Tools
Change country:

Why USC canceled its pro-Palestinian valedictorian

Asna Tabassum, a graduating senior at the University of Southern California majoring in biomedical engineering, is at the center of the latest firestorm on college campuses after the university named her valedictorian, then barred her from speaking at graduation. | Genaro Molina/Los Angeles Times via Getty Images

As the school year winds down, colleges are still grappling with student speech.

Campus tensions over Israel’s war on Gaza have flared up again, this time at the University of Southern California, which this week barred its valedictorian from speaking at next month’s commencement ceremony. The school cited potential campus safety risks if Asna Tabassum delivered a speech.

Provost Andrew T. Guzman said in an email to students and staff on Monday that public discussion had “taken on an alarming tenor” after the school announced its choice for valedictorian. “The intensity of feelings, fueled by both social media and the ongoing conflict in the Middle East, has grown to include many voices outside of USC and has escalated to the point of creating substantial risks relating to security and disruption at commencement,” he wrote.

Tabassum, a South Asian American biomedical engineering major who is Muslim and wears a hijab, says that she, along with other critics of the decision, believes the school canceled her speech because of her public support for the human rights of Palestinians.

Pro-Israel USC student groups, including Trojans for Israel and the Chabad Jewish Student Center, had complained online about Tabassum’s views, calling them antisemitic. The Provost explained in the email that the decision “has nothing to do with freedom of speech” and made no mention of Tabassum’s political views. The Provost’s email did not state whether USC had already received specific threats of violence or disruption.

Since Hamas’s October 7 attack on Israel, campuses have been embroiled in controversy as student protests test the boundaries of freedom of expression. Many college and university leaders have struggled to make satisfactory public statements about the conflict and balance safety with speech protections. In the attack, Hamas killed 1,200 Israelis and took more than 200 hostage. Since then, Israel has killed 33,899 Palestinians, according to the Gaza Health Ministry.

Though schools have vowed to keep their students safe, some have reported facing violence and harassment. After failing to adequately condemn antisemitism in congressional testimony late last year, the presidents of the University of Pennsylvania and Harvard resigned. A congressional hearing on Wednesday also brought Columbia University’s president before lawmakers to answer questions about the school’s response to antisemitism, showing that the quandary is far from over.

The USC Provost referenced the broader turmoil on US campuses in his email: “We cannot ignore the fact that similar risks have led to harassment and even violence at other campuses.”

Pro-Israel groups are celebrating USC’s decision, claiming that Tabassum’s speech, which she said she had not yet written, could have made Jewish students feel uncomfortable. Tabassum told Inside Edition that she hoped to share a message of hope in her speech.

Meanwhile, critics say that it undermines free speech and is a signal that universities are caving to pro-Israel pressures. “USC cannot hide its cowardly decision behind a disingenuous concern for ‘security,” said Hussam Ayloush, the executive director of the Council on American-Islamic Relations Los Angeles. “The university can, should and must ensure a safe environment for graduation rather than taking the unprecedented step of canceling a valedictorian’s speech.” Student groups and outlets including the LA Times and the Guardian have defended Tabassum and condemned USC.

As the academic year comes to a close, the country is watching how similar situations might unfold on other campuses. It’s customary for students to make political statements during commencement speeches, but this year’s campus controversies could lead schools to keep buckling under pressure, raising concerns about students’ freedom of expression in the process.

USC chose its valedictorian — then silenced her

USC announced that Tabassum would be the university’s valedictorian on April 2, based on her grade point average, which topped 3.98, contributions to the campus community, essay submission, and performance in interviews. Tabassum, who also minors in resistance to genocide — studies about conflicts including the war in Ukraine, genocide in Darfur, and the Holocaust — was selected from more than 200 students who qualified for the award, and was slated to deliver the customary valedictory speech at the May 10 commencement. Then, Tabassum was notified that she wouldn’t deliver the address at commencement after all because of safety concerns. Critics began to speculate that USC was kowtowing to pro-Israel groups and people who complained about Tabassum being selected as valedictorian.

The right-wing pro-Israel organization organization End Jew Hatred welcomed USC’s decision stating, “Ms. Tabassum’s speech as valedictorian was anticipated to be harmful to Jewish students and even potentially agitate anti-Jewish activists.” The USC campus group the Trojans for Israel wrote that Tabassum “openly traffics in antisemitic and anti-Zionist rhetoric.”

