Tools
Change country:

Why the attempt to deplatform Trump failed so utterly

Donald Trump flanked by flags and crowds, standing in front oa a giant “Trump will fix it” sign.
President-elect Donald Trump takes the stage for his last rally of the election year at Van Andel Arena on November 5, 2024, in Grand Rapids, Michigan. | Chip Somodevilla/Getty Images

The 2024 election has conclusively proven something that we really should have known since 2016: America’s gatekeepers have failed.

The premise of “gatekeeping,” as a political enterprise, is that there is a mainstream consensus that can be enforced by institutions designed to protect it. It works not by outright violent repression, but by deplatforming and shunning certain ideas, people, movements, and the like.

Gatekeeping, when successful, involves a collective of recognized authority figures declaring that something is out of bounds — and then that thing actually getting consigned to the fringes. No politician will engage with it, no talk show hosts will give it a respectful hearing, and only a tiny number of citizens will have heard of it. Think of how nearly everyone agreed, after 9/11, that conspiracy theorizing about the attack deserved scorn.

Trump’s wins are proof that gatekeeping doesn’t really work anymore. Immediately after the attack on the Capitol on January 6, 2021, there was a brief moment when leaders across the political spectrum agreed Trump was too dangerous to be allowed to remain in politics — and even tried to drive him out. In a January 8 email, Rupert Murdoch wrote that “Fox News [is] very busy pivoting … We want to make Trump a non person.” 

Yet Murdoch failed, pivoting back to pro-Trump coverage almost immediately. Every other attempt to shun Trump into political nonexistence has met with similar failure.

This isn’t just a Trump phenomenon. 

His chief allies and messengers — like Elon Musk, Joe Rogan, and Steve Bannon — have all been shunned or blacklisted to varying degrees. X/Twitter suffered a post-Musk ad revenue collapse, liberal musicians pulled their music from Spotify to pressure the streaming giant to drop Rogan, and Bannon just spent four months in federal prison (for good reason). None of these tactics have durably eroded these figures’ influence.

Nor is the failure of deplatforming even a famous person thing.

I’ve written extensively and repeatedly about the influence of obscure radicals on the mainstream Republican Party — the way that, for example, Vice President-elect JD Vance has explicitly cited someone who openly wants to topple American democracy as a key influence in his thinking about the executive branch. I’m hardly the only one: There’s a whole cottage industry of journalism devoted to tracing the linkages between the true fringe — internet weirdos with names like Bronze Age Pervert — and the Republican mainstream. 

Such links are no longer hidden, but out in the open. Yet, with a few exceptions, this kind of reporting doesn’t seem to have hurt, and it sometimes even helps the targets of the gatekeepers’ ire by raising their profiles.

Again and again, we’ve seen the gatekeepers’ efforts to deplatform their enemies into oblivion fail. And I think it has a lot to do with a mistaken analysis of power — specifically, a failure to appreciate just how much people with devoted followings can get away with in the 21st-century political-media environment.

Trumping the gatekeepers

In the past, the American mainstream consensus was enforced through bipartisan political agreement and a cultural apparatus dominated by elite institutions: a shared set of norms in those environs helping to define the rules of the political game. If you broke those rules, either by (for example) insulting the troops or particular ethnic groups, you could risk electoral defeat or even being exiled from polite public life.

Trump’s 2016 rise to power and 2024 political resurrection help us see why neither political nor cultural elites can enforce their old rules anymore.

Anyone who heads one of the two major parties already has a baseline floor of about 46 to 47 percent of the electorate. The most important voters in deciding the general election are swing voters. In a highly polarized country with two very different parties, swing voters tend to be people who definitionally don’t have very strong partisan preferences, seeing both parties as potential options. 

Candidates like Trump who enjoy unified support of a major party cannot truly be gatekept. They are definitionally part of the mainstream, and thus potentially electable thanks to the basic gravity of a two-party political system. 

All of this raises the question: How is it that Trump, an extremist, managed to seize control of the Republican Party in the first place?

For reasons I’ve documented extensively, including in my book The Reactionary Spirit, Trump managed to build a direct bond with a critical mass of GOP primary voters rooted in shared resentments and fears. These voters, like Trump and unlike Democratic partisans, were largely disdainful of any elite attempts to gatekeep him — either from the cultural mainstream or even the alternative elites of the Republican Party, which back in 2016 tried and failed to stop his initial rise in power.

In other words, Trump short-circuited the gatekeeping capacity of both the Republican Party and mainstream media.

After January 6, when some Republican elites tried again to break with Trump, they faced immense backlash from their base. Three days after his “non-person” email, Murdoch was walking things back — telling his son Lachlan that “we have to lead our viewers, which is not as easy as it might seem.” Fox’s viewers actually forced its CEO to reboard the Trump train.

