Tools
Change country:

The miserable, utterly charmless razzle-dazzle of Joker: Folie à Deux 

A man in full-face clown makeup wears a serious expression. A woman behind him in a red blazer wears more subtle clown makeup.
Joaquin Phoenix’s Joker (right) and Lady Gaga in Joker: Folie à Deux.

Academy Award-nominated director Todd Phillips and his new sequel Joker: Folie à Deux bravely ask the daring question: What if the most annoying man you know got an equally annoying girlfriend? And what if they sang show tunes to each other? And what if you had to watch?

The man in question is one Arthur Fleck (Joaquin Phoenix), the social outcast turned serial killer from 2019’s Joker, who is in jail awaiting trial following the events of the first film. The girlfriend is one Harley Quinn (Lady Gaga), a woman with both a master’s in psychiatry and an obsession with Fleck, who gets herself locked up in order to stalk him better. Harley Quinn and Joker’s toxically codependent relationship has existed in the Batverse for decades — first appearing in Batman: The Animated Series in 1992 — and the former doctor and the one-time patient who drove her mad have been explored across comics, movies, and TV. In Phillips’s new film, however, their entanglement is rewritten to be even more grim and, frankly, flat (especially Quinn’s arc), but with a lot more singing.

Yes, though he is loath to tell anyone, Phillips has also managed to make a movie musical about the Joker’s murder trial. On paper, creating a supervillain movie that doesn’t involve setting a city on fire or threatening the world is about as subversive as a director can get. Potentially ignoring the strict directives that come with franchise filmmaking and the demands of Warner Brothers and then throwing in singing and dancing? There was potential here for something truly subversive. 

But as Fleck reminds us, some people don’t seek change, but simple misery. For two hours and 20 minutes of Joker: Folie à Deux, Phillips shows us how. 

Do not be fooled, Joker 2 is actually a musical 

Following a trend of movies like Mean Girls and Wonka, the marketing and creative team behind Joker: Folie à Deux, a.k.a. Joker 2, have refrained from making it clear the movie is a musical (a choice the upcoming Wicked also seems to be making). Some of that obfuscation might be a conscious effort not to alienate Joker’s original audience, but it may also be based on the notion that movie-going audiences don’t like musicals. Mean Girls and Wonka didn’t sell themselves as musicals, and they were considered box office successes — meanwhile obvious musicals like the West Side Story revival and In the Heights underwhelmed. 

That said, and despite the reluctance, Joker 2 is very much a movie musical — at times trying to be a very edgy one. 

Phillips uses music as a very obvious storytelling device, if not a very sensitive one. Throughout the film, Fleck’s sanity is in question. Everyone from judges to doctors talk about him living in a “fantasy world.” Enter: the singing and dancing. From “Get Happy” to the Carpenters’ “Close to You,” the movie’s numbers function as a glimpse into Fleck’s desires, fears, and mental illness all rolled into one. 

One can only know the surreal interior life of this man by peering into his delirious hallucinations, where we find a sparkly, razzle-dazzle version of his trauma and mental illness.

These moments also allow Lady Gaga to take off her pop star mask and show us Stefani Germanotta, theater kid. She’s good — especially when Fleck envisions himself and Harley as a kind of chaotic Sonny and Cher duo. Gaga’s committed, crackling performance is proof there is room for another Judy Garland biopic, as long as she can audition.

Phoenix, on the other hand, warbles and screeches through his numbers.

The result sounds like a big bird harassing another smaller bird. Phoenix’s vocal performance is knowingly bad, especially when you consider this man won an Oscar for playing Johnny Cash in Walk the Line. Perhaps Phillips believes that his audience wouldn’t be able to fully comprehend how disturbed Fleck is if he sounds smooth and delightful in his own fantasies, but Phoenix deliberately makes him sound discordant. After three or so songs, the singing just feels a little like some kind of petty punishment. I suppose that’s the point: Being in Joker’s head is supposed to be an unpleasant experience. I just wanted to be unpleased in a different way. 

Imagine if you took all the fun out of My Cousin Vinny, then you have Joker 2

The most perplexing element of Joker 2 is not that it’s a musical; it’s that it’s a courtroom procedural. While there’s a rich cinematic history of clowns and their girlfriends in courtrooms, this is not a choice that makes for an exciting film.