Tabassum told CNN that she received “hate and vitriol” for including a link to the website “Free-Palestine.Carrd.Co” on her Instagram profile. The homepage of the website contains the image of a woman holding up a Palestinian flag and a peace sign rising above flames and smoke, and links to help visitors “learn about what’s happening in Palestine.”

USC’s Chabad argued that the linked website called for the “abolishment of the state of Israel” and called the words on the website, which Tabassum did not create, “antisemitic and hate speech.”

Tabassum said in a statement that she believes there was a “campaign” of “racist hatred” on the part of “anti-Muslim and anti-Palestinian voices” to prevent her from addressing her peers at commencement due to her “uncompromising belief in human rights for all.”

“I am not surprised by those who attempt to propagate hatred. I am surprised that my own university—my home for four years—has abandoned me,” Tabassum said, adding that the school denied her request for more information about their threat assessment.

Pro-Palestinian students and groups such as Students for Justice in Palestine and Jewish Voice for Peace have faced discipline, sanctions, and campus suspensions and bans over protest activity since October 7 — part of a long history silencing student activism for Palestine. Meanwhile, students advocating for Palestine have been labeled antisemitic for chanting phrases such as “From the river to the sea, Palestine will be free” and “globalize the intifada.” Student protesters say the phrases don’t advocate for harm to Israelis, while critics say the phrases are threatening and call for violence.

School leadership has often said the groups were reprimanded for violating school policies amid a rise in antisemitism and anti-Muslim sentiment on campus. On Thursday, police in riot gear arrested more than 100 pro-Palestinian Columbia students at President Minouche Shafik’s direction, while administrators suspended three Barnard students, including, Isra Hirsi, the daughter of Minnesota Rep. Ilhan Omar (D), for setting up “unauthorized” protest encampments on campus.

USC has not responded to requests for further information about any specific threats to Tabassum or anyone else in the USC community. USC has not yet responded to Vox’s request for comment.

“If anti-Palestinian groups are threatening violence, then USC needs to say what they’ve threatened and why it is so dangerous that it has led to such a drastic action, instead of disingenuously claiming that it isn’t engaging in censorship,” said Radhika Sainath, an attorney at Palestine Legal, an organization that defends people who speak out in support of Palestine.

“The fact that Palestinians and their allies are being punished and canceled in this way — while Israel is committing an ongoing genocide in Gaza — speaks to the McCarthyite moment we’re in.”

USC’s decision raises questions about free speech on campus

USC is a private school that makes First Amendment-like free speech promises, Alex Morey, an attorney at Foundation Individual Right and Expression, an organization that advocates for free speech, told Vox. The school is also required to provide students First Amendment rights in certain situations under California’s Leonard Law, a 1992 statute that extended free speech protections to students at private colleges and universities in the state. The school’s decision to cancel Tabassum's speech, Morey said, “does implicate campus expression in an important way.”

“For those of us watching the campus speech space on the regular, canceling controversial speeches or events due to vague, unspecified ‘safety concerns’ is one of the oldest tricks in the book,” Morey said. “USC appears to have made a calculated move that this was the way to avoid the most criticism. Yanking the student’s valedictorian status or canceling the speech for viewpoint-based reasons, would have pleased the students’ critics but angered her supporters. By citing ‘safety’ however, USC’s doing their best to look like the good guy and suggest this isn’t about viewpoint at all.”

Morey told Vox the school should have done everything in its power to ensure that the event would go on, and that if threats remained, it should have been transparent about what those threats are.

If USC did in fact cancel the speech due to pressure from pro-Israel critics, now they know “that with the right amount of pressure, they can silence certain views at USC,” Morey said.

The USC decision has also introduced bigger questions about whether students who have publicly expressed any views on Palestine or Israel will be passed over for honors in the future. These decisions might lead students to self-censor.

“If USC will only honor students with certain views, are they really living up to their lofty free expression promises?” Morey said.

Ironically, Morey pointed out, Tabassum minored in “resistance to genocide” and is effectively getting dinged for saying “precisely the kind of things you’d imagine one would hear in Resistance to Genocide 101 at a school like USC.”


