alleged arsonist, 26, set NY state trooper’s childhood home on fire over traffic tickets Williams had searched online for personal information about the trooper who gave him traffic tickets, including his address, before the house fire, according to the DA.
    nypost.com
  21. At Least 12 Arrested at U.C. Berkeley After Police Order Protesters to Disperse The authorities had given demonstrators until 7 p.m. to vacate a new encampment that had been erected at a fire-damaged complex on campus.
    nytimes.com
  22. Congress Suddenly Erupts Into Chaos Amid Hearing Lawmakers took shots at one another's appearance during a House Oversight Committee hearing Thursday.
    newsweek.com
  23. Houston metro rocked by severe storms that left 4 dead and over 1 million without power During the height of the severe weather, utility companies that service the Houston metro reported that nearly 1 million customers were without power.
    nypost.com
  24. 4 dead as storms slam Houston again; nearly 1 million customers without power The Houston Mayor's Office confirmed to CBS News that there were at least four weather-related deaths from the storms.
    cbsnews.com
  25. 5/16: CBS Evening News Morehouse College prepares for possible disruptions ahead of Biden's commencement address; Oncology nurse faces down her own cancer diagnosis with courage
    cbsnews.com
  26. Rangers refused to panic while staring down past demons: ‘It was calm’ This was a referendum on the culture built not just by Peter Laviolette but by the guys who were here before him.
    nypost.com
  27. Archaeologists Reveal Iron Age Building Destroyed by 'Violent' Fire Around 2,200 years ago, a fire ravaged an Iron Age settlement, preserving remains that shed light on the life of the community.
    newsweek.com
  28. Billie Eilish is a master of deception on mind-blowing new album ‘Hit Me Hard and Soft’: review The critical darling's sonic sleight of hand comes to play throughout her latest record, on which she contorts herself to toy with diverse genres and tempos.
    nypost.com
  29. Ask Amy: Retired couple misses social activities since the pandemic A retired couple has seen their social life dwindle as many of the activities they used to participate in have been shut down.
    washingtonpost.com
  30. Miss Manners: Longtime friends lose minds over canceled dinner plans A couple canceled dinner plans with old friends a month ago. Their friends are still fuming.
    washingtonpost.com
  31. Carolyn Hax: After holiday meals, guests rush the kitchen to claim the leftovers When fellow guests rush the leftovers after big family holiday gatherings, is it okay to speak up on behalf of the hosts?
    washingtonpost.com
  32. How Rich Candidates Burned Cash on Running for Office It is a time-honored tradition in U.S. politics: wealthy people burning through their fortunes to ultimately lose an election.
    nytimes.com
  33. Elle King sobbed after drunken Dolly Parton birthday tribute performance, admits ‘I was mortified’ Elle King spoke out for the first time about her drunken performance during Dolly Parton's 78th birthday celebration at Nashville's Grand Ole Opry in January.
    nypost.com
  34. At Least Four Dead as Storms Batter Houston Area Buildings were damaged in Houston and school officials canceled classes in the city on Friday, citing the destruction. It may take the city as much as 48 hours to restore power to some customers.
    nytimes.com
  35. Hurricanes coach accuses Rangers’ Mika Zibanejad of selling crucial penalty: ‘Lot of extra’ Minutes after his team’s season ended, Carolina coach Rod Brind’Amour expressed his displeasure with the call that led to the Rangers’ tying goal in their comeback victory Thursday night. 
    nypost.com
  36. Missouri Attorney General Accuses Local Government of Doxxing Chiefs Kicker David Eulitt/Getty ImagesMissouri’s top prosecutor is baying for justice after accusing Kansas City of having “doxxed” Harrison Butker, the Chiefs kicker who has come under fire in recent days for a controversial commencement speech in which he urged women to get back in the kitchen.State Attorney General Andrew Bailey said his office was “demanding accountability,” declaring that he would “enforce the Missouri Human Rights Act to ensure Missourians are not targeted for their free exercise of religion” and telling his X audience to “stay tuned.”Bailey’s heated response came after the official X account of Kansas City tweeted “a reminder” on Wednesday night that Butker did not live in Kansas City, but in a named city around 25 minutes’ drive away.Read more at The Daily Beast.