At the heart of this two-hour and 20-minute movie is the question of whether or not Arthur Fleck, a.k.a Joker, is insane and, by extension, if the Joker is real. His attorney (played by Catherine Keener) claims as a defense strategy that while Fleck did kill five people, he has dissociative identity disorder (DID), formerly known as multiple personality disorder. (The police don’t know Fleck killed his own mother, which would bring the body count to six.) Joker is that other personality, and so Fleck can’t be held responsible. Prosecutor Harvey Dent (Harry Lawtey) — the man who will become the Batman villain known as Two-Face — argues that Fleck and Joker are one and the same: a violently depraved murderer. 

Watching Fleck in jail waiting for trial or on trial waiting to go back to jail just doesn’t make for thrilling viewing. Dissociative identity disorder as a legal argument is sort of compelling but less so when it becomes all that’s happening. (It’s also important to note that despite some media portrayals, people with DID are not more violent than the general public.) Courtroom procedurals need some kind of twist or some kind of build to enhance the drama. Starting with all the cards on the table — Arthur Fleck is culpable for Joker or he isn’t — just takes the air out of the genre.  

Close-up photo of Joaquin Phoenix and Lady Gaga about to kiss, backlit by orange glowing light. Phoenix wears clown face makeup.

Maybe that’s why it’s a musical? 

As a character who has been an icon since the 1960s, the Joker was created to terrorize Gotham City. The Joker was not created to sit in a jail cell and talk legal strategy with his lawyer. There’s a reason that so many Batman comics and adaptations have a jailbreak scene. Batman’s villains are more interesting when they’re doing crime!  

Phillips seems to want to make a bigger point about how the most terrifying part of the character is Joker’s influence over Gotham’s citizens. If Fleck is allowed to be Joker, then what’s stopping everyone else in the city from being Joker? If Fleck is declared legally insane, how can the laws in Gotham keep people safe? If no one can be held accountable for murder, it doesn’t matter how powerful Gotham’s police force is; it doesn’t even matter how powerful its heroes are. But other than the huge crowds outside of the courtroom, some in Joker masks, Phillips doesn’t really show us what’s happening in Gotham. We aren’t really made to understand the stakes for Joker’s verdict, even if they’re the destruction of a civilized society. 

Worst of all, Phillips has intentionally or unintentionally created a bizarro, humorless version of My Cousin Vinny. In the 1992 classic, a clown and his Italian girlfriend are the only people that stand in the way of a mixed-up town convicting a pair of dweebs of murder. In Joker 2, a clown and his Italian-ish girlfriend are the only people that stand in the way of a mixed-up town convicting a dweeb of murder. Now, imagine if Marisa Tomei wasn’t charming, the clown wasn’t funny, and there were no twists, no turns, and no 1963 Pontiac Tempest with its independent rear suspension. Your honor, that dour, miserable thing is The Joker 2.