So it’s Trump’s personal support, his mass following, that gives him and aligned Republicans the power to resist gatekeepers. 

The death of the old political-media order

There’s something else too. Shifts in the media landscape have allowed his allies in the cultural space to survive and even thrive for similar reasons.

In the past, it used to be hard enough to create a mass media enterprise that only a handful of people — the sorts who could operate television stations and mass newspaper distribution networks — could do it. Today, anyone can find fans on social media and work to monetize that following. Given direct access to a mass audience, unpopularity among cultural gatekeepers is far less of a concern than it used to be. 

Joe Rogan has millions of dedicated fans; those fans like him much more than the people trying to make listeners feel bad for enjoying his show. Steve Bannon’s War Room show is super popular among the Trump faithful, and remains so despite (or perhaps because of) his stint in prison. Nick Fuentes’s weird and creepy fans don’t really care if the mainstream media calls them weird and creepy for stanning a Nazi incel. All enjoy a level of influence and power because of their ties to Republicans who are unwilling to be shamed for said connections.

This fragmented landscape means there’s not enough cultural unification to ever really expel anyone from the discourse. When Fox News fired Tucker Carlson, many wondered why it took them so long: it was Fox that held the power, not its popular but increasingly difficult employee. Yet Carlson’s post-Fox trajectory — a successful turn to Twitter/X broadcasting that earned him a seat next to Trump at the Republican National Convention — reveals that even the Murdoch empire couldn’t cancel someone with Carlson’s devoted following.

Even if someone doesn’t have the personal draw of a Carlson or a Rogan, there are institutions dedicated to serving ever more extreme audiences that might be willing to hire you. If you get “canceled” at a mainstream outlet, you can go to Fox. If you get kicked off Fox News, NewsMax and One America News Network are out there waiting.

To be clear, there are benefits to the end of gatekeeping. By concentrating power in a smaller number of people and institutions, the old consensus encouraged groupthink, resulting in, for example, widespread cheerleading for the 2003 Iraq War. The era of gatekeeping was also meaningfully less democratic, in that it gave elites far more power than the people as a collective to set the terms of public debate. The creator economy, for all its faults, gives citizens the ability to financially empower voices they believe are unfairly cut out of public life. 

Yet those faults are undoubtedly immense. 

Donald Trump, a man who literally incited a riot on the Capitol and has openly vowed to attack democratic institutions in his second term, is president-elect largely — if not primarily — because he built a following that allowed him to short-circuit elite gatekeepers in both parties. And the gatekeepers, for all their flaws, adhered to basic standards of evidence and decency that simply can’t be enforced in our new political-media environment. Does anyone really think this country is better off now that someone like Fuentes has the juice to secure dinner with the once and future president?

Regardless of how you normatively evaluate these trade-offs — ones that I think point to thorny conceptual problems for liberalism itself — we need to be clear on where we’re at empirically. And the fact is that Trump and aligned Republican extremists clearly can’t be criticized into defeat. Nor can Musk be shamed into managing X more responsibly or Rogan ignored into political oblivion. 

Their opponents need a new tactic.