Read full article on: vox.com
2024 ACM Awards: Complete winners list
The 59th annual Academy of Country Music Awards was held at the Ford Center at The Star in Frisco, Texas on Thursday night.
foxnews.com
Chris Pratt's stunt double, Tony McFarr, dead at 47: 'I'll never forget his toughness'
Chris Pratt's longtime stunt double, Tony McFarr, died at the age of 47 Monday. The two worked together in movies like "Jurassic World" and "Guardians of the Galaxy Vol. 2."
foxnews.com
Homeless California parolee dragged female jogger by ponytail on beach in attempted sexual assault: police
A homeless man allegedly dragged a female jogger near Los Angeles by her ponytail and tried to sexually assault her, police said Thursday.
foxnews.com
JESSE WATTERS: 'The defense caught Cohen in lie after lie'
"Jesse Watters Primetime" host Jesse Watters says Michael Cohen was caught in "lie after lie" during cross examination in New York v. Trump.
foxnews.com
Chris Kreider hat trick completes Rangers rally to eliminate Hurricanes in Game 6
The Rangers forward notched a natural hat trick in the third period to lead the Rangers to a 5-3 comeback win in Game 6 over the Hurricanes, sending New York to the Eastern Conference Final.
nypost.com
Missourians head to Washington to call for a House vote on the Radiation Exposure Compensation Act
Residents of impacted communities are heading to Washington to speak in favor of the Radiation Exposure Compensation Act before it expires this summer.
foxnews.com
LA Mag’s Billie Eilish Cover Shoot Shrouded in Drama
Photo Illustration by Elizabeth Brockway/The Daily Beast/Reuters/GettyA feud that unfolded behind the scenes of a glitzy Los Angeles magazine cover story starring pop icon Billie Eilish left one photographer so aggrieved that he pulled his name from the finished product and ended his working relationship with the magazine altogether.A source familiar with the photoshoot told The Daily Beast that the photographer, Shayan Asgharnia, wanted his name removed after the magazine gave final approval over the photographs to Eilish’s team during the session. Editor-in-chief Shirley Halperin confirmed in emails to The Daily Beast that Asgharnia did, indeed, ask for his credit to be scrapped from the December shoot as it went to press, but she said she did not know why.Halperin said the magazine “worked closely” with Eilish and her team for the shoot “as is standard with major talent,” but she denied Eilish or her team had cover approval or creative control. A representative for Eilish also characterized the magazine cover shoot as a “unique collaboration” and a “collaborative affair,” but they said they did not get “final approval.”Read more at The Daily Beast.
thedailybeast.com
Pro-Palestinian Student Protesters Celebrated for ‘Moral Clarity’ at ‘The People’s Graduation’
Hundreds of students gathered at The Cathedral of Saint John the Divine on Thursday for 'The People's Graduation'
time.com
U.S. announces effort to expedite cases of migrants who cross border illegally
Migrant adults released by federal border officials after crossing into the U.S. unlawfully will be eligible to be placed in the program.
cbsnews.com
Caitlin Clark’s home debut a rough welcome thanks to Liberty rout
The Liberty’s 102-66 win at Gainbridge Fieldhouse captured just how difficult the rookie’s transition will still be.
nypost.com
Prep baseball: North Hollywood's Enoch Yi throws no-hitter in Division I opener
North Hollywood defeats Wilson 4-0 behind no-hitter from Enoch Yi, who strikes out 10 in a City Section Division I baseball playoff opener Thursday.
1 h
latimes.com
Nuggets plan to continue excluding Aaron Gordon from team dinners amid playoff winning streak
After dropping the first two games of the Western Conference semifinals, the Nuggets decided to have a players-only team dinner — without Aaron Gordon.
1 h
foxnews.com
After Assembly issues apology for California's role in slavery, some reparations bills die in Senate
The California Senate killed some reparations bills for Black residents on Thursday amid a budget deficit after the Assembly issued a formal apology for slavery
1 h
latimes.com
Jordan Martinook makes insane diving save to rob Rangers of goal in Game 6
It was the save of the night and it wasn’t even the Hurricanes goaltender that kept what looked like a sure Rangers goal out of the net. 
1 h
nypost.com
Yankees lineup rounding into shape after prolonged woes
The Yankees’ pitching staff dominated their sweep of the Twins this week, but they also received some promising signs from their lineup. 
1 h
nypost.com