Read full article on: vox.com
Hernández: Los problemas de pitcheo en Dodgers podrían provocar otra decepción en playoffs
La decisión de los Dodgers de que Yoshinobu Yamamoto sea titular en el primer partido de la NLDS contra los Padres demuestra lo vulnerable que es el equipo ante otra eliminación prematura de los playoffs.
latimes.com
'Joker: Folie á Deux' pairs two singing jailbirds but skimps on supervillainy
Joaquin Phoenix, Lady Gaga and co-writer-director Todd Phillips bend the architecture of the comic-book origin story toward a musical, not all that tunefully.
latimes.com
We found the best prices on Dodgers-Padres 2024 NLCS tickets
The NL West showdown will be Shohei Ohtani's first MLB playoff series.
nypost.com
Royals Recap: Queen Camilla reportedly nixes a King Charles-Prince Harry reunion, another royal baby, more
This week Travis Kelce’s mom Donna dishes on his meeting with Prince William. Queen Camila’s reportedly discouraging King Charles from reuniting with Prince Harry and there’s a royal baby on the way! In case you missed this week’s biggest news from across the pond, here’s your royal’s recap! Subscribe to our YouTube for more royal news!
nypost.com
Donna Kelce opens up about delaying her divorce from Ed Kelce
Donna Kelce gave some insight into her divorce from Ed Kelce in Glamour’s 2024 Women of the Year: The Moms Issue. The mom of Travis and Jason Kelce revealed that she and her ex “stayed together” for the sake of their sons. Watch the full video to learn more about the rare details from football’s...
nypost.com
Halle Bailey and DDG, who share a baby boy, call it quits: 'We are still best friends'
Halle Bailey and rapper DDG will no longer be part of each other's worlds — at least not romantically. The two have split up months after welcoming a baby boy.
latimes.com
L.A.'s ex-deputy mayor headed to prison: 'Corruption at any level will not be tolerated'
A federal judge sentenced former Los Angeles Deputy Mayor Raymond Chan for his role in a sprawling City Hall corruption case that also brought down a former councilmember.
latimes.com
We’re Entering Uncharted Territory for Math
Terence Tao, a mathematics professor at UCLA, is a real-life superintelligence. The “Mozart of Math,” as he is sometimes called, is widely considered the world’s greatest living mathematician. He has won numerous awards, including the equivalent of a Nobel Prize for mathematics, for his advances and proofs. Right now, AI is nowhere close to his level.But technology companies are trying to get it there. Recent, attention-grabbing generations of AI—even the almighty ChatGPT—were not built to handle mathematical reasoning. They were instead focused on language: When you asked such a program to answer a basic question, it did not understand and execute an equation or formulate a proof, but instead presented an answer based on which words were likely to appear in sequence. For instance, the original ChatGPT can’t add or multiply, but has seen enough examples of algebra to solve x + 2 = 4: “To solve the equation x + 2 = 4, subtract 2 from both sides …” Now, however, OpenAI is explicitly marketing a new line of “reasoning models,” known collectively as the o1 series, for their ability to problem-solve “much like a person” and work through complex mathematical and scientific tasks and queries. If these models are successful, they could represent a sea change for the slow, lonely work that Tao and his peers do.[Read: OpenAI’s big reset]After I saw Tao post his impressions of o1 online—he compared it to a “mediocre, but not completely incompetent” graduate student—I wanted to understand more about his views on the technology’s potential. In a Zoom call last week, he described a kind of AI-enabled, “industrial-scale mathematics” that has never been possible before: one in which AI, at least in the near future, is not a creative collaborator in its own right so much as a lubricant for mathematicians’ hypotheses and approaches. This new sort of math, which could unlock terra incognitae of knowledge, will remain human at its core, embracing how people and machines have very different strengths that should be thought of as complementary rather than competing.This conversation has been edited for length and clarity.Matteo Wong: What was your first experience with ChatGPT?Terence Tao: I played with it pretty much as soon as it came out. I posed some difficult math problems, and it gave pretty silly results. It was coherent English, it mentioned the right words, but there was very little depth. Anything really advanced, the early GPTs were not impressive at all. They were good for fun things—like if you wanted to explain some mathematical topic as a poem or as a story for kids. Those are quite impressive.Wong: OpenAI says o1 can “reason,” but you compared the model to “a mediocre, but not completely incompetent” graduate student.Tao: That initial wording went viral, but it got misinterpreted. I wasn’t saying that this tool is equivalent to a graduate student in every single aspect of graduate study. I was interested in using these tools as research assistants. A research project has a lot of tedious steps: You may have an idea and you want to flesh out computations, but you have to do it by hand and work it all out.Wong: So it’s a mediocre or incompetent research assistant.Tao: Right, it’s the equivalent, in terms of serving