Read full article on: vox.com
Newly sworn-in LAPD chief sparks backlash after revealing plan to buck Trump admin on 'mass deportations'
The newly sworn in chief of the Los Angeles Police Department vowed in a hearing not to assist in mass deportations and said that Trump's election has caused 'fear.'
foxnews.com
Whoopi Goldberg claims NYC bakery ‘refused’ to make her a birthday dessert because of her ‘politics’
Goldberg celebrated her 69th birthday by indulging in some sweet treats with her "The View" co-stars.
nypost.com
Penn State York advisory board member resigns after racist road rage video
"I am racist," Spanos says as the man he was arguing with confirms, "John Spanos is a racist."
nypost.com
Man dead after suspected failed attack on Brazil Supreme Court ahead of G20
A man killed by explosions outside of Brazil's Supreme Court in Brasilia on Wednesday night is suspected to have been trying to launch an attack.
abcnews.go.com
Georgia lineman killed, another injured after workplace accident: 'Tragic passing'
Veteran lineman Eric Weems died on Wednesday after equipment failed while working on a power project in Griffin, Georgia. Another lineman was also injured.
foxnews.com
Estudio: Clima extremo influye en migración no autorizada y de retorno entre EEUU y México
En todo el mundo, el cambio climático —causado principalmente por la quema de combustibles fósiles como el carbón y el gas natural— exacerba el clima extremo.
latimes.com
México exhibe masivas detenciones como logro de plan de seguridad, pero ataques empañan política
Las autoridades mexicanas anunciaron el martes la detención de 3.015 presuntos delincuentes en las últimas cinco semanas en el marco del nuevo plan de seguridad del gobierno de Claudia Sheinbaum que se ha visto empañado por varios cruentos eventos ocurridos en diferentes puntos del país que han dejado decenas de muertos.
latimes.com
‘No eres un error’: cómo la iglesia episcopal St. James de Fresno llega a los trabajadores agrícolas LGBTQ+
La iglesia episcopal es conocida por su aceptación de las personas LGBTQ+ tal como son, y ha llevado su postura progresista a los campos.
1 h
latimes.com
Schemer dons bear costume to stage attacks on luxury cars to fool insurance companies into $141K payouts
Once upon a time in Southern California, a person wore a bear costume to damage luxury cars so friends could allegedly cash in on hefty insurance payouts.
1 h
nypost.com
The Podcast Campaign: Is it curtains for mainstream media?
Although much of this year's presidential campaign played out on TV, traditional media is being written off as old news while digital media and podcasts are the hot new players.
1 h
foxnews.com
Dear Abby: I want to charge my daughter’s dog rent
Dear Abby advises a mother who believes her children are abusing her good will.
1 h
nypost.com
Maryland mom of newborn daughter dies two days after golf cart accident
The new mom was airlifted to a hospital where she succumbed to her injuries on Monday.
2 h
nypost.com
California school parents demand district fire teacher after viral anti-Trump rant at students
Perez, who also called the 45th and future 47th president a “rapist, draft dodging coward,” was placed on administrative leave as the school district investigated his rant.
2 h
nypost.com
Florida mom sets up sting operation at local Popeye’s to catch alleged predator who was sexting her 13-year-old daughter: cops
“When you hear the shots tonight, you know what’s up.”
3 h
nypost.com
Dozens of anti-Israel protesters detained in Amsterdam after unrest over soccer match
Officials said friction had been growing in the lead-up to the soccer match, with the antisemites who led the attack calling for an organized "Jew hunt" in the city.
3 h
nypost.com
Defense leads Cleveland High to City boys' water polo open division title
The Cleveland High boys water polo team limits defending champ Palisades to one goal in final three quarters of a 15-4 victory.
3 h
latimes.com
Miami-Dade police investigating decapitated human head that washed ashore on popular South Florida beach
Miami-Dade police are investigating after a human head washed up on a popular South Florida beach behind the Key Colony II Ocean Sound condos on Tuesday morning.
3 h
foxnews.com
GOP incumbent projected to defeat Dem challenger in closely watched Arizona House race
Rep. Juan Ciscomani has been projected as the winner in the race for Arizona's 6th Congressional District, one of the most closely watched House races in the country.
3 h
foxnews.com
Canadian teen hospitalized in critical condition with deadly bird flu
Canada’s National Microbiology Lab confirmed the presumptive prognosis after testing genomic sequencing, officials said.
3 h
nypost.com
Another LeBron James triple-double leads Lakers to third win in a row
LeBron James has his third consecutive triple-double as the Lakers defeat the Memphis Grizzlies.
3 h
latimes.com
End of Knicks’ brutal loss is just beginning of this team’s story
The Knicks suffered their first heartbreaking loss of the season, a 124-123 gut punch to the Bulls that was intriguing as hell.
3 h
nypost.com
Ben Simmons misses first Nets game due to injury this season
Ben Simmons and Dorian Finney-Smith both missed Wednesday’s 139-114 loss to Boston, with Simmons needing an MRI exam on his tight left calf. 
4 h
nypost.com
Ohio Senate Passes Bill Banning Transgender People from Women's Bathrooms
The Ohio State Senate passed a bill on Wednesday that would bar transgender people from using women's bathrooms. The post Ohio Senate Passes Bill Banning Transgender People from Women’s Bathrooms appeared first on Breitbart.
