Tools
Change country:

Why USC canceled its pro-Palestinian valedictorian

Asna Tabassum, a graduating senior at the University of Southern California majoring in biomedical engineering, is at the center of the latest firestorm on college campuses after the university named her valedictorian, then barred her from speaking at graduation. | Genaro Molina/Los Angeles Times via Getty Images

As the school year winds down, colleges are still grappling with student speech.

Campus tensions over Israel’s war on Gaza have flared up again, this time at the University of Southern California, which this week barred its valedictorian from speaking at next month’s commencement ceremony. The school cited potential campus safety risks if Asna Tabassum delivered a speech.

Provost Andrew T. Guzman said in an email to students and staff on Monday that public discussion had “taken on an alarming tenor” after the school announced its choice for valedictorian. “The intensity of feelings, fueled by both social media and the ongoing conflict in the Middle East, has grown to include many voices outside of USC and has escalated to the point of creating substantial risks relating to security and disruption at commencement,” he wrote.

Tabassum, a South Asian American biomedical engineering major who is Muslim and wears a hijab, says that she, along with other critics of the decision, believes the school canceled her speech because of her public support for the human rights of Palestinians.

Pro-Israel USC student groups, including Trojans for Israel and the Chabad Jewish Student Center, had complained online about Tabassum’s views, calling them antisemitic. The Provost explained in the email that the decision “has nothing to do with freedom of speech” and made no mention of Tabassum’s political views. The Provost’s email did not state whether USC had already received specific threats of violence or disruption.

Since Hamas’s October 7 attack on Israel, campuses have been embroiled in controversy as student protests test the boundaries of freedom of expression. Many college and university leaders have struggled to make satisfactory public statements about the conflict and balance safety with speech protections. In the attack, Hamas killed 1,200 Israelis and took more than 200 hostage. Since then, Israel has killed 33,899 Palestinians, according to the Gaza Health Ministry.

Though schools have vowed to keep their students safe, some have reported facing violence and harassment. After failing to adequately condemn antisemitism in congressional testimony late last year, the presidents of the University of Pennsylvania and Harvard resigned. A congressional hearing on Wednesday also brought Columbia University’s president before lawmakers to answer questions about the school’s response to antisemitism, showing that the quandary is far from over.

The USC Provost referenced the broader turmoil on US campuses in his email: “We cannot ignore the fact that similar risks have led to harassment and even violence at other campuses.”

Pro-Israel groups are celebrating USC’s decision, claiming that Tabassum’s speech, which she said she had not yet written, could have made Jewish students feel uncomfortable. Tabassum told Inside Edition that she hoped to share a message of hope in her speech.

Meanwhile, critics say that it undermines free speech and is a signal that universities are caving to pro-Israel pressures. “USC cannot hide its cowardly decision behind a disingenuous concern for ‘security,” said Hussam Ayloush, the executive director of the Council on American-Islamic Relations Los Angeles. “The university can, should and must ensure a safe environment for graduation rather than taking the unprecedented step of canceling a valedictorian’s speech.” Student groups and outlets including the LA Times and the Guardian have defended Tabassum and condemned USC.

As the academic year comes to a close, the country is watching how similar situations might unfold on other campuses. It’s customary for students to make political statements during commencement speeches, but this year’s campus controversies could lead schools to keep buckling under pressure, raising concerns about students’ freedom of expression in the process.

USC chose its valedictorian — then silenced her

USC announced that Tabassum would be the university’s valedictorian on April 2, based on her grade point average, which topped 3.98, contributions to the campus community, essay submission, and performance in interviews. Tabassum, who also minors in resistance to genocide — studies about conflicts including the war in Ukraine, genocide in Darfur, and the Holocaust — was selected from more than 200 students who qualified for the award, and was slated to deliver the customary valedictory speech at the May 10 commencement. Then, Tabassum was notified that she wouldn’t deliver the address at commencement after all because of safety concerns. Critics began to speculate that USC was kowtowing to pro-Israel groups and people who complained about Tabassum being selected as valedictorian.