as that kind of an assistant. But I do envision a future where you do research through a conversation with a chatbot. Say you have an idea, and the chatbot went with it and filled out all the details.It’s already happening in some other areas. AI famously conquered chess years ago, but chess is still thriving today, because it’s now possible for a reasonably good chess player to speculate what moves are good in what situations, and they can use the chess engines to check 20 moves ahead. I can see this sort of thing happening in mathematics eventually: You have a project and ask, “What if I try this approach?” And instead of spending hours and hours actually trying to make it work, you guide a GPT to do it for you.With o1, you can kind of do this. I gave it a problem I knew how to solve, and I tried to guide the model. First I gave it a hint, and it ignored the hint and did something else, which didn’t work. When I explained this, it apologized and said, “Okay, I’ll do it your way.” And then it carried out my instructions reasonably well, and then it got stuck again, and I had to correct it again. The model never figured out the most clever steps. It could do all the routine things, but it was very unimaginative.One key difference between graduate students and AI is that graduate students learn. You tell an AI its approach doesn’t work, it apologizes, it will maybe temporarily correct its course, but sometimes it just snaps back to the thing it tried before. And if you start a new session with AI, you go back to square one. I’m much more patient with graduate students because I know that even if a graduate student completely fails to solve a task, they have potential to learn and self-correct.Wong: The way OpenAI describes it, o1 can recognize its mistakes, but you’re saying that’s not the same as sustained learning, which is what actually makes mistakes useful for humans.Tao: Yes, humans have growth. These models are static—the feedback I give to GPT-4 might be used as 0.00001 percent of the training data for GPT-5. But that’s not really the same as with a student.AI and humans have such different models for how they learn and solve problems—I think it’s better to think of AI as a complementary way to do tasks. For a lot of tasks, having both AIs and humans doing different things will be most promising.Wong: You’ve also said previously that computer programs might transform mathematics and make it easier for humans to collaborate with one another. How so? And does generative AI have anything to contribute here?Tao: Technically they aren’t classified as AI, but proof assistants are useful computer tools that check whether a mathematical argument is correct or not. They enable large-scale collaboration in mathematics. That’s a very recent advent.Math can be very fragile: If one step in a proof is wrong, the whole argument can collapse. If you make a collaborative project with 100 people, you break your proof in 100 pieces and everybody contributes one. But if they don’t coordinate with one another, the pieces might not fit properly. Because of this, it’s very rare to see more than five people on a single project.With proof assistants, you don’t need to trust the people you’re working with, because the program gives you this 100 percent guarantee. Then you can do factory production–type, industrial-scale mathematics, which doesn't really exist right now. One person focuses on just proving certain types of results, like a modern supply chain.The problem is these programs are very fussy. You have to write your argument in a specialized language—you can’t just write it in English. AI may be able to do some translation from human language to the programs. Translating one language to another is almost exactly what large language models are designed to do. The dream is that you just have a conversation with a chatbot explaining your proof, and the chatbot would convert it into a proof-system language as you go.Wong: So the chatbot isn’t a source of knowledge or ideas, but a way to interface.Tao: Yes, it could be a really useful glue.Wong: What are the sorts of problems that this might help solve?Tao: The classic idea of math is that you pick some really hard problem, and then you have one or two people locked away in the attic for seven years just banging away at it. The types of problems you want to attack with AI are the opposite. The naive way you would use AI is to feed it the most difficult problem that we have in mathematics. I don’t think that’s going to be super successful, and also, we already have humans that are working on those problems.The type of math that I’m most interested in is math that doesn’t really exist. The project that I launched just a few days ago is about an area of math called universal algebra, which is about whether certain mathematical statements or equations imply that other statements are true. The way people have studied this in the past is that they pick one or two equations and they study them to death, like how a craftsperson used to make one toy at a time, then work on the next one. Now we have factories; we can produce thousands of toys at a time. In my project, there’s a collection of about 4,000 equations, and the task is to find connections between them. Each is relatively easy, but there’s a million implications. There’s like 10 points of light, 10 equations among these thousands that have been studied reasonably well, and then there’s this whole terra incognita.