4 h
breitbart.com
GREG GUTFELD: We've got one shot to save the greatest experiment in government of all time
'Gutfeld!' panelists react to the latest round of Cabinet picks in President-elect Trump's upcoming administration.
4 h
foxnews.com
St. John’s Zuby Ejiofor hopes high-energy-second half can be ‘stepping stone’ after benching
Maybe Zuby Ejiofor has begun to find his game.
4 h
nypost.com
Former Giants running back Charlie Evans dead at 76
Charlie Evans, who played in the Giants backfield in the early 1970s, died in his Texas home on Nov. 4 at 76.
4 h
nypost.com
American tourist, 60, found 'beaten to death' at 5-star hotel in Ireland frequented by celebrities
A 60-year-old American man was found "beaten to death" at Ballyfin Demesne, a luxurious five-star hotel in Ireland. Police said a suspect is in custody.
4 h
foxnews.com
11/13: CBS Evening News
Trump selects Gaetz, Gabbard to join his Cabinet; Vietnam War-era “Dustoff” crews honored with Congressional Gold Medal
4 h
cbsnews.com
Smoking pot can increase cancer risk, speed up aging — and harm your future children
"The link we’ve described between cannabis use and genotoxicity has far-reaching consequences," said study co-author Stuart Reece of the University of Western Australia.
4 h
nypost.com
Comfort and joy: God’s Love We Deliver brings meals and more to those in need
God's Love We Deliver, New York City's only nonprofit organization delivering medically tailored meals, is ramping up efforts this holiday season to provide thousands of meals to individuals with life-altering illnesses.
4 h
nypost.com
What to know about Trump's DOGE, led by Musk and Ramaswamy
Billionaires Elon Musk and Vivek Ramaswamy will head an effort, dubbed DOGE, to reduce wasteful federal spending. Here's what it's about.
4 h
cbsnews.com
Asking Eric: Husband’s bucket list plans exclude spouse
Husband’s extreme sport activities post-retirement leave out his spouse.
4 h
washingtonpost.com
Miss Manners: Friendship falls apart over hand-me-down baby clothes
A parent feels frustrated at being asked to give back baby clothes so another woman can use them as well.
4 h
washingtonpost.com
Tteokgalbi (Korean Beef Patties)
Rich and tender, Korean beef patties are easy to make at home.
4 h
washingtonpost.com
Carolyn Hax: Husband refuses to tell spouse why he’s unhappy in their marriage
When a husband won’t say what he thinks is wrong with their marriage, does his spouse wait around until he’s ready to talk?
4 h
washingtonpost.com
How India Is Embracing Trump’s Second Term
India appears to be welcoming Trump’s return to the White House, which may embolden nationalist leaders like Prime Minister Narendra Modi.
4 h
time.com
Man kills self in explosions outside Brazil's Supreme Court
The Supreme Court in recent years has become a target for threats by far-right groups and supporters of former President Jair Bolsonaro due to its crackdown on the spread of false information.
4 h
cbsnews.com
Jeremy Renner named 2024 Hollywood Christmas Parade grand marvel, er, marshal
MCU star Jeremy Renner was revealed as the grand marshal for the 2024 Hollywood Parade, nearly two years after a near-fatal accident.
4 h
latimes.com
Knicks’ Karl-Anthony Towns ‘disappointed’ in himself despite big night
Karl-Anthony Towns managed his highest scoring output of the season Wednesday night, but he remained on the court long after the Knicks’ last-second loss to the Bulls working on his game. 
4 h
nypost.com
SEAN HANNITY: Trump has a 'mandate' to restore these agencies to their former greatness
Fox News host Sean Hannity discusses President-elect Trump's big appointments for key positions as he hits the ground running.
5 h
foxnews.com
Mike Tyson-Jake Paul fight a circus full of questions — and fueled by mystery
In the penultimate month of 2024, Mike Tyson is still at the center of massive events.
5 h
nypost.com
At Black Thanksgiving, both body and soul are fed
A Thanksgiving menu that celebrates Black traditions spans the Caribbean and East Africa, with plenty of local influence.
5 h
latimes.com
Victor Wembanyama reminds the Wizards what they don’t have
The Wizards show some fight, overcoming a 16-point deficit to forge a tie in the second half, but they have no answer for the Wembanyama.
5 h
washingtonpost.com
Capitals still can’t solve the Maple Leafs in 4-3 overtime loss
The Caps looked poised to beat the Maple Leafs after losing all three meetings last season before a late third-period comeback by Toronto led to an overtime defeat.
5 h
washingtonpost.com
‘Golden Bachelorette’ Joan Vassos gets engaged to Chock Chapple with ‘show-stopping’ 4-carat diamond ring
Neil Lane said he designed the sparkler to "perfectly symbolize" the couple's "undeniable connection."
5 h
nypost.com
Sereno a sus 58 años, Mike Tyson, no cae en provocaciones de Jake Paul, 31 años menor
Mike Tyson no estaba de humor para hablar en la última conferencia de prensa antes de que el excampeón de los pesados, de 58 años, se enfrente al youtuber convertido en boxeador Jake Paul.
5 h
latimes.com
Former Jets QB Boomer Esiason offers pointed advice to Sauce Gardner after social media dispute with fans
The Jets are in the midst of another disappointing season, but a former member of Gang Green is sharing some words of wisdom with the team’s standout cornerback.
5 h
foxnews.com
Jeff Ulbrich gets back to basics trying to fix Jets’ season-long tackling problem
Jets interim coach Jeff Ulbrich is trying to tackle the team’s biggest defensive issue — tackling.
5 h
nypost.com