NFL Distances Itself From Chiefs Kicker Harrison Butker After His Controversial Commencement Speech
During a commencement speech, the Kansas City Chiefs kicker encouraged women to prioritize their "vocation" as homemakers.
1 h
time.com
Girlfriend of US Airman killed by Florida deputy speaks out
The girlfriend of U.S. Air Force Senior Airman Roger Fortson, who was on the phone with Fortson when he was killed, is speaking out about the May 3 incident.
1 h
abcnews.go.com
Morehouse College prepares for Biden's commencement address
For weeks, some students and faculty have challenged leaders of the historically Black college to rescind Mr. Biden's invitation over his administration's response to the Israel-Hamas war​.
1 h
cbsnews.com
Caitlin Clark’s Fever home debut came with a signature 3-pointer
It took nearly three quarters for Caitlin Clark to hit a 3-pointer in her home opener with the Fever.
1 h
nypost.com
Republican congressman files for divorce amid rumored relationship with fellow House GOP colleague
Rep. Rich McCormick (R-Ga.) filed for divorce earlier this month and is rumored to be romantically involved with House GOP colleague Rep. Beth Van Duyne (R-Texas).
1 h
nypost.com
Sexual assaults are down in the US military. Here's what to know about the numbers
Officials are 'cautiously optimistic' that a decline in reported sexual assaults among the military academies and active-duty service members suggests leaders are getting a handle on the problem.
1 h
foxnews.com
Ended with a big bang: ‘Young Sheldon’ boss on series finale — and Jim Parsons and Mayim Bialik’s return
"To get to have Jim and Mayim....It was really fun to watch them step back into these characters as older versions," Steve Holland, "Young Sheldon" exec producer said about the series finale.
1 h
nypost.com
Police arrest suspect in 1989 cold case killing of Pa. woman, 78: ‘You don’t get a free pass on murder’
"We're at the end of a long investigation that — although it went cold — it was never forgotten, and it was never put aside," the district attorney said.
1 h
nypost.com
Dodgers pitcher Emmet Sheehan has season-ending Tommy John surgery
The Dodgers announced that 24-year-old right-hander Emmet Sheehan underwent season-ending Tommy John surgery.
1 h
latimes.com
Iain Armitage was 9 when 'Young Sheldon' began. Now, he's saying goodbye to his biggest role yet
Iain Armitage, 16, talks about the end of "Young Sheldon," which aired its finale Thursday on CBS, and what's next for him.
1 h
latimes.com
'The Big Cigar' dramatizes Black Panther Huey P. Newton's Hollywood ties and escape to Cuba
The Apple TV+ series looks at the relationship between Black Panther Huey P. Newton and Hollywood producer Bert Schneider as they plan a fake movie to usher Newton's escape.
1 h
latimes.com
‘9-1-1’s Malcolm-Jamal Warner On Amir And Bobby, Working With Peter Krause, And More
"I was a huge Six Feet Under fan, so getting to spend so much time with Peter was really exciting," Warner told Decider.
1 h
nypost.com
David Stearns still confident in ‘track records’ of struggling Mets hitters
The Mets slow-starting bats are leaning on their past and believing it will eventually become their present.
2 h
nypost.com
Anti-Israel student protester at UC Irvine gives TV interview during arrest as cops clear encampment
The University of California Irvine pro-Palestinian encampment was broken up by police on Wednesday.
2 h
nypost.com
What to know about how much the aid from a US pier project will help Gaza
A U.S.-built pier has been installed to bring aid to Gaza, and U.S. military officials hope to deliver about 90 to 150 truckloads of aid each day; it is not yet clear if the new route will work.
2 h
foxnews.com
Josh Hart’s ‘fierce’ rebounding prowess fueling Knicks run
The Eastern Conference’s leading rebounder isn’t a big man. Technically, he’s not even a forward. 
2 h
nypost.com
GOP Rep Files for Divorce as Wife Drops Cryptic Hint About His ‘Colleague’
Kevin Dietsch/Getty ImagesRep. Rich McCormick (R-GA) is calling it quits on his marriage of 12 years, filing for divorce from his oncologist wife earlier this month even as Capitol Hill insiders report seeing him cozy up to another Republican lawmaker.A petition for divorce was filed by McCormick on May 3, according to Gwinnett County court records. A mutual restraining order was filed in the case docket on the same day.The Daily Mail first reported the pending divorce on Thursday. Asked by the outlet about her husband’s reasons for the divorce, Dr. Debra Miller replied in a text that she wasn’t sure McCormick would be “forthcoming.”Read more at The Daily Beast.
2 h
thedailybeast.com