[Read: Science is becoming less human]There are other fields where this transition has happened, like in genetics. It used to be that if you wanted to sequence a genome of an organism, this was an entire Ph.D. thesis. Now we have these gene-sequencing machines, and so geneticists are sequencing entire populations. You can do different types of genetics that way. Instead of narrow, deep mathematics, where an expert human works very hard on a narrow scope of problems, you could have broad, crowdsourced problems with lots of AI assistance that are maybe shallower, but at a much larger scale. And it could be a very complementary way of gaining mathematical insight.Wong: It reminds me of how an AI program made by Google Deepmind, called AlphaFold, figured out how to predict the three-dimensional structure of proteins, which was for a long time something that had to be done one protein at a time.Tao: Right, but that doesn’t mean protein science is obsolete. You have to change the problems you study. A hundred and fifty years ago, mathematicians’ primary usefulness was in solving partial differential equations. There are computer packages that do this automatically now. Six hundred years ago, mathematicians were building tables of sines and cosines, which were needed for navigation, but these can now be generated by computers in seconds.I’m not super interested in duplicating the things that humans are already good at. It seems inefficient. I think at the frontier, we will always need humans and AI. They have complementary strengths. AI is very good at converting billions of pieces of data into one good answer. Humans are good at taking 10 observations and making really inspired guesses.
theatlantic.com
Serial killers hiding in plain sight as truckers to terrorize US highways, expert says
The FBI launched its Highway Serial Killings Initiative in 2009 after analysts noticed a pattern of murdered women – most living transient lifestyles involving drug abuse and prostitution.
nypost.com
Blackface photo shakes up toss-up House district in NY
New York Republican Congressman Michael Lawler is embroiled in controversy over a 2006 Halloween costume, when he dressed in blackface as Michael Jackson.
foxnews.com
Jordyn Woods massive diamond ring sparks engagement buzz with Karl-Anthony Towns after Knicks trade
The new Knicks center-forward and his girlfriend, Jordyn Woods, stirred buzz that they might be engaged when she showed off a massive diamond on her ring finger.
nypost.com
Burger King, Dunkin' launch Halloween wars early with Wednesday's Whopper, spider donuts and more
Fast-food chains are already waging the Halloween wars with their slate of newly announced items. Burger King has four Addams Family-inspired items while Dunkin' gave a makeover to a fan favorite.
foxnews.com
Diddy Pimped Me Out as Trump and A-Listers Partied: Dancer
ReutersA former go-go dancer involved in Sean “Diddy” Combs’ alleged “freak-offs” said that Donald Trump, Diana Ross, and Paris Hilton were among the A-list celebs to attend the musician’s now-infamous parties. Adria Sheri English, 46, made the revelation in an interview with the Daily Mail on Friday, where she also alleged that she was “pimped out” by Combs and ordered to have sex with high-profile party guests—encounters she claims were secretly recorded and held by Diddy as “blackmail.”“He would send them in a room with me or another sex worker, record it, and then hold that over that celebrity or that influential person’s head and then basically use me,” she said. “It was like high-class temping, if you will.”Read more at The Daily Beast.
thedailybeast.com
Joy Behar surprised with striptease on ‘The View’ for her 82nd birthday
Behar's close friend Nathan Lane brought out a stripper dressed as a pizza delivery man during Friday's episode of the ABC talk show.
nypost.com
Elon Musk: LA residents recoil at mention of Trump's name
Elon Musk quips that people in Los Angeles have a strong negative response to the topic of former President Donald Trump.
foxnews.com
Ed Wood at 100 is no more 'the world's worst filmmaker,' plus the week's best movies
Also this week: Road movies, including 'Paper Moon,' 'It Happened One Night' and 'Two for the Road,' plus a Guy Maddin retrospective that includes his new 'Rumours.'
latimes.com
Jefferson acepta los reflectores internacionales como embajador de la NFL
Jugó fútbol con Vinícius Júnior en Brasil y recorrió la pasarela con su amigo Joe Burrow en París Ahora se dirige a Londres.
latimes.com
Luis Suárez provoca un terremoto en Uruguay con duras críticas a Bielsa de cara a nuevas fechas FIFA
Alejado de la selección de Uruguay por su retiro, el ídolo nacional Luis Suárez causó un terremoto en Uruguay tras criticar fuertemente al entrenador de la selección, el argentino Marcelo Bielsa, y el tenso ambiente que se vive en el vestuario de la Celeste por los roces entre el entrenador y jugadores.
latimes.com
Sinner confía que su caso de dopaje tendrá un resultado positivo tras apelación de la AMA
Jannik Sinner, el tenista número uno del mundo, “confía intensamente” que evitará un veto después de que la Agencia Mundial Antidopaje apeló la decisión de exonerarlo de cualquier delito después de sus dos positivos por dopaje.
latimes.com