The right-wing pro-Israel organization organization End Jew Hatred welcomed USC’s decision stating, “Ms. Tabassum’s speech as valedictorian was anticipated to be harmful to Jewish students and even potentially agitate anti-Jewish activists.” The USC campus group the Trojans for Israel wrote that Tabassum “openly traffics in antisemitic and anti-Zionist rhetoric.”

Tabassum told CNN that she received “hate and vitriol” for including a link to the website “Free-Palestine.Carrd.Co” on her Instagram profile. The homepage of the website contains the image of a woman holding up a Palestinian flag and a peace sign rising above flames and smoke, and links to help visitors “learn about what’s happening in Palestine.”

USC’s Chabad argued that the linked website called for the “abolishment of the state of Israel” and called the words on the website, which Tabassum did not create, “antisemitic and hate speech.”

Tabassum said in a statement that she believes there was a “campaign” of “racist hatred” on the part of “anti-Muslim and anti-Palestinian voices” to prevent her from addressing her peers at commencement due to her “uncompromising belief in human rights for all.”

“I am not surprised by those who attempt to propagate hatred. I am surprised that my own university—my home for four years—has abandoned me,” Tabassum said, adding that the school denied her request for more information about their threat assessment.

Pro-Palestinian students and groups such as Students for Justice in Palestine and Jewish Voice for Peace have faced discipline, sanctions, and campus suspensions and bans over protest activity since October 7 — part of a long history silencing student activism for Palestine. Meanwhile, students advocating for Palestine have been labeled antisemitic for chanting phrases such as “From the river to the sea, Palestine will be free” and “globalize the intifada.” Student protesters say the phrases don’t advocate for harm to Israelis, while critics say the phrases are threatening and call for violence.

School leadership has often said the groups were reprimanded for violating school policies amid a rise in antisemitism and anti-Muslim sentiment on campus. On Thursday, police in riot gear arrested more than 100 pro-Palestinian Columbia students at President Minouche Shafik’s direction, while administrators suspended three Barnard students, including, Isra Hirsi, the daughter of Minnesota Rep. Ilhan Omar (D), for setting up “unauthorized” protest encampments on campus.

USC has not responded to requests for further information about any specific threats to Tabassum or anyone else in the USC community. USC has not yet responded to Vox’s request for comment.

“If anti-Palestinian groups are threatening violence, then USC needs to say what they’ve threatened and why it is so dangerous that it has led to such a drastic action, instead of disingenuously claiming that it isn’t engaging in censorship,” said Radhika Sainath, an attorney at Palestine Legal, an organization that defends people who speak out in support of Palestine.

“The fact that Palestinians and their allies are being punished and canceled in this way — while Israel is committing an ongoing genocide in Gaza — speaks to the McCarthyite moment we’re in.”

USC’s decision raises questions about free speech on campus

USC is a private school that makes First Amendment-like free speech promises, Alex Morey, an attorney at Foundation Individual Right and Expression, an organization that advocates for free speech, told Vox. The school is also required to provide students First Amendment rights in certain situations under California’s Leonard Law, a 1992 statute that extended free speech protections to students at private colleges and universities in the state. The school’s decision to cancel Tabassum's speech, Morey said, “does implicate campus expression in an important way.”

“For those of us watching the campus speech space on the regular, canceling controversial speeches or events due to vague, unspecified ‘safety concerns’ is one of the oldest tricks in the book,” Morey said. “USC appears to have made a calculated move that this was the way to avoid the most criticism. Yanking the student’s valedictorian status or canceling the speech for viewpoint-based reasons, would have pleased the students’ critics but angered her supporters. By citing ‘safety’ however, USC’s doing their best to look like the good guy and suggest this isn’t about viewpoint at all.”

Morey told Vox the school should have done everything in its power to ensure that the event would go on, and that if threats remained, it should have been transparent about what those threats are.