    thedailybeast.com
  37. Rangers fans raucously celebrate inside — and outside — the Garden after Game 6 thriller The Rangers huge Game 6 series-clinching win over the Hurricanes in Game 6 came on the road, but that didn't mean Madison Square Garden was silent.
    nypost.com
  38. Christopher Gregor, NJ dad accused of son’s treadmill death, tried to coach his mother’s testimony In the recorded jailhouse call, both Gregor's parents were heard repeatedly telling their son to stop talking.
    nypost.com
  39. ‘Summer House’ star West Wilson says Jesse Solomon and Danielle Olivera had sexual tension "I think Danielle would f--k Jessie in two seconds," Wilson said during Page Six's "Virtual Reali-Tea" live taping Thursday.
    nypost.com
  40. Kevin Spacey Breaks Cover to Do First U.S. TV Interview in Seven Years NewsNationKevin Spacey sat for his first U.S. television interview in seven years on Thursday, telling NewsNation’s Chris Cuomo that he is eager to “get back to work” in show business after a series of sexual misconduct accusations derailed his career.When asked by the Cuomo host about some of Spacey’s peers in the industry—like Liam Neeson and Sharon Stone—publicly stating their desire to see his return, Spacey said their support “means a tremendous amount.”“These are people that I have conversations with who have been really helpful on my path, and I’m very, very grateful to them,” he said. “But look, Chris. Here’s the thing: I just want to go back to work. I would much rather play you in a movie than to be sitting here answering questions on your show.”Read more at The Daily Beast.
    thedailybeast.com
  41. May 16, 2024 Israel-Hamas war Israel called South Africa the "legal arm" of Hamas on Thursday after it accused Israeli forces, in remarks at the International Court of Justice, of failing to protect civilians in the southern Gaza city of Rafah.
    edition.cnn.com
  42. Chiefs’ Harrison Butker jersey ranked among NFL’s bestsellers after kicker’s faith-based commencement address Kansas City Chiefs kicker Harrison Butker's commencement address at a private Catholic liberal arts school in Kansas over the weekend has drawn strong reaction.
    nypost.com
  43. Deadly Storm Ravages South Texas: Everything We Know Southern Texas was pummeled by a violent storm on Thursday, knocking out power for nearly 1 million residents.
    newsweek.com
  44. UPS driver fatally shot while sitting in parked van, Irvine police say The Irvine Police Department said that a man was shot near Chrysler and Bendix streets around 3 p.m. Thursday.
    latimes.com
  45. New Hampshire daycare workers sprinkled melatonin in children’s food unbeknownst to parents, police say The owner of an in-home daycare in New Hampshire and three of her employees are facing charges after they allegedly served melatonin to children without parents’ knowledge and consent
    foxnews.com
  46. Rangers become first Presidents’ Trophy winner in nearly a decade to make conference final The Rangers are the first team to advance to the Conference Finals after winning the President's Trophy in nine years.
    nypost.com
  47. Donovan Mitchell shoots down reported Cavaliers discontent: ‘Sick of y’all’ Donovan Mitchell is trying to put an end to the rumors about his happiness in Cleveland. 
    nypost.com
  48. Seth Meyers Revels in Lauren Boebert’s Courthouse Humiliation NBCFormer president Donald Trump is not allowed to publicly complain about his ongoing trial without risking a gag order violation, so Rep. Lauren Boebert (R-CO) and a clown car of Republican suck-ups flew to Manhattan Thursday to aid his defense.After sitting through hours of the proceedings, she attempted to give an impassioned speech outside the courthouse, only to be drowned out by a sea of heckling New Yorkers who got creative rather than sticking with the tried and true “boos” often used to disrupt public addresses.They chanted “Beetlejuice!” at Boebert, referring to the 2023 scandal where she was kicked out of a public theater for vaping and groping her date—all of which was caught on camera.Read more at The Daily Beast.
    thedailybeast.com