Ex-porn star accusing Diddy of coercing her into ‘freak offs’ recalls seeing Rev. Al Sharpton, Diana Ross at rap mogul’s parties: report
A former porn star and go-go dancer who has accused Sean "Diddy" Combs of forcing her to have sex during his “freak offs” claims she saw the likes of Donald Trump, Diana Ross and Rev. Al Sharpton at his famed parties, a new report said.
nypost.com
Democrats worry about Harris' cautious media approach in tight 2024 race: 'Voters deserve better'
Democrats said in a new report they were concerned that Vice President Kamala Harris' campaign's strategy of avoiding the media could cost her the election.
foxnews.com
'More serious than we had hoped': Bird flu deaths mount among California dairy cows
Although California dairy farmers anticipated a bird flu mortality rate of less than 2%, some say between 10% and 15% of infected cattle are dying.
latimes.com
Lee Zeldin sends a crucial message to New Yorkers from the swing-state campaign trail
WAUKESHA, Wis. — Lee Zeldin may not be repping the Empire State in Congress anymore, but after zigzagging the country making swing-state stops on the Team Trump Bus Tour, he has a message for New Yorkers: Though they live in a deep-blue state, their votes will truly count this November. The ex-rep was stumping for...
nypost.com
Most New York City residents want indicted Mayor Eric Adams to resign: poll
A new Marist poll finds that a majority of New York City residents want Mayor Eric Adams to resign after his indictment on federal corruption charges.
foxnews.com
Viral ‘footprints in the sand’ optical illusion — what do you see?
“It’s so weird!” Another mind-bending image is dividing the internet. A photo of a little girl’s footprints in sand was shared online by Australian TikTokker Alice James. She claims the footprints either look like imprints or as if they’re “coming out of the sand, like 3D.” James likened the optical illusion to 2015’s infamous blue-and-black...
nypost.com
Kamala Harris boosted solar firm linked to Chinese slave labor with nearly $2B in handouts to set up Georgia plant
The Harris-Biden administration helped out a South Korean solar company whose supply chain is tied to Chinese slave labor, a list of federally sanctioned entities shows, handing out nearly $2 billion to the firm to expand its presence in Georgia. Vice President Kamala Harris, 59, visited Hanwha Qcells manufacturing plant in Dalton, Ga., in April...
nypost.com
Brutal gang attack on a small Haitian town killed at least 70 people, U.N. says
U.N. human rights office says the death toll in a brutal gang attack on Pont-Sondé, a small town in central Haiti, has risen to at least 70.
latimes.com
Bruce Springsteen endorses Harris, condemns Trump
Rock star Bruce Springsteen spoke out in a video and said Trump should be disqualified from ever being president again.
cbsnews.com
Lithium Is Making a Comeback
Of the first three elements to appear after the Big Bang, only one is available to buy as a bath soak. The Sads Smashing Anti-Stress Bath Treatment, which comes in shiny silver packaging, lists lithium as an ingredient and promises to take users “from weighed down to mellowed out.” It’s one of dozens of over-the-counter lithium supplements that claim to support a healthy mood. The metal is also an ingredient in Novos Core, a supplement marketed to “target the 12 root causes of aging,” plus in Life Extension, XtendLife, LifeLink, Youngevity, and AgeImmune. The anti-aging entrepreneur Bryan Johnson’s “Essential” multivitamin includes lithium too. “I am on a 1mg daily dose,” Johnson told me in an email.Lithium, in other words, has become firmly entrenched in the wellness industry’s extensive library of supplements. But in crucial ways, it is unlike the other trendy products that dance across your Instagram stories. At higher doses, lithium is a powerful treatment for severe mood disorders—and preliminary evidence suggests that lower doses might improve well-being for people without mood disorders too. The problem is, American companies have little business interest in finding out how effective it really is.If you put pure lithium into water, it will explode into crimson flames, but mixed with acids, lithium forms stable salts. Lithium compounds also dissolve uric acid, which doctors in the mid-1800s believed to be the cause of many illnesses. Physicians began using lithium to treat “a wide range of ailments, including headaches, diabetes, asthma, indigestion, obesity, skin disorders, rheumatism,” Walter Brown wrote in his book Lithium: A Doctor, a Drug, and a Breakthrough. By the end of the century, lithia water (water with a trace amount of lithium) was marketed as a patent medicine. (In that era, patent medicines—trademarked, proprietary cure-alls, many of which contained alcohol or opium—were a popular alternative to going to the doctor.) 