If USC did in fact cancel the speech due to pressure from pro-Israel critics, now they know “that with the right amount of pressure, they can silence certain views at USC,” Morey said.

The USC decision has also introduced bigger questions about whether students who have publicly expressed any views on Palestine or Israel will be passed over for honors in the future. These decisions might lead students to self-censor.

“If USC will only honor students with certain views, are they really living up to their lofty free expression promises?” Morey said.

Ironically, Morey pointed out, Tabassum minored in “resistance to genocide” and is effectively getting dinged for saying “precisely the kind of things you’d imagine one would hear in Resistance to Genocide 101 at a school like USC.”


Read full article on: vox.com
Knicks compare Jalen Brunson’s late-game heroics to Damian Lillard
In the biggest spots and most pressurized moments, Josh Hart has full faith in Jalen Brunson. 
nypost.com
Girl, 17, trafficked into US by Mexican national rescued after texting 911, relaying landmarks to authorities
Deputies began scouring the area as the call taker continued to text back and forth of the victim, the law enforcement agency said.
nypost.com
Dodgers look flat on Shohei Ohtani bobblehead night
Dodgers lose their second in a row, managing only four singles against a struggling Cincinnati Reds team.
latimes.com
5-year-old dead after being strangled by backyard swing in freak accident
“She pulled her little plastic slide over to where her swing was. And somehow got caught up in the swing, and the swing strangled her.”
nypost.com
Chris Kreider ended Rangers’ power-play drought at perfect time
Highlights from the Rangers' 5-3 Game 6 win over the Hurricanes on Friday night to advance to the Easter Conference Final.
nypost.com
Physically healthy Dutch woman Zoraya ter Beek, 29, granted euthanasia approval over her severe depression
“I feel relief. It’s been such a long fight.”
nypost.com
Trump will campaign in Minnesota after attending his son Barron's graduation
Former President Donald Trump’s break from his hush money trial in New York includes a trip to Minnesota for a Republican fundraiser in a traditionally Democratic state that he boasts he can carry in November
abcnews.go.com
‘A Gentleman in Moscow’ Finale Will Make You Cry, if Only for a Moment
Ben Blackall/Paramount+ with SHOWTIMEWe’ve reached the end of A Gentleman in Moscow, but we can’t wrap things up without one final escapade for Alexander (Ewan McGregor), Anna (Mary Elizabeth Winstead), and Sofia (Beau Gadsdon). Before the finale wraps, they’ll need to become spies for the American government—this way, Sofia will have a ticket out
thedailybeast.com
Mets ace Kodai Senga ‘making some strides’ during injury recovery
Mets officials have begun to receive a positive vibe about Kodai Senga’s rehab.
nypost.com
PGA Championship odds: A new leader at the top after Round 1
Round 1 of the PGA Championship is in the books, and there's a new favorite at the top of the odds board.
nypost.com
Chris Kreider adds another signature playoff moment to storied Rangers career
The narrative was threatening to overwhelm the Rangers. But the narrative was never really about this team and its Game 4 and Game 5 defeats. 
nypost.com
Bus rider fatally shot amid spate of violence on L.A. Metro
A Metro passenger was fatally shot on a bus Thursday afternoon in Commerce hours after Mayor Karen Bass ordered a 'surge' in law enforcement on the system's trains and buses.
latimes.com
GREG GUTFELD: Don't expect a 'fair fight' in Trump-Biden debates, it's 'not part of the Democrat playbook'
Fox News host Greg Gutfeld argues there are "other tricks in the works" to explain President Biden's plans to debate former President Trump on "Gutfeld!"
foxnews.com
A New Lawsuit Accuses Spotify of Cheating Songwriters Out of Royalties
Spotify allegedly used a legalistic word change to justify slicing royalties to musicians and publishers, reducing the revenue on which royalties are based by almost 50%.
time.com
House hearing on Garland devolves into chaos involving AOC, MTG & Crockett: ‘Are your feelings hurt? Aww’