Defending champ Brooks Koepka off to strong start at PGA Championship
Danger lurks on the PGA Championship leaderboard. Brooks Koepka is Danger. Look out below.
2 h
nypost.com
Sounding off on latest ridiculousness plaguing sports
A 24-year-old, smallish — by modern standards — lefty with no discernible flash, Josh Gasser was what today is easily missed or dismissed. 
2 h
nypost.com
America’s fastest-growing cities—and their home prices—might surprise you
The latest US Census Bureau figures on population growth reveal the cities that are growing the fastest.
2 h
nypost.com
NFL had to take Taylor Swift’s Eras Tour into account for 2024 schedule
So maybe everything isn't about Taylor Swift... But what if it is?
2 h
nypost.com
Why this couple decided to rent out rather than sell their old home: ‘It’s a gem’
While many homebuyers sell their first property when moving onto their next, Chris was reluctant to part with such a stellar mortgage rate.
2 h
nypost.com
It’s Peak Wedding Season—Here’s Everything You Need to Know About Bridal Beauty Treatments, According to Pros
Scouted/The Daily Beast/Artem Makovskyi/Maxim Fesenko/iStock.Scouted selects products independently. If you purchase something from our posts, we may earn a small commission.The months preceding your wedding day are undoubtedly stressful for a laundry list of reasons. You’ve found your dress, triple-confirmed your guest list, secured your catering and cake situation, and double-checked with your venue that they’re ready to host you on the big day—and the list goes on.Now that the essential to-do list items are (hopefully) out of the way, you get to deal with planning your wedding day beauty look. Aside from locking in a makeup and hair team (and I suggest doing a test run with your team a month or two before the date so that everyone’s on the same page), you may be thinking about how to get your complexion as glowing, smooth, and photo-ready as possible by tapping the in-office aesthetic treatments and targeted skincare. Read more at The Daily Beast.
2 h
thedailybeast.com
Tony Washington country club torn apart over plans to upgrade no-gals-allowed ‘Men’s Club’
The club's president was accused of pursuing a "grossly misogynistic and outdated agenda" for the storied 130-year-old country club.
2 h
nypost.com
‘West Point’ for Democratic operatives hired director who called terrorism the ‘dream of politics’
The "West Point for Democratic operatives," which credits itself for aiding President Biden's victory, hired a digital director, who previously shared that "terrorism is the dream of politics."
2 h
nypost.com
Southern California Releasing Thousands of Mosquitoes
County officials are looking for solutions to curb the growing population of the invasive Aedes mosquito, which can transmit diseases.
2 h
newsweek.com
Apple agrees to $35 million settlement with some iPhone 7 users
The settlement covers U.S. residents who owned an iPhone 7 or 7 Plus between September 16, 2016, and January 3, 2023, and reported a covered issue to Apple or paid the company for repairs.
2 h
cbsnews.com
Canyonlands National Park in Utah searching for 2 visitors suspected of 'archeological theft'
The National Park Service is seeking to identify two suspects wanted in connection with an "archeological theft" at Canyonlands National Park in Utah.
2 h
foxnews.com
Alaska lawmakers end their session with late bills passing on energy, education
Alaska lawmakers ended their session early with last-minute bills addressing issues like correspondence school programs and energy; quarreling over the budget was muted.
2 h
foxnews.com
Kel Mitchell’s ex-wife denies claims she got pregnant by other men during their marriage: ‘This man is lying’
"Kel's math is not mathing. He is not talking about me," Tyisha Hampton said in a TikTok video following the actor's viral "Club Shay Shay" interview.
2 h
nypost.com
Justice Dept. makes arrests in North Korean identity theft scheme involving thousands of IT workers
The Justice Department announced multiple arrests in a series of stolen identity theft cases that are reportedly part of a scheme that generates proceeds for North Korea its weapons program.
2 h
foxnews.com
Anti-Israel agitators arrested at UC Irvine claim to be professors: 'out here supporting my students'
Some people claimed to be professors at the University of California, Irvine after they were arrested during an anti-Israel protest.
2 h
foxnews.com
Arab League Calls for U.N. Peacekeepers in Gaza and the West Bank
Any use of U.N. forces would have to be approved by the Security Council. “There first has to be peace to keep," said a U.N. spokesman.
2 h
nytimes.com