7 Up was originally named Bib-Label Lithiated Lemon-Lime Soda, contained lithium citrate, and was marketed as a health tonic and hangover cure. Sears sold Schieffelin’s Effervescent Lithia Tablets, which were marketed for a variety of health concerns, including gout. Smithsonian National Museum of American History In 1949, lithium chloride, a table-salt alternative marketed to people with heart conditions, caused an outbreak of lithium poisoning in which at least two people died. The FDA, which had already started cracking down on patent medicines, quickly banned lithium in food products; later, researchers found that high doses of lithium can cause kidney failure, thyroid damage, tremors, and nausea. In 1970, the agency approved lithium carbonate for bipolar disorder; today, it’s also used off-label mostly for major depressive disorder. Then, in 1994, the FDA created the category of “dietary supplements,” which it does not evaluate, ushering lithium—mostly in the form of lithium orotate—back into a patent-medicine-like gray zone.For decades, scientists have debated whether the lithia-water craze had any truth to it—if low doses of lithium might benefit a larger population than people with mental-health conditions, maybe even everyone. Some researchers think it's worth investigating whether lithium is an essential micronutrient, like calcium or magnesium, with a recommended daily minimum of some yet-to-be-determined amount. Lithium carbonate is typically given at 600 to 900 milligrams a day for mood disorders. We get minuscule amounts of lithium from foods such as grains, potatoes, tomatoes, and cabbage. Depending on where you live and what mineral deposits are nearby, your tap water may also contain lithium. A 2024 review paper led by Allan Young, a psychiatrist at King’s College London, determined that most lithium orotate supplements on the market today contain a “micro” dose of 5 to 20 milligrams, and many have a “trace” dose of just 1 milligram. (The Sads Smashing Anti-Stress Bath Treatment contains 127 milligrams of lithium orotate, but it’s meant to be absorbed through the skin, not ingested.)[From the May 1928 issue: The secret of longevity]The effects of such low doses remain a mystery. Although a 2020 meta-analysis of studies from nine countries (including the United States) found that higher amounts of naturally occurring lithium in tap water are indeed associated with lower suicide rates, studies from places such as Switzerland and the East of England have found no association. In a 2021 study of rural Argentina, places with more lithium in their tap water had more suicides. Martin Plöderl, a co-author of the recent Switzerland study, told me that his team has found a publication bias in studies of lithium in tap water: Those with positive findings are more likely to end up in journals. Research into lithium’s effects on dementia, Alzheimer’s, and longevity has also been promising but inconclusive. A 2011 study of tap-water data from Japan found that the more lithium in the water, the longer people lived. Lithium consumption has been linked to longer life spans in flies, roundworms, and yeast, perhaps because it regulates molecules involved in metabolism and resistance to stress, Michael Ristow, a medical researcher at Charité University Medicine Berlin and co-author of the Japan study, said. A 2019 study found that bipolar-disorder patients who take lithium have longer telomeres—a proxy for lower biological age—than patients with other psychiatric disorders. And a more recent study from Japan found that people who took lithium for mood disorders had lower rates of dementia than similar patients who did not take lithium.These data are compelling enough for Ristow, who told me he takes a low dose of lithium every day. Nassir Ghaemi, a psychiatrist at Tufts University School of Medicine, did not comment on his personal use, but told me, “I think it’s beneficial in people who are middle-aged and older, who have any risk factors for dementia.” To really be sure, randomized trials in humans are needed. Because lithium is an ancient element, however, it can’t be patented—only novel inventions are available for intellectual-property protection. In order to obtain a patent, a company would have to come up with some different delivery method or other improvement. Pharmaceutical companies, which are regulated by the FDA, therefore have little reason to fund an expensive clinical trial, especially when cheap versions are already sold over the counter. But supplement companies have incentive to sell lithium OTC without conducting rigorous research on its effects. Zero clinical trials for lithium orotate are currently registered in the U.S., despite its widening market availability.Scientists don’t yet know whether lithium-orotate supplementation would yield different results than lithium in tap water. Only two studies on such supplementation have ever been conducted in humans—one from 1973 and one from 1986—and they have small sample sizes and no placebo groups. “Given lithium does work at least for preventing bipolar disorder, it’s a scandal that we don’t know how it works,” Young told me. If low-dose lithium remains akin to a patent medicine, Americans could miss out on understanding how and how well it works, and if taking it comes with any risks. In at least one case report from 2007, a woman took 18 tablets of a lithium supplement called Find Serenity Now at once and went to the hospital after vomiting. She was discharged with no other serious issues, but the risks of long-term use simply haven’t been assessed.[Read: I went to a rave with the 46-year-old millionaire who claims to have the body of a teenager]In the late 19th century, people such as Mark Twain and President Theodore Roosevelt traveled to Lithia Springs, Georgia, to drink lithium-rich water. The springs’ appeal endures: You can order water from its website, which states, “Locals have always believed Lithia Spring Water flows from the fountain of youth.” Lithium predates human life, is extracted from stone, and can have a profound impact on a person’s emotional life. No wonder it tempts our never-ending desire for some primordial cure-all, whether it be found in a groundwater spring or in our very own bathtubs.