“I think you know what you’re here for,” Greene shot back. “I think your fake eyelashes are messing up what you’re reading.” 
nypost.com
Sports Illustrated Swimsuit 2024 Issue Release: see the stars
The event also celebrated the magazine's 60th anniversary.
nypost.com
Mets’ Edwin Diaz won’t use being out for year as reason for closing woes
It took 17 games this season for Mets closer Edwin Diaz to allow his ninth run and blow his third save, a far cry from his magical 2022 season.
nypost.com
House Oversight Committee Hearing Goes Totally Off the Rails Thanks to MTG
TwitterA House Oversight Committee hearing—which was supposed to be cover contempt proceedings for Attorney General Merrick Garland on Thursday night—quickly devolved into chaos after repeated interruptions from a certain far-right representative from Georgia.The meeting, originally intended to advance a measure to hold Garland in contempt for refu
thedailybeast.com
Rangers’ Chris Kreider gave teammates third-period guarantee before hat trick
Chris Kreider told teammates within earshot that he was going to score before they took the ice Thursday for the third period of Game 6.
nypost.com
Alleged arsonist, 26, set NY state trooper’s childhood home on fire over traffic tickets
Williams had searched online for personal information about the trooper who gave him traffic tickets, including his address, before the house fire, according to the DA.
nypost.com
At Least 12 Arrested at U.C. Berkeley After Police Order Protesters to Disperse
The authorities had given demonstrators until 7 p.m. to vacate a new encampment that had been erected at a fire-damaged complex on campus.
nytimes.com
Congress Suddenly Erupts Into Chaos Amid Hearing
Lawmakers took shots at one another's appearance during a House Oversight Committee hearing Thursday.
newsweek.com
Houston metro rocked by severe storms that left 4 dead and over 1 million without power
During the height of the severe weather, utility companies that service the Houston metro reported that nearly 1 million customers were without power.
nypost.com
4 dead as storms slam Houston again; nearly 1 million customers without power
The Houston Mayor's Office confirmed to CBS News that there were at least four weather-related deaths from the storms.
cbsnews.com
5/16: CBS Evening News
Morehouse College prepares for possible disruptions ahead of Biden's commencement address; Oncology nurse faces down her own cancer diagnosis with courage
cbsnews.com
Rangers refused to panic while staring down past demons: ‘It was calm’
This was a referendum on the culture built not just by Peter Laviolette but by the guys who were here before him.
nypost.com
Archaeologists Reveal Iron Age Building Destroyed by 'Violent' Fire
Around 2,200 years ago, a fire ravaged an Iron Age settlement, preserving remains that shed light on the life of the community.
newsweek.com
Billie Eilish is a master of deception on mind-blowing new album ‘Hit Me Hard and Soft’: review
The critical darling's sonic sleight of hand comes to play throughout her latest record, on which she contorts herself to toy with diverse genres and tempos.
nypost.com
Ask Amy: Retired couple misses social activities since the pandemic
A retired couple has seen their social life dwindle as many of the activities they used to participate in have been shut down.
washingtonpost.com
Miss Manners: Longtime friends lose minds over canceled dinner plans
A couple canceled dinner plans with old friends a month ago. Their friends are still fuming.
washingtonpost.com
Carolyn Hax: After holiday meals, guests rush the kitchen to claim the leftovers
When fellow guests rush the leftovers after big family holiday gatherings, is it okay to speak up on behalf of the hosts?
washingtonpost.com
How Rich Candidates Burned Cash on Running for Office
It is a time-honored tradition in U.S. politics: wealthy people burning through their fortunes to ultimately lose an election.
nytimes.com
Elle King sobbed after drunken Dolly Parton birthday tribute performance, admits ‘I was mortified’
Elle King spoke out for the first time about her drunken performance during Dolly Parton's 78th birthday celebration at Nashville's Grand Ole Opry in January.