theatlantic.com
Eric Church supports Hurricane Helene victims by donating royalties from new song: 'They’re in need'
On Friday, Eric Church shared that he will be transferring all the publishing royalties for his new song, "Darkest Hour," to the victims of Hurricane Helene.
foxnews.com
Corinne Foxx celebrated engagement in dad Jamie Foxx’s physical rehab room: ‘So intimate and meaningful’
“He planned a very special post-engagement party in my dad’s room in Chicago,” the actress said of her now-husband in a new interview with Vogue.
nypost.com
US, British forces launch airstrikes on Yemen’s Iran-backed Houthi rebels, targeting weapons systems and bases
The U.S. and British militaries struck more than a dozen Houthi targets in Yemen, going after weapons systems, bases and other equipment belonging to the Iranian-backed rebels, U.S. officials said.
1 h
nypost.com
'Being true to our inner nerd': The eye-catching lineup at L.A. Comic Con is proof of the event's growth
L.A. Comic Con's diverse lineup includes Ewan McGregor, Rosario Dawson, Michael J. Fox and ... Anjelica Huston?
1 h
latimes.com
Trump can win on these 3 key issues, Michigan voters tell Fox
Voters in the critical swing state of Michigan said that former President Donald Trump can win the state by focusing his message on the economy, inflation and jobs.
1 h
foxnews.com
‘Mean Girls’ Broadway cast throws the ‘fetchest party of the year’ in Cancun — on Oct. 3
The stars hosted a pool party at Grand Oasis Cancun's beach club and performed a cabaret-style concert at the hotel's arena in honor of "Mean Girls" Day.
1 h
nypost.com
Climate change activists ‘drown’ themselves with oil, gas and flames in nightmarish protest
The Ocean Rebellion campaigners staged the frightening demonstration on the steps of the International Maritime Organization -- the UN agency responsible for regulating maritime transport -- in London on Friday.
1 h
nypost.com
Suni Lee still fuming over Olympics feud with ex-USA teammate MyKayla Skinner
Suni Lee made it clear that MyKayla Skinner's comments stung.
1 h
nypost.com
Taiwan official warns China, Russia, Iran forming 'alliance' after Blinken says 'no axis' exists
Taiwan's new representative in the U.S. is warning about the alliance among China, Russia, Iran and North Korea.
1 h
foxnews.com
What do the cheapest tickets cost to see the Yankees-Royals in 2024 ALDS?
Some are shockingly inexpensive.
1 h
nypost.com
CNN Reporter Warns Kamala Harris Campaign Looks ‘Like a Loser’
CNN/screengrabCNN data reporter Harry Enten says that one key statistic may spell serious trouble for Vice President Kamala Harris’ presidential campaign just one month out from the election—so much so that a win would be, in his words, “historically unprecedented.”In a segment with host John Berman, Enten analyzed the polling data around the question, “Do you think the country is on the right track?” Apparently, just 28 percent of Americans think that the United States is currently headed in the right direction under its Democratic leadership.Enten said that this a problem for Harris, the party’s nominee, given that, on average, this figure sits at 42 percent in years when the incumbent party wins the presidency and just 25 percent when it loses.Read more at The Daily Beast.
1 h
thedailybeast.com
Buccaneers’ Tristan Wirfs angry over ‘TNF’ loss to Falcons: ‘We s–tted down our legs’
There are less graphic ways to describe Tampa Bay’s fourth quarter meltdown, though Wirfs certainly paints a succinct picture. 
1 h
nypost.com
How the Secret Service will secure Trump's return tomorrow to Butler, Pennsylvania
Trump is returning to Butler, Pennsylvania, tomorrow for a rally at the site of the first assassination attempt against him.
1 h
cbsnews.com
Social Security will set its 2025 COLA in days. Here's what to know.
The Social Security Administration will set its 2025 cost-of-living adjustment within days. Here's what the experts say.
1 h
cbsnews.com
An airline flagged my oversized carryon bag — but young, hot passengers with the same luggage were let on
She felt like they benefited from pretty privilege.
1 h
nypost.com
Diddy warned Justin Bieber to stay quiet about things he did with ‘big brother Puff’ in resurfaced clip: ‘He knows better’
“He’s one of the greatest kids you could ever know,” the rapper said.
1 h
nypost.com
Sabrina Carpenter blasts critics of her skimpy tour outfits: 'Don't come to the show'
Sabrina Carpenter doesn't want critics of her lingerie-inspired outfits at her concerts. The "Espresso" singer hit back at criticism while on her Short n' Sweet Tour.
1 h
foxnews.com
Beyoncé flaunts her curves in hip-hugging jeans and cropped tee and more star snaps
Beyoncé rocks a crop t-shirt, Naomi Watts puckers up with a pooch and more snaps...
1 h
nypost.com
Elon Musk’s X loses court battle with Australia over child abuse safety notice
The Federal Court has ruled X Corp has to comply with an Australian child sexual abuse transparency notice issued to the social media giant while it was still called Twitter.
1 h
nypost.com