nypost.com
At Least Four Dead as Storms Batter Houston Area
Buildings were damaged in Houston and school officials canceled classes in the city on Friday, citing the destruction. It may take the city as much as 48 hours to restore power to some customers.
nytimes.com
Hurricanes coach accuses Rangers’ Mika Zibanejad of selling crucial penalty: ‘Lot of extra’
Minutes after his team’s season ended, Carolina coach Rod Brind’Amour expressed his displeasure with the call that led to the Rangers’ tying goal in their comeback victory Thursday night. 
nypost.com
Missouri Attorney General Accuses Local Government of Doxxing Chiefs Kicker
David Eulitt/Getty ImagesMissouri’s top prosecutor is baying for justice after accusing Kansas City of having “doxxed” Harrison Butker, the Chiefs kicker who has come under fire in recent days for a controversial commencement speech in which he urged women to get back in the kitchen.State Attorney General Andrew Bailey said his office was “demandin
thedailybeast.com
Rangers fans raucously celebrate inside — and outside — the Garden after Game 6 thriller
The Rangers huge Game 6 series-clinching win over the Hurricanes in Game 6 came on the road, but that didn't mean Madison Square Garden was silent.
nypost.com
Christopher Gregor, NJ dad accused of son’s treadmill death, tried to coach his mother’s testimony
In the recorded jailhouse call, both Gregor's parents were heard repeatedly telling their son to stop talking.
nypost.com
‘Summer House’ star West Wilson says Jesse Solomon and Danielle Olivera had sexual tension
"I think Danielle would f--k Jessie in two seconds," Wilson said during Page Six's "Virtual Reali-Tea" live taping Thursday.
nypost.com
Kevin Spacey Breaks Cover to Do First U.S. TV Interview in Seven Years
NewsNationKevin Spacey sat for his first U.S. television interview in seven years on Thursday, telling NewsNation’s Chris Cuomo that he is eager to “get back to work” in show business after a series of sexual misconduct accusations derailed his career.When asked by the Cuomo host about some of Spacey’s peers in the industry—like Liam Neeson and Sha
thedailybeast.com
May 16, 2024 Israel-Hamas war
Israel called South Africa the "legal arm" of Hamas on Thursday after it accused Israeli forces, in remarks at the International Court of Justice, of failing to protect civilians in the southern Gaza city of Rafah.
edition.cnn.com
Chiefs’ Harrison Butker jersey ranked among NFL’s bestsellers after kicker’s faith-based commencement address
Kansas City Chiefs kicker Harrison Butker's commencement address at a private Catholic liberal arts school in Kansas over the weekend has drawn strong reaction.
nypost.com
Deadly Storm Ravages South Texas: Everything We Know
Southern Texas was pummeled by a violent storm on Thursday, knocking out power for nearly 1 million residents.
newsweek.com
UPS driver fatally shot while sitting in parked van, Irvine police say
The Irvine Police Department said that a man was shot near Chrysler and Bendix streets around 3 p.m. Thursday.
latimes.com
New Hampshire daycare workers sprinkled melatonin in children’s food unbeknownst to parents, police say
The owner of an in-home daycare in New Hampshire and three of her employees are facing charges after they allegedly served melatonin to children without parents’ knowledge and consent
foxnews.com
Rangers become first Presidents’ Trophy winner in nearly a decade to make conference final
The Rangers are the first team to advance to the Conference Finals after winning the President's Trophy in nine years.
nypost.com
Donovan Mitchell shoots down reported Cavaliers discontent: ‘Sick of y’all’
Donovan Mitchell is trying to put an end to the rumors about his happiness in Cleveland. 
nypost.com
Seth Meyers Revels in Lauren Boebert’s Courthouse Humiliation
NBCFormer president Donald Trump is not allowed to publicly complain about his ongoing trial without risking a gag order violation, so Rep. Lauren Boebert (R-CO) and a clown car of Republican suck-ups flew to Manhattan Thursday to aid his defense.After sitting through hours of the proceedings, she attempted to give an impassioned speech outside the
thedailybeast.com